The movie was simply too gay.
That's why director Steven Soderbergh says Behind the Candelabra, his latest (and possibly last) film, was not shown in American theaters. When the major Hollywood studios declined to pick up the biopic—which stars Michael Douglas as the famous Vegas showman Liberace and Matt Damon as Scott Thorson, his much younger boyfriend—HBO snapped it up. The film premiered on the cable network last month to critical acclaim.
Two weeks ago, after I published a review of Behind the Candelabra that highlighted Soderbergh's claim that the movie was too gay for Hollywood, I started receiving messages from Hollywood insiders who said Soderbergh was lying. Some claimed that Soderbergh had never pitched his Liberace project to their studio. Others, including Mark Fritz, a director of theatrical sales and distribution for Warner Brothers International, objected to the charge that the film was rejected by major studios because it was too gay. "Sorry, but it is completely untrue that this film was deemed 'too gay' by Hollywood," Fritz tweeted in response to my review. Fritz also dismissed Soderbergh's claim as tantamount to absurd "conspiracy theories." Warner Brothers had originally developed the film in 2008 and 2009. (UPDATE: In an email sent after this story was published, Fritz said that he was not referring specifically to Soderbergh's statement when he mentioned "conspiracy theories." He said that "Warner Bros. celebrates and espouses diversity in all its forms," and that he "has the utmost respect for both Soderbergh and Behind the Candelabra.")
After hearing about the pushback, Soderbergh himself got in touch with me to set the record straight. He kicked off our chat with a sarcasm-drenched tirade, describing an alternate reality in which the Hollywood version of why Behind the Candelabra didn't get picked up might be believable:
"I usually let this stuff slide, but this just sounded too fascinating to let drop."
"I usually let this stuff slide, but this just sounded too fascinating to let drop," Soderbergh tells Mother Jones. "Since I'm a big fan of conspiracy theories, I propose a counter conspiracy theory: Warner Brothers never developed [the script for Behind the Candelabra] and didn't…put it into turn around. [Producer] Jerry Weintraub did not spend six months working with a woman named Cathy Morgan to sell territories all over the world with contractual contingencies that these deals would be voided if we didn't have a domestic partner…I never had a conversation that the economics would not work because the audience [for this film] was too limited. Everybody in town was not aware that this project was available, despite the big names attached. And we never wanted to make this a theatrical release because I never wanted [Matt Damon and Michael Douglas] to be eligible for Academy Awards. That's my counter conspiracy theory, and your readers can decide which of these two theories is more plausible."
[Read the full article]