Erik Kain

Erik Kain writes about politics at The League of Ordinary Gentlemen, and technology and video games at Forbes. His work has also appeared in The Atlantic and elsewhere. For smaller doses, you can follow him on Twitter.

Get my RSS |

The NRA's Anti-Obama Ad Is Not Only Tasteless But Also Totally Unrealistic

| Wed Jan. 16, 2013 3:09 PM PST

Some people are calling the NRA's new anti-Obama ad a thinly veiled threat against the president's children. I doubt that this was its intent, but nonetheless, it's well beyond poor taste to use Obama's kids to make a point. (And it's absurd on its face: Like Jenna and Barbara Bush before them, Sasha and Malia get protection at school, as do all US presidents' children. It's called the Secret Service.) Between this and the Shooting Range app recently released by the NRA on iOS devices, the lobbying group's public-relations wing is failing miserably.

Now let's take a look at the substance of the ad itself: The NRA wants to staff every school in America with armed guards, and the president is "an elitist hypocrite" for being skeptical of the idea.

According to the National Center for Education Statistics, in 2009-10 there were 98,817 public schools, 33,366 private schools, and 6,742 two-year and four-year colleges in America. Assuming that many of the colleges and at least some of the schools already have security and that private schools would require private funding for private security, that still leaves somewhere in the neighborhood of 100,000 schools with no armed security staff.

Hiring an armed guard for each of these would be enormously expensive, especially since these guards would need extensive background checks and would require expensive equipment and training, as well as benefits, pensions, and so forth. While many Americans have indeed expressed support for this sort of measure in recent polling, the public often supports expensive plans with little attention to the cost.

With its argument for getting rid of all "gun-free zones" in the country—which relies on fallacy rather than real data—the NRA has also recommended staffing these 100,000 public schools with armed volunteers: Retired police officers or ex-military types who would bring their guns to schools across the country each day—vigilantes of a sort, with the power of life and death just a trigger finger away.

Of course, assuming we could rally 100,000 full-time volunteer guards (or many more part-time guards) and then vet each of them properly, one has to ask whether we'd trust our nations' children in their hands. Would these retirees themselves pose some possible danger? Would they be able to stop a shooter should one attack? The armed security at Columbine and Virginia Tech proved incapable of stopping those mass shootings, and shooting rampages have rarely if ever been stopped this way.

Advertise on MotherJones.com

Glenn Beck's Fake City Is a Sign of Tea Party Irrelevance

| Tue Jan. 15, 2013 4:01 AM PST
Glenn Beck wants to build his own theme park: Independence, USA.

Glenn Beck may not be a Fox News contributor anymore, but he's not content to be just another talking head on the AM dial either.

Beck, whose anti-Obama rhetoric leading up to the 2008 election landed him a job on Fox, and whose tearful pleas to Americans helped invigorate the Tea Party, isn't stopping at punditry. As MoJo's Tim Murphy reported last Friday, it appears the new gold-standard of conservative punditry is building your very own city-theme park hybrid, where Americans can learn all the values that make this country great except, one imagines, the value of organic communities.

Beck's grand planned commmunity will be called Independence, USA (if it's ever built) which is not quite as catchy as Freedom, USA, or America, USA, but we won't dock points for lack of creativity just yet.

Honestly, while this may be even sillier than the Free State Project, which was pretty unbelievably silly, the fact is Glenn Beck is in the news again after a long dry spell. That we're talking about him at all may mean he's already won this small battle. Like Sarah Palin before him, Beck is doing whatever he can to remain relevant in a post-Tea Party political climate.

Indeed, it's not looking good for the tri-corner hat industry. According to Rasmussen, only 8 percent of voters self-identify as Tea Party members now, down from a high of 24 percent in April 2010. Meanwhile 49 percent of voters view the Tea Party unfavorably, compared to a 30 percent favorability rating. And this is from Rasmussen, a polling outfit not exactly harsh on conservatives.

That's why Beck's latest scheme may have more relvelance than its pure entertainment value: It's a sign that the Tea Party is beginning to fade and the pundits who used to sing its praises are showing just how desparate they've become. When even Ann Coulter is chastising her fellow commentators about the rules of defeat, you know something is seriously shaky inside the far-right GOP's house of cards.

Meanwhile, powerful financiers at the RNC are starting to worry about the direction the party has taken, and popular Republican governors like Chris Christie are speaking out about the absurd failings of leadership in the Republican-controlled House. Beck's Independence project may be a joke, but it's just one more sign that the far right is in big trouble.

For my part, I say we encourage Beck to build it (thus fulfilling his desire for freedom) and then let him secede from the Union (allowing him to scratch that independence itch.) I could think of a worse fate for America than a few of our louder and more ridiculous pundits going Galt.

Joe Scarborough Says the Sandy Hook Massacre "Changed Everything"

| Mon Dec. 17, 2012 2:48 PM PST

Today on MSNBC's Morning Joe, former Republican congressman Joe Scarborough came out forcefully against the gun lobby, saying that Friday's horrifying shooting in Connecticut changes everything including his past views on gun control.

Scarborough said that while he once viewed gun control as a "powerful, symbolic" struggle between big government and individual rights. Now he sees the issue as a matter of public safety.

"The ideologies of my past career are no longer relevant to the future that I want, to the future that I demand for my children, " Scarborough said in his eight-minute monologue on the tragedy.

When Republicans Love Legalized Pot

| Thu Dec. 13, 2012 4:03 AM PST
Republicans and marijuana

Indiana Gov. Mitch Daniels told National Review that he believes federalism "is, first and foremost, a protection of liberty" and that, without specifically endorsing the legalization of marijuana, he believes Washington and Colorado "under our system, had a right to do it."

This is federalism in action, according to the Republican governor. "A lot of the worst problems we've got in this country, and some of the worst divisions we have, came when the right of citizens in community and in politics, like their state, had those rights usurped by the federal government," Daniels said. "And having disagreed with it when it happened on other occasions, I sure wouldn't call for it here."

Now, I won't come right out and say that federalism is an inherently bad thing. After all, I'd rather see the war on drugs suffer a setback on a state-by-state level than not at all. Still, I can't help but be reminded of the many ways that so-called "states' rights" federalism has been used to strip away much more fundamental human rights. This includes the fact that someone in Indiana today would still face a far harsher penalty under current drug laws than Daniels faced when he was busted for possession as a young man.

Indeed, federalism is a double-edged sword, and as the saying goes, it can cut both ways. And more often than not it has been damaging to the nation.

Do We Really Need to Start the 2016 Election Already?

| Wed Dec. 5, 2012 10:47 AM PST

Memeorandum

The political media is at it again, attempting to convince the general public that the just-finished 2012 presidential election was little more than the first course in a much longer and more grueling meal.

Scanning the top headlines at political punditry aggregator Memeorandum, you might hazard a guess or two about the state of politics this post-election season.

First, you might surmise that all this talk of Hillary Clinton being at the top of the 2016 food chain and the repetition of the names "Rubio" and "Ryan" adjacent to one another in headline after headline, indicates that the media is already circling the wagons around their favorite candidates.

Second, you might guess that this means there's a deficit of current news to keep the fires burning.

Tue Apr. 30, 2013 12:57 PM PDT
Tue Feb. 12, 2013 5:21 AM PST
Thu Dec. 13, 2012 4:03 AM PST
Mon Nov. 5, 2012 4:20 PM PST
Fri Jun. 1, 2012 3:20 AM PDT
Fri Jun. 1, 2012 3:00 AM PDT
Thu May. 31, 2012 3:35 PM PDT
Thu May. 31, 2012 1:33 PM PDT
Thu May. 31, 2012 12:51 PM PDT
Tue May. 29, 2012 3:27 PM PDT
Tue May. 29, 2012 12:24 PM PDT