«--Previous Post | Blog Index | Next Post--»
Does Eco-Tourism Encourage Child Labor?
There may be no way to travel guilt-free.
For a while, carbon offsets looked promising—we were told (and we told ourselves) that by paying a little extra, we could make it as if our long-haul flights never happened at all! Well, as it turns out, not quite.
The latest bad news about carbon offsets: In some cases, child laborers may be paying for our supposedly ethically sound vacations. Climate Care, a British company that finances sustainable projects in the developing world, is at the center of the scandal:
Climate Care uses the money to help persuade families...to give up labour-saving diesel pumps and buy human-powered treadles instead. It claims that by using the treadle, a family will save money on diesel and hire charges, earn more from increased crops and cut the carbon emissions that would have been produced by the pump.
And in many of these families, the human that powers the treadle is a child (the London Times found a family who, because of financial circumstances, had a six-year-old child working half-hour shifts on the treadle).
So much for guilt-free.
Comments
Eco-Tourism is an oxymoron!
[cf., healthy smoking; environmentally-friendly SUV; safe cancer...]
edro,
Eco-tourism is not an oxymoron. It has real meaning. It is NOT zero impact. Eco-tourism provides an economic reason for preserving areas of high biodiversity. Even hiking on local trails has some impact. However, let's not throw out a concept that has real value.
As for promotion of child labor, I would say that we need to simply put pressure on the various organizations to ensure that their projects have greater validity than simply stopping a diesel generator. We need to ensure that a power source is replaced with a renewable source, not simply replaced with kids on treadles. This should not be that difficult.
Posted by: Misanthropic Scott on 09/25/07 at 12:10 PM Respond
Scott
EDRO posted a new message on eco-tourism at
http://feww.wordpress.com/
Posted by: FEWW on 09/28/07 at 6:02 PM Respond
ARCHIVE
RECENT COMMENTS
Snake Sidewinds Energy from the Sea (2)
Trollstein wrote:
Energy is the single most powerful commodity on Earth.
We ...
[more]
Farms Kill Frogs (3)
cover me with blanket wrote:
This is hardly a subject to laugh about. It is frightenin...
[more]
Why Miles Per Gallon Suck (3)
Nancy wrote:
I seem to remember that the "Car Talk" brothers had a simi...
[more]
Making Fake Stuff Look More Real (2)
Fair Trade wrote:
The people dumb enough to still think it's acceptable to b...
[more]
Clean Energy Leaps Forward (1)
Patrick wrote:
The exponential growth of green industry investment makes ...
[more]
Forecast for Solar: Cloudy (4)
breezi wrote:
First of all, other countries (e.g.,Germany) are years ahe...
[more]
Everglades Wins Big (10)
breezi wrote:
Lantern Bearer is so right. And, although I know it's ton...
[more]
Scientist on Warming: "We're Toast" (2)
Jill wrote:
Hanson is a false prophet, just like Al Gore who is such a...
[more]
Prescription Drugs Are in our Drinking Water: What to do Now? (5)
Ally wrote:
So drinking water can cause you to finally end up with an ...
[more]
Bush Administration to California: Eff You (2)
treehugger wrote:
Jeez, the things people talk about while out duck hunting....
[more]
Movable Type 3.33


Posted by: edro on 09/25/07 at 3:20 AM Respond