My Trash's Afterlife (Parts 1, 2, and 3)
Was I wrong to recycle the junk-mail envelopes with plastic windows? Won’t the "Two Buck Chuck" bottle just shatter? A guided tour of trash heaven.
Part 1: In which our intrepid reporter sets off on a trash odyssey and learns that he's been throwing out his garbage all wrong. [Read Part 2 and Part 3.]
Step 1: The Big Sort
In the best of ways, San Francisco is king of the trash heap. While the average American annually discards more than 1,100 pounds of garbage, the typical resident of the city by the bay trashes 882 pounds, thanks to a Herculean recycling program that recovers nearly half of everything that gets tossed. No major American city recycles more. I wanted to know why. It certainly wasn't because of me.
To find out whether my city's phenomenal recycling success was actually real, I asked San Francisco's waste contractor, Sunset Scavenger, if I could track one week's worth of my own trash in real time. It agreed, and so began my odyssey into a world of waste.
In addition to curbside pickup, Sunset Scavenger offers 11 other recycling services, everything from free "bulky item" pickup to a 16-year-old construction debris program that accounts for roughly 30 percent of everything the company recycles. These programs are supplemented by other independent recycling services that trade in everything from glass bottles to used asphalt. Factoring them all in, San Francisco calculates that 72 percent of its waste is diverted from the landfill. To reflect this focus on waste diversion, Sunset Scavenger's parent company recently changed its name from Norcal Waste Systems to Recology.
Could other cities follow in San Francisco's footsteps? Sunset Scavenger picks up recycling and compost for free but charges $24.75 per month to empty a large residential trash bin. That beats Los Angeles but not my previous hometown, anti-recycling Houston, where free garbage pickup (funded by local taxes) makes tossing things disturbingly easy. Sunset spokesman Robert Reed thinks his company's rates are a bargain when weighed against the environmental costs of throwing out energy-intensive products and methane-spewing organic wastes. And he attributes the company's success less to the collection rate it charges than San Franciscans' stellar job of sorting their trash.
Not that I'd been obsessing over my garbage. Tall and lean with the short-cropped hair and intense stare of a drill sergeant, Reed informed me that I'd been living in the recycling Dark Ages. Though the recycling bins in my apartment building were still labeled "bottles and cans" and "paper and cardboard," I no longer needed to sort things this way. Back in 2001, Sunset Scavenger switched to "single stream" recycling. Handling my recyclables had just gotten a lot easier, but I wondered if single stream was all it was cracked up to be.
Of course, the tradeoff for not parsing my cans and papers was that I was now strongly encouraged to separate out my food waste and put it in a compost bin. When I'd first called Reed, he'd berated me for not owning one. "About a quarter of the apartments in San Francisco have these," he barked. "It's kind of hard to do that story if you don't have the green bin!" I felt like a kid who'd spent all night on the wrong homework assignment, though really, the decision not to order a green bin had been my landlord's. I told Reed I'd convince him to have one delivered.
The night before my trash-tracking trek, I dumped the contents of my garbage can and recycling bin onto the kitchen floor to see what I'd be following: One bottle of "Two Buck Chuck" cabernet sauvignon, an unusually large paper egg carton, a Nine Whole Grain Crunch cereal box, and a couple of pounds of cat shit tied up in a Chinese take-out bag that said "Have a Nice Day."
Imagining how Reed might further trash my recycling skills the next morning, I agonized over sorting. Should I recycle a piece of aluminum foil slathered in cherry pie filling? Or the junk-mail envelopes with plastic windows? Should I bother to fish out that plastic tub of skin cream that my wife had thrown away?
Step 2: Pickup Artists
At seven the next morning, Reed showed up outside my apartment in San Francisco's Inner Richmond neighborhood. He opened my building's big, black communal garbage bin and immediately spotted the plastic skin-cream container. I blamed my wife, but he'd already moved on to more contraband tossed by my neighbors. "Here's a newspaper," he said. Then he held up an envelope and proclaimed, "This is junk mail." I noted its plastic window. "That's okay, we can handle that," he grunted, throwing everything into a recycling bin.
"You've got big garbage cans and a small green bin," he said, sounding agitated. "Shouldn't it be the other way? Shouldn't you have small black, big green?" He grabbed a paint can out of the trash, mumbled "What the hell?" and began pulling wads of paint-covered masking tape out of it. Tossing the can into the recycling bin, he explained that any extra paint could be dropped off at the dump's paint recycling center, which remixes it and donates it to communities in Zambia, Mali, and Tonga. Next, he unwrapped a clump of foil containing a half-eaten sausage and threw the foil in the recycling and sausage in the compost. I mentioned the cherry-pie-covered foil that I'd thrown away. "Just give it a little rinse," he advised. "These are simple things. This isn't rocket science."
Reed went to wash his hands just as my garbage collector, Eric Pike, pulled up in his truck, which he calls the "Big Pig." He wheeled my building's recycling and trash bins up to its side, where a mechanical arm hoisted them up one by one and rattled out their contents. Chutes inside the truck routed the loads into two separate compartments.
Two dirty pillows jutted from one of the recycling bins next door. Pike fished them out with a hook, tossed them in the truck's garbage compartment, and stuck a handwritten note on the bin that explained that pillows aren't recyclable. "If there's one thing I don't like, it's the bedding of other people," he said. I asked about other annoyances. "Hypodermic needles, netting and hair, just stuff like that," he said. One time an opossum jumped out of a can. "That scared the poo out of me."
When Pike started his job 13 years ago, he'd scan the trash for anything of value. He took home CD players, most of which turned out to be broken, and once discovered $80 in cash. He eventually came to believe that garbage is garbage for a reason. These days, he said, "I try not to pay attention to the garbage too much. It just goes in the truck. My motto is, Get it done and go home."
Waste not, video not
Sadly this video story had a lot of video and very little story. Why bother?
Sorry you didn't like the
Sorry you didn't like the video. Mother Jones is still fairly new to web video, and I welcome any suggestions you have on how to improve it. Please do read the print story, which goes way beyond the video for detail.
My apartment doesn't
My apartment doesn't have green bins either. Are they not required to provide these? I'd love to have a compost but I guess the next best thing would be city compost. Is the green bin an optional thing? I'd like to try and convince my landlord to get one- it's free right- they don't charge for pick up? If it's free, why doesn't every one have one?
I guess the next
I guess the next best thing would be city compost. Is the green bin an optional thing? I'd like to try and convince my landlord to get one- it's free right- they don't charge for pick up? If it's free, why doesn't every one have one?
Garments Logos | Communication Logo Design
the heat inside the
the heat inside the rows by turning them and keeping them smaller. Eight months ago, the company purchased a German-made machine that efficiently grooms the finished compost into a fine-grained loam. "This is the last stage," Soares said as we watched the machine hum, "until the compost grows something. Then you buy that tomato over there at the store."
Waste not
-
tagged as:
- solution
There are several questions for urban recyclors that I have. Although we recycle plastic bottles, what about the plastic playsets, barbie houses, sleds, etc. that are thrown out. They are tremedous amounts of plastic. That mass of plastic could be over 10,000 bottles.
And we recycle metal cans but then throw out a hot water heater, range, dryer or washer. What about those? If it wasn't for my neighborhood metal scavengers every garbage pickup, those would be thrown away to landfills too. That one hot water heater consists of several hundred if not more metal cans!
Is there any one recylcing those before they hit the land fill?
Good points. I think the the
Good points. I think the the answer depends on where you live. Though I stand to be corrected by Sunset Scavenger, my understanding is that in San Francisco, plastic toys, as long as they are all plastic, can be recycled. All the plastic gets melted down and mixed together to make heavy stuff like park benches, so you don't really have to worry too much about what kind of plastic it is.
As far as water heaters and stuff like that, SF has a "bulky item" pick-up service. You just dial them and they take it away to the scrap yard.
Is paper worth recycling?
My son, a smart and kind chemistry and history major, tells me that recycling paper takes more energy than it "gains" from the recycling process. i.e, that recycling paper is not a green thing to do. Does that make sense? Perhaps you have addressed this already; if so, point me to where. Mahalo.
I must concur with the first comment
The article is interesting but the video left much to be desired.
Really interesting article.
Really interesting article. I've always wondered about dirty foil and mail with plastic windows as well. There seems to be a lot more to recycling these days- so much so that you really need an article like this covering it to make sense of it all. My apartment doesn't have green bins either. Are they not required to provide these? I'd love to have a compost but I guess the next best thing would be city compost. Is the green bin an optional thing? I'd like to try and convince my landlord to get one- it's free right- they don't charge for pick up? If it's free, why doesn't every one have one?
green bins
It can all get pretty confusing when you're trying to recycle as much as you possibly can. Sean Davison, a Sunset Scavenger guy who appears later in the story, told me that the company is working on what it calls "The Bible:" a complete list of everything that is recyclable. I'm already imagining an exegesis of this text as people search for the closest thing to some item that isn't there.
Composting is still new for apartment dwellers in SF, but yesterday the board of supervisors voted to make composting mandatory, which presumably means that landlords are going to have to order up the green bins. If you request one from your landlord, he can call the city and they'll send one over. I'd recommend it. It's actually kind of fun and your regular trash bag will get really dry and light--basically just a big ball of plastic.
SF Recycling Guides
Our updated websites have been posted. If you have questions or want to learn more about San Francisco's comprehensive waste diversion programs, click on any of the following links.
www.SFRecycling.com/green
(use the contact us link to start green cart collection today.)
www.SFRecycling.com/RecycleMyJunk
www.SFRecycling.com/toxics
Thanks for the interesting and fun article.
Sean
I liked the video, mostly
It seemed a little odd when the guy was talking to you, looking for social feedback, and you kept your nose in your notebook.
A little bit of voice-over at the end explaining what we were seeing would have helped hold my interest. Those were bales of mixed paper, right? Or maybe some of them were plastic??
This article makes me think I should do a similar thing for my village newspaper, about what happens to our recycling. Yeah, in my abundant free time. . . Still, it's useful to hear about plastic windows in envelopes--I'm sure someone told me (years ago) that you had to rip those out. I like the idea of re-purposing paint. I hope they don't mix all the colors into gray brown mush!
My Trashes Afterlife
-
tagged as:
- solution
Obviously, recycling and reclamation are going to be BIG business in the future. San Francisco is leading the way and good for them. We need the private sector to jump on board. I heard on NPR today that the mayor want's to be at 75% by 2012 and 100% no waste by 2020. Maybe The mayor should challenge other cities around the country to a little contest.
But there is a story and an opportunity that I think is being missed, (or perhaps not even being thought of.) We have hundreds of thousands of "dumps" across the country. Here in NY we have the Fishkills landfill on Staten Island, which, if things keep going the way they are, will be the highest geographical feature on the eastern seaboard by 2015. Scientists, a few years ago went in and dug down about 20 or 30 feet and found entire newspapers from the 1960's! We're always talking about how plastics and stryofoam etc. don't biodegrade. But if you remove sunlight from the equation, nothing biodegrades. One would think a newspaper would turn to dust. But no.
My point is, recycle yes, reclaim yes, reuse yes. But what about mining? Think of the potential of all the landfills in all the states and towns that are just sitting there with all this stuff that hasn't and perhaps will never go away. Talk about a 21st century gold rush.
Naysayers might talk about the toxins and the sluge and think that this stuff is irretrevable. Perhaps. Now. But with better technology in the future I think we might be able to deal with that. Not to mention that all the toxins and sluge afore mentioned, leaching into our water table is an even better reason to go in, extract, recycle, and reclaim these sites.
We're talking decades of perhaps reuseable stuff. 100,000 times more tonage than we're dealing with now. Let's reverse the flow. Instead of dumping things into a landfill, let's start taking it out.
Response to a great idea.
Write on Trash Mining Guy!
A non-sexist response to a great idea:
Write on Trash Miner!
Who is Mining Guy
You have my email. Ask away.
trash mining
Actually, your email is somewhere in the site that I, as a mere reporter, can't access. Send me an email as jharkinson (at) motherjones.com
Dumping trash and other items.
Being as I have just discovered Mother Jones, this first comment may not be in order. I am at heart an environmentalist. Have been most of my life. I do not believe in plastic bags being the best method of dumping out refuse. Paper bagging items to be discarded in the local dumps are the proper method to use.
The major problems with plastic in general is that they do not deteriate in the under ground conditions. Outside in the atmosphere plastic will deteriate due to the suns rays and weathering conditions. However when buried into the landfills the plastic will last just about forever without deteriating.
Recycling is of course the answer.
Paper baging for trash.
My take on this subject of trash dumping.
Paper bagging from grocery stores are what I generally use for dumping my daily rubbish. I do not place garbage in these bags but rather grind it down in a mixer and rid it into the sewage which in turn is fed to bacteria in the septic tank. Grease is never a part of this system, so chicken fats and the like never go in.
The landfills crush up all of that rubbish as we know but it still remains as plastic, the bagging that is used and never rots in the ground. In affect it is a mucky mess.
In the long run composting is not really what is being developed in the ground and it wll for many years never really rot away the contents underground.
Brown paper bagging is the answer since the paper will rot in the ground, but tell that to the rubbish man who picks it up. He would rather it be plastic.
reinventing the wheel? you
reinventing the wheel? you know if cities like san fran who are trying to be more "green" are doing it by choice, they should reallly examine countries who recycle as a necessity. try checking out taiwan and you'll see how an entire country can recycle better than 1 small city.
oh btw i can't wait to see
oh btw i can't wait to see part 2.
Really???
Now you can see why the news prints are losing tons of money every day. This reporter couldn't come up with a better new story? How about some real reporting? Following his own garbage, now that takes some real talent!! Maybe that is why the editor allowed a ridiculous story like this be released to the public.
Re:
The half of the equation that hasn't even been mentioned here, is smart-shopping to make these recycling dilemmas less frequent. For example, never buy juices and ther liquids in those "tetra-pak" cartons which contain fused layers of aluminum, paper, and plastic/wax. They're simply impossible to recycle. Another silly example is glass jars - the metal lids often contain a lining of rubber/plastic to make a good seal against the glass, but this means the lids cannot be recycled (not here in the northeast anyway). A third example is "non-degradable" food waste - animal bones and similar items, which will muck up a compost heap. Not buying these things stops the problem at its root.
You spoke of ..."A third
You spoke of ..."A third example is "non-degradable" food waste - animal bones and similar items, which will muck up a compost heap. Not buying these things stops the problem at its root." ....but I would like to point out that those bones are somewhere.
REcycling sausage?
I was surprised the fellow in the article tossed a half eaten sausage into the compost. I'd always thought meat should be kept out because it attracts rats and other vermin while vegetables do not.
meat in compost
I was also surprised that meat is ok in the compost, but they told me it is. I think it's because the compost method that they use is advanced enough to handle it. This stuff with be discussed in part 3 of the piece.
The main problem with these
-
tagged as:
- solution
The main problem with these recycling programs is that they are relying on people's good nature or threat of fines to recycle which will only get us so far. Why should someone who only throws out 1 bag of trash a week pay the same price as his neighbor who throws out 5 bags. In my City of Decatur, GA they started a pay you throw trash program that charges residents for the disposal of trash by volume. Residents buy various size trash bags from the City that include the cost of disposal (more expensive than hefty). Residents have a monetary incentive to recycle and now our City leads the state in recycling.
Don't sweat a lot of the
Don't sweat a lot of the negative commenters. This is a great article, I especially liked the cat shit part :). Looking forward to the rest of the story.
I Agree with "Don't Sweat"
I Agree with "Don't Sweat" (Really??? Submitted by Anonymous) must be having a bad day and wouldn't know a good story or good reporting if it bit "Anonymous" in the ass. People who leave nasty comments should be required to own up to them by at least posting a name. Coward. Other papers might be littered with typos, bad editing and reporting due to staff cuts and a pervasive fear among the journalist of job loss but Mother Jones is still my one stop for quality reporting- interesting, informative, and entertaining. I liked the cat shit part too! (:
Submitted by RF Callahan
Submitted by RF Callahan (not verified) on June 10, 2009 - 9:13pm.
This is of course a repeat of the abovew comments in case it did not go in.
My take on this subject of trash dumping.
Paper bagging from grocery stores are what I generally use for dumping my daily rubbish. I do not place garbage in these bags but rather grind it down in a mixer and rid it into the sewage which in turn is fed to bacteria in the septic tank. Grease is never a part of this system, so chicken fats and the like never go in.
The landfills crush up all of that rubbish as we know but it still remains as plastic, the bagging that is used and never rots in the ground. In affect it is a mucky mess.
In the long run composting is not really what is being developed in the ground and it wll for many years never really rot away the contents underground.
Brown paper bagging is the answer since the paper will rot in the ground, but tell that to the rubbish man who picks it up. He would rather it be plastic.
Biodegradable or Compostable?
Federal Trade Commission Defines Biodegradability
A funny thing happened to me on the way to the local garbage dump. I discovered that my trash wasn’t biodegradable. The trash in the back of my truck was headed for a “Dry Tomb” landfill where my garbage will be compacted, covered with dirt, compacted some more and then layer upon layer the process will continue rendering my trash non-biodegradable. Archeologists thousands of years from now will be able to drill through these layers and just like Indiana Jones, find out how I lived by looking at what I threw away.
In a traditional “Dry Tomb” landfill, the stuff isn’t going to go away, at least not very fast. We use our dry tomb landfills to hide our trash...keep it away from our sight and noses.
I was surprised yesterday, to see an interesting tidbit about our landfills in the press. The federal government (Federal Trade Commission) has determined that since things do not biodegrade in a landfill, any item that is disposed of by tossing it in the garbage cannot be called biodegradable. Why you ask? Well, things in a typical “Dry Tomb” landfill don’t biodegrade and that would include things that normally do biodegrade...like paper, and food waste. It seems that anything that isn’t burned or composted in a commercial composting site and is disposed of in a landfill....can no longer be called biodegradable.
Take PLA (Corn starch or other plant starch) plastics, most PLA plastic will end up in a landfill. Historically, 70-80 percent of plastics isn’t recycled and end up in our landfills, streams and oceans. PLA can’t be mixed in with the normal recycling stream with other plastics so most PLA will end up in a landfill. For proper disposal, PLA must be processed in a commercial composting site. Commercial composting sites in the U.S. are far and few between. Since most PLA will probably end up in a “Dry Tomb” landfill under the FTC ruling it should no not be considered/labeled as biodegradable plastic.
Let’s take another example, leftover food. If you dig a hole in your backyard and put your food scraps in the hole and cover it with dirt, your food scraps will biodegraded within two to three weeks. Food placed in a back yard hole would be considered biodegradable. Now, let’s take that same piece of lettuce and take it to our local garbage dump...oops; it’s no longer biodegradable (Assuming your landfill is the “Dry Tomb” type).
However, if you happen to be lucky and your local landfill is a “Bioreactor landfill”, then paper, lettuce and a lot of other garbage will biodegrade.
Bioreactor landfills are designed to cause things to biodegrade and a bioreactor landfill is designed to capture biogases and turn those gases into clean energy. There are only a few bioreactor landfills in the U.S., they cost more to build then dry tomb landfills. Another thing that impedes bioreactor construction is that compliance with EPA and other environmental regulations takes years of paperwork and meetings to get the building permits. The process to build these modern landfills should be faster and easier, bioreactor landfills are better for us, the environment and future generations.
Many dry tomb landfill operators are all that interested in building a new generations landfill, operators have told me that it’s easier for then to maintain status quo and as one operator told me,” We have land for another 50-100 years, then it will be someone else’s problem.”
There are exceptions to every rule, and there are things that go into a dry tomb landfill that can be considered biodegradable. Stuff in a landfill does biodegrade but some of it might take thousands of years. However, anything that can biodegrade in an anaerobic environment will biodegrade in a dry tomb landfill much quicker then something that needs oxygen. ENSO Bottles, an environmental company, realized that all plastics ultimately end up in a landfill and with more than 150 billion bottles being produced each year something needed to be done about reducing plastic pollution. Less that 30 percent of plastic bottles are recycled, the remaining 100 plus billion bottles are ending up in our landfills, streams and oceans. ENSO is a supporter of recycling, which is an important step in conserving our scarce resources and protecting our environment.
ENSO decided to do something about the pollution problem and recently announced the development of a modified PET plastic bottle that will biodegrade including in a “Dry Tomb” anaerobic landfill environment. The ENSO Bottle has been tested for biodegrade in an anaerobic or aerobic microbial environment. The ENSO Bottle may be the only plastic product that meets the FTC’s requirement of biodegrade in a landfill microbial environment, leaving behind natural elements of biogases and humus within a reasonable time frame.
We believe that consumers have a right to know is their products are correctly labeled. Consumers and competitors can request test result from ENSO Bottles, LLC.
ENSO bottles with EcoPure™ have been tested and validated for the following:
(1) Recyclability through a third-party lab for ASTM D 1003 (Haze and Transmission).
(2) ASTM D 4603 (Intrinsic Viscosity)
(3) ASTM F 2013 (Acetaldehyde), Fluorescence Visual, and Visual Black Specks and Gels.
(4) ASTM D 5511 Standard Test Methods, a standard for biodegradation testing in anaerobic environments. Results clearly indicate ENSO bottles with EcoPure™ biodegrade through natural microbial digestion.
To learn more about these solutions visit http://www.ensobottles.com and http://www.bio-tec.biz.
To request official test results contact:
ENSO Bottles at 866-936-3676 or Bio-Tec 1-505-999-1160.
THE PROBLEM WITH IMMIGRATION & THE DESTRUCTION OF AMERICA
The destruction of any country, America included, is done by those within that control or have a lack of, thus destruction will arise. We cannot blame the foreign element of 12 million who have passed through the open gates and into this country. It was our fault for leaving our guard down. The gate was opened once we turned our heads to the fact that just about the entire foreign element that had their poor would naturally seek a better life for their families. Who can blame them?
Our higher labor rates for our workers and the fact that foreigners, illegal or not, were willing to work for less brought the silent majority of the industrial and farming companies to taking them in.
Basically it went okay for six months here in this country with a Visa and six months back to Mexico or Porto Rico or whatever country would be allowed. That was legal.
Another problem was that the moneys went in one direction only, to Mexico or Porto Rico or whatever country would be allowed, destroying our economy all the more. Again I ask, who can blame them?
THE PROBLEM WITH IMMIGRATION & THE DESTRUCTION OF AMERICA
The destruction of any country, America included, is done by those within that control or have a lack of, thus destruction will arise. We cannot blame the foreign element of 12 million who have passed through the open gates and into this country. It was our fault for leaving our guard down. The gate was opened once we turned our heads to the fact that just about the entire foreign element that had their poor would naturally seek a better life for their families. Who can blame them?
Our higher labor rates for our workers and the fact that foreigners, illegal or not, were willing to work for less brought the silent majority of the industrial and farming companies to taking them in.
Basically it went okay for six months here in this country with a Visa and six months back to Mexico or Porto Rico or whatever country would be allowed. That was legal.
Another problem was that the moneys went in one direction only, to Mexico or Porto Rico or whatever country would be allowed, destroying our economy all the more. Again I ask, who can blame them?
THE PROBLEM WITH IMMIGRATION & THE DESTRUCTION OF AMERICA
The destruction of any country, America included, is done by those within that control or have a lack of, thus destruction will arise. We cannot blame the foreign element of 12 million who have passed through the open gates and into this country. It was our fault for leaving our guard down. The gate was opened once we turned our heads to the fact that just about the entire foreign element that had their poor would naturally seek a better life for their families. Who can blame them?
Our higher labor rates for our workers and the fact that foreigners, illegal or not, were willing to work for less brought the silent majority of the industrial and farming companies to taking them in.
Basically it went okay for six months here in this country with a Visa and six months back to Mexico or Porto Rico or whatever country would be allowed. That was legal.
Another problem was that the moneys went in one direction only, to Mexico or Porto Rico or whatever country would be allowed, destroying our economy all the more. Again I ask, who can blame them?
Thanks for the Post!
Hello MotherJones team!
Thanks for this great article!
Best Regards,
Luiz
Thanks for concern to
Thanks for concern to environment, my biggest gratitude to those who put respect to environment.
I was also surprised that
I was also surprised that meat is ok in the compost, but they told me it is. I think it's because the compost method that they use is advanced enough to handle it. This stuff with be discussed in part 3 of the piece.
emo
No matter where you choose
No matter where you choose to buy your Eugenie Wallet
,louis vuitton onlineno matter whether you decide on a replica handbag of Louis Vuitton Eugenie Wallet or the authentic one, Louis Vuitton Multiple Wallet in mind that take your time choosing the bag of your dreams to Multiple Wallet that you have the best possible deal for your money.
ugg sale
I would like to buy uggs,
ugg sale,
ugg boots uk,
ugg boots london,
ugg boots sale,
uggs,
ugg london,
ugg boots sale,
UGG Bailey Button boots,
bailey button ugg boots,
UGG Nightfal boots,
and so on.





























