Page 1 of 2

The Battle of Blair Mountain, Round Two

Once the site of a historic labor showdown, the West Virginia ridge is again the backdrop for a fight between activists and Big Coal.

| Fri Nov. 12, 2010 7:00 AM EST

It's largely absent from history books, but for labor scholars the 1921 battle at Blair Mountain is legendary. Years of struggle between miners and coal-company bosses came to a head at this ridge in southern West Virginia, as an army of more than 7,500 miners marched miles to face off against coal-company guards, hired security forces, and local sheriffs. The five-day skirmish was the largest labor uprising in US history, and it is seen as a turning point—a crack in the armor of King Coal.

Now, almost 90 years later, there's another fight over Blair Mountain, featuring a new generation of activists and several modern-day coal companies intent on bulldozing and blasting away at a historical site to access the veins of coal beneath.

The original battle came a little over a year after a bloody face-off between miners and operators in Matewan, West Virginia, and just weeks after the town's union-supporting police chief, Sid Hatfield, was shot to death. Miners from across the southern part of the state answered a call from United Mine Workers of America leaders to advance on Logan County, looking to gather support in the coalfields as they marched. Blair Mountain stood as a fault line between the part of the state under control of the coal industry and the unionized areas to the north.

Advertise on

Our namesake, the legendary labor leader Mary Harris "Mother" Jones, played a role in the fight, as well. Years before, she'd warned the governor that there would be "one hell of a lot of bloodletting in these hills" if the coal companies' hired guards didn't end their campaign of violence against organizers. But in the days before, Jones discouraged the miners from marching, at one point claiming to have a telegram from President Warren G. Harding urging them not to fight. (Historians believe the telegram was actually a fake).

But the miners weren't deterred, says Gordon Simmons of the West Virginia Labor History Association. Their plan, he says, was to "overthrow the rule of company domination" in southern West Virginia—to establish the right to organize and fight for safer working conditions in the mines—and to use force if they had to.

Miners began arriving at the mountain one morning in late August (there are varying accounts about the actual date). Though the miners were greater in number, the better-armed coal-company forces overpowered them from the ridge above. The companies reportedly hired private planes to drop homemade bombs on the miners, and by September 5, federal troops that the governor called in for backup began arriving. After five days of open warfare and dozens of lost lives, the miners gave up; they had little interest in fighting against the federal forces that many had recently fought with in World War 1. Most headed home, but hundreds were charged with insurrection, and dozens more with treason and murder.

Only years later, with the passage of the National Labor Relations Act in 1935, would the miners win the rights to unionize that they fought for at Blair Mountain. But that battle set the stage. "It's probably the most significant single event in American labor history, in terms of quantity of people involved, the event, the historical significance," says Simmons.

After more than a decade of working to get the 1,600 acre site listed in the National Register of Historic Places, it was finally recognized in March 2009—only to have that listing taken away several months later. Now, several groups are suing the Department of Interior to get the site relisted—a move they say is necessary to keep history from going up in smoke.

Kenny King, a resident and amateur archeologist, has been combing the battle site for nearly two decades with a metal detector, searching for artifacts. His grandfather, a miner, fought in the battle. Over the years, King has found shell casings, buttons, a whistle, a belt buckle, and three guns. "People were just so fed up with their conditions, the way they were being treated, they felt they had to do something," he says. "They had no other choice, they had to settle it themselves. That ought to be worth something. It's part of our history."

But in the months since it was delisted, coal companies like Massey Energy Company and Arch Coal have crept closer to the site. Four landholding companies currently own portions of the land that advocates want set aside for historical protection. Locals say their mining blast sites come right up to the boundary of the 1,600 acre plot already, and worry that the two companies could start clearing the way to mine on the battlefield in the coming months. Last time he went there searching for artifacts, King found two armed security guards on all-terrain vehicles blocking the road.

Page 1 of 2