Top Ten Lists

| Sun Oct. 31, 2010 12:05 PM EDT

Here's a Twitter conversation from last night:

@kdrum: @ebertchicago's "Why I Loathe Top 10 Film Lists" doesn't actually say a word about why he loathes Top Ten lists. http://ow.ly/323Z8

@RemoteClancy: re: @ebertchicago & Top 10 lists. Not a word, just 900 of them. Re-read his response to 'Best in Film' for clearest reason.

I guess you'll have to click the link and decide for yourself who's right. As near as I can tell, Roger Ebert told us why he doesn't like being asked to participate in creating Top Ten lists for free, but that's a whole different question than why he loathes Top Ten lists in general. I realize he didn't write the headline for the piece, but I still want to know: why does he loathe Top Ten lists? He does seem to, but there's really no explanation given. Even for a serious critic, it seems like it might be sort of a fun exercise.

Get Mother Jones by Email - Free. Like what you're reading? Get the best of MoJo three times a week.