One Soldier's View
Jarhead: A Marine' s Chronicle of the Gulf War and Other Battles
By Anthony Swofford | Scribner. $24.
Anthony Swofford's Gulf War memoir, Jarhead, could hardly be more timely. But the author, who served as a Marine sniper in Desert Storm, has wisely avoided virtually every nod toward direct commentary on current politics and every cliché of battlefield memoir. Instead, much of the story alternates between descriptions of Swofford's training -- his rise through the ranks and eventual deployment to Iraq -- and descriptions of his personal degradation by that process. In the end, Jarhead emerges as a scary, detailed, well-written indictment of life in the military.
Swofford also offers some essential reporting. A military recruiter doesn't offer the then-17-year-old enlistment-brochure promises -- that he'll get to see the world and defend the Constitution. More perniciously, he entices the teenager with the truth: that he' ll spend his time getting drunk, starting fights, killing people with interesting weapons, and buying lost weekends with port-of-call prostitutes.
Swofford's concise writing and liberal use of unquotably coarse military lingo underscore both the intensity, and ambivalence, of his experience. As he rises to a coveted spot in a prestigious sniper unit, he sucks on a bullet as a kind of pacifier and talks about wanting to kill people he meets: Bedouins encountered on a desert patrol, distant soldiers seen through a telescope.
In the end, Jarhead captures the blackest of black comedy. His Marine troop, spoiling for a fight, starts shooting at camels and firing captured weapons at burned-out Iraqi tanks. Swofford himself teeters on the edge of sanity, contemplating suicide, torturing a cohort at gunpoint, and watching his fellow soldiers desecrate Iraqi corpses. The similarity between the recruiter's promises of a soldier's life and the reality of Swofford's account is instructive.
Jarhead is a book written by a marine who is suffering from the tedium which afflicts all men in war or preparing for war. As a Marine Corps veteran of Vietnam War, I cannot locate the stress the men in this story are subject to. And what bothers me the most about this story is that this author does not understand war because he has been in one and he fails to show that in the Maines on will meet the very best of mankind; men who are wonderful models of humanity even in the dirty business of war. Swofford and his [deleted]bird partners needed something to do as too much freedom and boredom leads to the absurd behavior he describes in his book. Read Maine Corps history and get in some shooting time and then you will do better with your subject.
Jarhead is a book written by a marine who is suffering from the tedium which afflicts all men in war or preparing for war. As a Marine Corps veteran of Vietnam War, I cannot locate the stress the men in this story are subject to. And what bothers me the most about this story is that this author does not understand war because he has been in one and he fails to show that in the Maines one will meet the very best of mankind; men who are wonderful models of humanity even in the dirty business of war. Swofford and his [deleted]bird partners needed something to do as too much freedom and boredom leads to the absurd behavior he describes in his book. Read Marine Corps history and get in some shooting time and then you will do better with your subject.



























