Thank you! Readers like you are helping us double down on our investigative reporting when it's more needed than ever.
Most of the big environmental groups are cheering the advancement of climate legislation out of the Environment and Public Works Committee on Thursday, but the farther-left environmental groups are still not happy with the bill.
Laudatory responses came almost immediately from Sierra Club, National Wildlife Federation, Environmental Defense Fund, and the Natural Resources Defense Council, to name a few. But Friends of the Earth—which along with Greenpeace was the only major green group to oppose the House climate legislation—blasted the bill as "a woefully disproportionate response to the tremendous economic, security and public health threats posed by global warming."
"It is extremely disconcerting to hear scientists speak about the level of action needed to prevent radical and dangerous climate destabilization, and then to see how far short even one of the most environmentally friendly committees in Congress has fallen," said Friends of the Earth President Erich Pica in a statement.
While some portions of the bill have been improved over the House bill, Friends of the Earth identified a number of concerns: "a poorly regulated carbon trading scheme," an allocation system that "showers polluting corporations with billions of dollars" without requiring stringent carbon reductions, and "massive carbon offset loophole."
"These flaws are unacceptable, and they are the result of a defective political system in which polluting corporations, Wall Street traders, and their lobbyists continue to exert far too much influence," Pica's statement said. And Pica said the negotiating effort by John Kerry (D-Mass.), Lindsey Graham (R-S.C.) and Joe Lieberman (I-Conn.) appeared "to be moving forward with an attempt to produce an even weaker bill—one friendlier to the oil, coal and nuclear industries."