In The Blogs

Gates Bars Torture Photos' Release

—A sketch by Thomas V. Curtis, a former Reserve M.P. sergeant, showing how a detainee in Afghanistan was allegedly chained to the ceiling of his cell. (Wikimedia Commons).

Defense Secretary Robert Gates has used powers granted to him by a controversial new law to block the court-ordered release of numerous photos of detainee abuse, government lawyers revealed in a court filing [PDF] Friday evening.

Gates' new authority comes from a law, signed by President Barack Obama last month, that gives the Secretary of Defense the power to rule that photos of detainees are exempt from release under the Freedom of Information Act. Gates' action on Friday was the first use of the new FOIA exemption since it passed Congress last month. The photos in question are the subject of a years-long legal fight by the American Civil Liberties Union, which first filed a FOIA request for records pertaining to detainee treatment, rendition, and death in May of 2005. The case is currently being reviewed by the Supreme Court.

The administration first sought to change FOIA in June, shortly after deciding to contest a ruling by the Second Circuit Court of Appeals that ordered the photos' release. The resulting bill, championed by Sen. Joseph Lieberman (I-Conn.), was specifically designed to nullify the effect of the appeals court's ruling. Since the court had ruled that the photos couldn't be withheld under an existing FOIA exemption, the Obama administration simply asked Congress to carve out a new exemption. Despite objections from liberal members of the House, Congress obliged.

image image

The new exemption's requirements are stunningly lax. In order to withhold the photos, Gates simply had to certify, as he did in the court filing, that "public disclosure of these photographs would endanger citizens of the United States, members of the United States Armed Forces, or employees of the United States Government deployed outside the United States." In other words, their release had to endanger someone, somewhere. And in the unlikely event that Gates had to stretch the truth to make that certification, it wouldn't matter, since there's no provision in the law that allows any court to review Gates' determination or rule on whether it was truthful.

This isn't just a few photos. Gates' block could apply to a far larger group of images than the 44 that are at issue in the ACLU's lawsuit. "The photographs include but are not limited to the 44 photographs" in the suit, Gates wrote in his certification. The extension of the ban beyond the 44 photos is the result of a flip-flop by the Obama administration. The Obama administration had originally planned to comply with the appeals court's order to release the photos. In April, Justice Department lawyers informed the ACLU in a letter [PDF] that the government planned to release the 44 photos and a "substantial number" of other images—over 2,000, according to some reports. But three weeks later, the administration changed course and decided to contest the appeals court's decision and pursue a legislative workaround. Now it appears that Gates has blocked the release of a large number—perhaps all—of the extant photos depicting abuse during the period from September 11th until the end of the Bush administration.

The administration undoubtedly has its reasons for withholding the photos. It's certainly possible that the release of more photos could help terrorist recruitment or further enrage anti-American sentiment abroad. But make no mistake. The new FOIA exemption that the Obama White House sought and obtained has one obvious result: shielding evidence of government lawbreaking, abuse, and torture under the Bush administration from public scrutiny. So much for Obama's claim that "transparency and the rule of law will be the touchstones of this presidency." There's a name for what the Obama administration did on Friday. It's called a coverup.

Nick Baumann covers national politics for Mother Jones' DC Bureau. For more of his stories, click here. He can also be found on twitter.

Get Mother Jones by Email - Free. Like what you're reading? Get the best of MoJo three times a week.
Comments
no profile pic for comment author

IF the ACLU really wants to help people...

...then why don't they work to decriminalize drugs? It seems, from the news, that the biggest problem currently facing Afghanistan is...drugs. Specifically, opium cultivation. Sooo...if this stuff is SO popular, in western countries, then why doesn't Bayer just put the stuff back on the market, why doesn't the ACLU petition them to do that? Essentially, you've got a pharmaceutical company that used to make the stuff that all these people are now killing each other over, and by this news report, a 65 billion dollar annual market,
http://www.nytimes.com/2009/10/23/world/23nations.html
"UNITED NATIONS — The Afghan opium harvest is feeding a $65 billion global trade in heroin each year, which now kills many more people in NATO countries in a year than the number of NATO soldiers who have died on the battlefield in Afghanistan since 2001, Antonio Maria Costa, the senior United Nations official on drugs and crime, said Thursday."

So, let's be 3% smarter than the problem, here, and have the stuff coming from a legitimate pharmacy company, from crops grown in the US and Europe, instead of a far-east country where they do business at gunpoint over the stuff.

Legalization of drugs puts the ball in the court of medicine, instead of the military. The medical community, in all their wisdom, probably knows how to get people unhooked off of heroin, and if the 'customers' are coming to them, instead of dealing with habib on a streetcorner, then maybe they stand a better chance of dealing with people and actually helping them, before they come to the emergency room, O.D.'d.

If the ACLU was that perturbed about the whole business of torture, then why didn't they do more to support the impeachment effort against Bush? It's too late now, water under the bridge, but now at least maybe they could use whatever influence they have to help get this country, and others, in front of the drug issue in a meaningful and productive way, and put the overseas parties out of business.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Heroin
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Marijuana

The US and europe have farmers, there's all this talk about unemployment, so,
'steal' the market from the folks in Afghanistan, and just grow the stuff inside our borders, keep the problem(and the money) local, and give the medicos a leg to stand on. That is, if the ACLU actually intends on doing anything meaningful, and helpful.

When the drug dealers have no more reason to smuggle to the United States, or even come to the United States, then they'll stop. And, maybe other countries can emulate our eventual success on dealing with 'dope' in this country. People are using the stuff anyway, in spite of best efforts, so...?

Klaatu Marachas Necktie

no profile pic for comment author

ACLU & Drugs

klaatu- The ACLU's mandate is to protect Constitutional rights. I'm unaware that there is a Constitutional right to use drugs. As you point out legalization requires a change in the laws. That's not the domain of the ACLU. There are lots of other organizations to donate and support for that.

The ACLU has been involved in civil rights issues related to drug prosecutions...search and seizure, unfair sentencing, evidence issues...and they do great work there.

The ACLU did expose more of Bush's Unconstitutional ACTS and did more than any other to build the case for impeachment. But impeachment is not something you do in Court...it's a political act.

no profile pic for comment author

I *like* it!

I like the idea; let's end our dependence on foreign drugs by producing more here at home.

Grow, Baby, Grow!

no profile pic for comment author

Coverup

Oh, dear. I did have Hope ... but I guess the old saw is true, "Power corrupts and absolute power corrupts absolutely." Hustling that law through Congress sure looks bad for the new administration.

One fact is, however, that Gates is protecting his old boss while screwing his new one. "Transparency" was never a strong point with the Cheney/Bush administration. [yes, Cheney was the brains of the outfit, so I see him as the 'de facto' prez.]

no profile pic for comment author

faces of death

wanting mr obama to release new photos of torture is a large request to meet the standards of transparency and i also assert thats its unnecessary. at least the admn. is admiting that the photos exist and that they are a problem. wanting to see them is another story. its like wanting to watch an al-queda training video. i dont see this as a cover up at all, its really handling sensitive material in a respectful way. and its absurd to insist that the world needs to see more acts of violence in order to be a fair and just place. if you all are so interested in others knowing the realities of the current war encourage your friends to read (ricks, coll, wright, johnson, etc...) there are plenty of outlets for us to educate ourselves without becoming fanatic consumers of the pain and suffering our lifestyle/culture is creating.

no profile pic for comment author

Agree completely. No one

Agree completely. No one 'needs' to see this photos. With all of the idiotic rampage running around the country in the name of 'freedom' and the fanatics who would have a hay day with these photos, the last thing we need is to fuel the fire.

What we need to do is hold the Cheney/Bush Adm accountable for their existence.

no profile pic for comment author

Torture photos

I don't think it's the government's job to decide what horrible images they need to "protect" us from. The law prevents effective legal action (both nationally and internationally) against torture, and puts the government that oversaw the crimes in charge of cleaning up its own house. It undermines the checks and balances that are supposed to restrain the executive branch. It's more important to prevent that than it is to "protect" anyone.

no profile pic for comment author

Non-release of photos

So much for Open Government, taking responsibility for acts, being big enough to face the world openly and admit wrong-doing with photographic evidence, and the rule of law. It is simply shameful. The rationale is flagrantly specious.

no profile pic for comment author

So covering up evidence of a

So covering up evidence of a crime is now legal because a new law allows it. With power like this is there anything the government can't do?

no profile pic for comment author

So covering up evidence?

The answer to your question is "NO"...

no profile pic for comment author

torture cover-up

By covering up the torture by the Bush administration, Obama becomes complicit in the crime. He is guilty after the fact. Just how significant is the difference between Obama and Bush?

no profile pic for comment author

torture cover-up

Sorry folks, believe me, I feel as bad about thlis as anybody, but, when it counts. like this torture cover-up, Bush = Obama, Obama = Bush.

no profile pic for comment author

Ever heard that Obama is is

Ever heard that Obama is is AKA - BUSHAMA!! It fits him perfectly.

edbrylovesaguy

Kerry for Secretary of Defense

John Kerry's qualifications for Secretary of Defense are exceptional.
We have one presidential candidate as our Secretary of State, why
not another as Secretary of Defense?

Sadgurunath Maharaj ki jay!

no profile pic for comment author

We know that the torture

We know that the torture happened, we've seen the proof, why does anyone want to see more pictures? Is torture your hobby? Do you need more pictures for your collection? Just get some snuff videos.Maybe someone can tell me why these photos need to be published. They add nothing to the narrative.

no profile pic for comment author

"Intelligence" Matters

no profile pic for comment author

It is amazing what minuscule

It is amazing what minuscule detail are often made a big fuss of, made to an all important
issue. What purpose would they serve anyhow? Sometimes human rights issues
are more a matter of egomania and righteousness, quarrelling over totally
unimportant things - and thus committing some kind of perfect sabotage when
it come to be bigger and actual issues.

no profile pic for comment author

War is Peace Freedom is

War is Peace

Freedom is Slavery

Ignorance is Strength

no profile pic for comment author

Democrat thugs

And who voted for OB? I knew he was a liar from the get go over that telecom immunity thing.
Democrats could have elected Bozo the Clown last election so who did they choose? A warmongering child killer. A wedding bomber.
I'm progressive. I don't vote for Democrats. Why? Because they're lying back stabbers.

no profile pic for comment author

Torture Photos' Release ....

The administration first sought to change FOIA in June, shortly after deciding to contest a ruling by the Second Circuit Court of Appeals that ordered the photos' release. The resulting bill, championed by Sen. Joseph Lieberman (I-Conn.), was specifically designed to nullify the effect of the appeals court's ruling. Since the court had ruled that the photos couldn't be withheld under an existing FOIA exemption, the Obama administration simply asked Congress to carve out a new exemption. Despite objections from liberal members of the House, Congress obliged.

The new exemption's requirements are stunningly lax. In order to withhold the photos, Gates simply had to certify, as he did in the court filing, that "public disclosure of these photographs would endanger citizens of the United States, members of the United States Armed Forces, or employees of the United States Government deployed outside the United States." In other words, their release had to endanger someone, somewhere.

ink cartridges

no profile pic for comment author

أزياء شتوية  

أزياء شتوية   فساتين مميزة  فسات


أزياء شتوية
  

فساتين مميزة
 

فساتين سهرة 2009
  

ملابس تركية
 

فساتين ساترة


ازياء شتويه
   

ازياء للصبايا
   

ازياء المصمم ايلي صعب
  

ازياء حوامل موضة 2010
 

فساتين مايلي سايرس
 

فساتين جميله


عبايات
 

فساتين قصيره


ازياء مغربية
 

فساتين مع اكسسوارات
 

فساتين سهرة 2010
 

فساتين ملكة
 

ديكورات و تحف


تحميل برنامج كاسبر
 

اثاث روعة


غرف نوم رومنسية
 

اثاث باللون الأصفر
 

ديكورات تصاميم جبسية
 

ديكور جديد سيراميك


ديكورات مائية


اكسسوارات غرف نوم


غرف نوم شبابيه
 

ديكورات بالآلوان
 

غرف نوم 2010
 

ديكورات منازل رائعة
 

ملابس دلع
 ديكور
منزل


خلطه طبيعيه لجمال شعرك
 

ديكورات لحمامات 2010
 

اجمل فساتين العروس 2010
 

عصيرات
 صور
مضحكه
 

المكياج اللبناني 


عطور غوتشي
 

مك آب من ديور
 

فساتين العروس 2010
 

مكياج وتساريح حنان دشتي
 

مكياج لآحلى العرائس


طرق تجفيف الشعر
 

فساتين سهره للمصمم فادي نخلة
  


عصير قمر الدين
 

عصير الليمون بالنعناع
 

ماسنجر هوت ميل الجديد
 

تنزيل برنامج تعريفات ويندوز Seven 7
 

النسكافيه والكاكاو
 

غرف نوم خيالية
 

ازياء كولكشن شتوي
 

فساتين للمصمم وليد عطاالله
 

مجوهرات
 

اكسسوارات باللون الاحمر
 

فساتين زواج فخمة
 

فساتين زفاف
 

فساتين عروسة
 

فساتين الخطوبة
  

فساتين زفاف
 

طرح للعرائس
 

فساتين عرايس
 

فساتين زواج 2009
 

فساتين زواج فرنسية
  

فساتين زفاف للمصمم زياد نكد


عصير الليمون طازج بالفانيلا
 

تورتة ستروبري


تورتة الفراشة بالصور
 

طريقه عمل السويسرول بالصور
 

طريقة عمل دجاج كنتاكي
 

طريقة عمل كيكة الموز
 

طريقة عمل فطيرة المشمش
 

سد الحنك
 

طريقة وضع المكياج الخليجي
 

ازياء فساتين اعراس
 

فساتين الزواج من تصاميم عالميه
  

تاج للعروسة
 

فساتين سهرة كلاسيكية
 

فساتين نجوى كرم
 

طرحات للعروس
 

مكياج سهرات
 

مكياج عيون
 

مكياج عيون خليجي
 

طاولات ترابيزات روعة 2010
 

صالات مغربيه
 

غرف معيشة
 

مكياج حليمة بولند
 

فساتين سواريه
 

الوايرلس حرام ام حلال
 

تمارين شد البطن
 

تمرينات رياضيه لرشاقة


طريقة لتخفيف وزنك
 

وصفة للشفط الشحوم
 

طرق تخفيف الوزن بالاعشاب
 

فوائد الزعفران
 

فوائد الشاي الاخضر للرجيم
 

فوائد التفاح للرجيم
 

خلطات تبييض للجسم
 

عجينة النعناع
 

منتديات الجود
 
الجود  
الجوديات 

الجوديات
 

منتديات نسائية
 
 اعلانات مبوبة
 دعايات 
صور
حواء 
العاب 
دليل مواقع  دليل
مواقع

 استشارات طبيه
-

الحمل و الولادة


الحياة الزوجية
-

المقبلين على الزواج

العروس -
ازياء
للعروس
-
تسريحات
للعروس

 صور
- فوتوشوب
-
توبيكات

ازياء
-
فساتين
-
موضة
-

فساتين سهرة

تسريحات شعر
-
العناية
بالبشرة
-
قصات شعر

اطايب
-
طبخ
- حلويات
- طبخات
- فيديو

مكياج
-
ادوات تجميل
- عطورات
-
اكسسوارات

ديكورات
- اثاث
- غرف نوم
- مطابخ
- كنبات


سوق نسائي
-
اسواق
نسائية
-

وظائف نسائية

رجيم
- الحميه
-
الرشاقة
  -
انقاص الوزن 

عالم الطفل
-
تربية
الاطفال
-
سلوك
الاطفال

الثقافة
الجنسية
-
قمصان
نوم

صور
تسريحات
-
صبغات
للشعر
-
جلابيات

الامومة

no profile pic for comment author

Fascism seems normal, these

Fascism seems normal, these days. Where, oh where has my country gone? Obama is a very dangerous man. I'm ashamed to have voted for him.

no profile pic for comment author

http://www.tube.alqaly.com

I think after this speech will be one of the visitors to this wonderful site Bstmrar Thank you to my friends

Excellent Thank you wish you more
دردشة|
يوتيوب|
منتديات,
رموز للماسنجر  |
مقاطع فيديو مضحكة |
مقاطع يوتيوب |
اسلامي  |
زفات |
ازياء |
فساتين اطفال|
رسائل جوال|
اناشيد اسلامية |
اناشيد mq3 |
اناشيد |
اناشيد اطفال |
اناشيد جديدة |
اناشيد 2010 |
توبيكات ماسنجر |
فساتين سهرات |
صور مسنجر |
مسجات جوال |
ابحاث |
ماجستير |
زفات تخرج نجاح|
السيره النبويه |
قصائد |
شعر |
خواطر رومانسية |
جواطر منوعة |
برامج كمبيوتر |
تحميل برامج انترنت ||
العاب كمبيوتر ||
تحميل العاب ||
رسائل وسائط |
شات |
صور مرعبه - صور غريبة - مخيفه |
مقاطع فيديو مقاطع مضحكة - مقاطع يوتيوب فيديو بنات |
مسجات |
العاب |
موقع العاب |
العاب جديدة |
صور ||
موقع صور |
صور اطفال|
دليل|
مواقع|
ابتسامات |
رامج فوتوشوب |
برامج فوتوشوب - ملحقات تصاميم - دروس - فلاش |
2010 |
موبايل sms |
مسجات |
رسائل |
أخبار السيارات Cars-صور سيارات |
اخبار الرياضة -كرة قدم -صور لاعبين |
ملابس رجالية |
ديكور - أثاث منزل - غرف نوم - اكسسوارات منزلية ( |
أثاث منزل |
غرف نوم|
وسائط جوال|
صور وسائط |
وسائط للعيد |
مسجات 2010 |
مسجات صباح الخير |
مسابقات - العاب - تحدي |
نكت - ضحك - فرفشه - الغاز |
صور 2010|
السفر - السياحه - رحلات - دول - عواصم ( |
اكلات |
حلويات
| يوتيوب |
الكامير الخفيه
| موقع فيديو |
فيديو youtube|
مقاطع youtube|
اليوتيوب youtube|
youtube|
يوتيوب|
يوتوب|
يتيوب |
منتديات,
قصائد شعر,
خواطر رومانسيه,
منتديات الغالي,
حب,
خواطر حب,
مقاطع|
فيديو|
يوتوب|
بنات|
مضحكة|
مقاطع فيديو |
مقاطع يوتيوب|
مقاطع بنات
|
مقاطع مضحكة|
يوتوب|
مقاطع - مقاطع - مقاطع - مقاطع
|
مقاطع فيديو - مقاطع يوتيوب - مقاطع بنات - مقاطع مضحكة
|
مسجات 2010 |
مسجات صباح الخير |
مسجات |
مسجات حب |
مسجات شوق |

no profile pic for comment author

156 Chinese protesters

156 Chinese protesters killed before Obama's arrival

http://joshfulton.blogspot.com/2009/11/china-jails-dissidents-before-oba...

no profile pic for comment author

I am sorry to hear about

I am sorry to hear about this new law, which does seem to continue policies I had hoped a new administration would correct. As for putting Americans in jeopardy, why permit photos to be taken in the first place? In the second place, I am thinking the US gov. is worried about war crimes trials initiated by foreign powers. In the third place, I have seen some of these photos all over the INTERNET. If there are photos worse than that, we all need to hang our head in shame. We have destroyed international treaties that our Americans initiated in the first place. I suppose that was long ago and Americans were different then.

no profile pic for comment author

Hope

I truly believed in Obama's plans for the future but now i am very disappointed. Still, i think he's better than Bush.

no profile pic for comment author

By covering up the torture

By covering up the torture by the Bush administration, Obama becomes complicit in the crime.

no profile pic for comment author

Try Bush in international courts?

If we're going to continue sending troops to Afghanistan we don't need to publish new anti-American material for enemy recruitment purposes.

If Obama wanted he could get some good political mileage out of the release of the photos. But Bush is no longer president. But an international court could try him for war crimes. Dragging Bush back thru the mud may have some (entertainment/political) value, but where do we draw the line as far as allowing our troops to be prosecuted in international courts for following orders.

At some point we need to think on how to move on from the Bush era and focus on what's best for the USA. Beating on Nixon might have been fun but Ford knew the country needed to focus on the future. Maybe Obama is trying to take the high road and do the same thing. It's not like he doesn't have other fish to fry...

no profile pic for comment author

It can reduce our dependence

It can reduce our dependence on forgian drugs. I like this idea.

no profile pic for comment author

It can reduce our dependence

It can reduce our dependence on forgian drugs. I like this idea.

no profile pic for comment author

Today I wrote for ScienceNOW

Today I wrote for ScienceNOW ugg 5815
about a new study on arsenic in Bangladesh. Some researchers from MIT think they’ve figured out why some water has
more arsenic than other water. Special microbes dissolve the arsenic from the sediment into the water, and they
need Ugg Classic Cardya carbon
source – so the scientists who Ugg sale boots study arsenic in Southeast Asia are
arguing over where that carbon comes fromThe launch date is tipped to be tomorrow,Ugg boots sale
so hopefully the wait won't be too long. You might want to reinvest in a newer computer chassis to fit this puppy inside.

no profile pic for comment author

Today I wrote for ScienceNOW

Today I wrote for ScienceNOW ugg 5815
about a new study on arsenic in Bangladesh. Some researchers from MIT think they’ve figured out why some water has
more arsenic than other water. Special microbes dissolve the arsenic from the sediment into the water, and they
need Ugg Classic Cardya carbon
source – so the scientists who Ugg sale boots study arsenic in Southeast Asia are
arguing over where that carbon comes fromThe launch date is tipped to be tomorrow,Ugg boots sale
so hopefully the wait won't be too long. You might want to reinvest in a newer computer chassis to fit this puppy inside.

no profile pic for comment author

vbn

Do you known what is the most popular this year?christian louboutin,ugg classic tall boots,or louis vuitton handbags?Yes,you are right!Are you hesitated by the high price?Do not worry,let me tell you a good place:Handbagcom.com!There are handbags,discount handbags,designer handbags,but also designer shoes.the high quanlity ugg classic short boots are more cheap than other ugg ultra tall boots.Handbagcom.com will let you happy and satisfy!
The products list of Handbagcom.com are as follow :
purse handbags designer handbag imposter diesel handbags handbags on sale monogram handbags monogrammed handbags quilted handbags handbags italian purses and handbags wholesale replica christian dior handbags designer bag cheap designer purses designer leather handbag designer purse knockoffs designer hobo bags designer tote bag discount designer purses discount designer wallets designer briefcases designer handbag knockoffs designer purse parties fake designer purses mens designer wallets replica designer handbag hobo bags designers bags fake bags shoulder handbags wholesale leather handbags luella handbags discounted handbags ladies handbags cheap wholesale handbags designer imposter handbags imitation handbags cheap replica handbags nfl jerseys handbags designer knockoffs handbags discount handbags for sale handbags knockoffs handbags online handbags replicas handbags sale italian leather handbags kooba handbags jimmy choo patent jimmy choo pumps coach womens shoes coach tennis shoes coach shoes sneakers cheap UGG Boots Christian Louboutin Christian Louboutin shoes Louis Vuitton UGG Boots Christian Louboutin on sale

no profile pic for comment author

Nice post. Thanks for update

Nice post. Thanks for update that the Gates bars torture photo release now. It is really nice i must say . . I am wondering if I can share your article in the bookmarks of society

christmas shopping

Post a comment
Alternately, you may login to or register an account
The content of this field is kept private and will not be shown publicly.
  • Web page addresses and e-mail addresses turn into links automatically.
  • Allowed HTML tags: <a> <ul> <ol> <li> <blockquote> <img>
  • Lines and paragraphs break automatically.

More information about formatting options


Jail.org - Inmate Search
Criminal records, instant public records & people search & current court records. www.jail.org

U.S. Public Records Search
Search County & State Court Records, Criminal records, Vital and Adoption Records www.PublicRecordsInfo.com

Records.com - People Search
Public Records and Background Checks. Instantly Search Criminal Records, Addresses and Court Records www.Records.com

Court Records & County Records
Find Instant Public Records, Criminal Records as Well as County Property Records Search. www.PublicRecordsIndex.com

Mother Jones Podcast
Get in on the conversation! We talk about culture, politics, the environment, the economy and more. Listen now!

TalkBackTees.com
A treasure trove of liberal wit, wisdom and quotations, from ancient to modern, on colorful, cotton tees.

Support Independent Artists
Amazing art, crafts, apparel, paper-goods and more. A carefully curated selection of sundries since 1999.

FREE CONNECTIONS FOR GREEN SINGLES
Meet progressive singles in the environmental, vegetarian & animal rights community who share your values