Delaware and Tennessee Win the 'Race to Consensus'
Teachers union buy-in makes, and breaks, some "Race to the Top" applicants.
Delaware and Tennessee will receive the first slice of the Obama administration's $4 billion "Race to the Top" education innovation fund, the administration announced Monday. The winning states edged out presumed front-runners like Florida and Louisiana—states that submitted equally reform-minded applications that were not as popular with teachers' unions.
The Department of Education gave Delaware's proposals the highest overall rating in the competition, and the tiny state will take home the $107 million it asked for. Second-place finisher Tennessee will receive about $500 million, leaving $3.4 billion available to states who participate in the competition's second round. Independent reviewers gave the winners' applications high marks for promoting accountability standards, implementing data systems to track student achievement, and pushing for charter school growth.
Georgia placed third in the competition, followed by Florida. Louisiana came in 11th place out of the 16 finalists announced earlier this month.
On Monday, Secretary of Education Arne Duncan played down the importance of broad "stakeholder support," calling it one of many factors that contributed to the finalists' total scores. But while Delaware and Tennessee boast nearly complete teachers union approval of their proposals, Florida's largest teachers union urged members to rebuke its application, and fewer than half of Louisiana's districts supported the state's plan.