« Zogby poll shows interest in new Septmber 11 investigation | Blog Index | Lobbyist Donations As High As Ever »
Importing Nurses
Nathan Newman raises an interesting issue here. Democrats in Congress offered an amendment to the immigration bill currently being debated that would allow an unlimited number of foreign nurses to enter the United States, on the grounds that there's a nurse shortage in this country.
That sounds like a good idea, but here's the problem: won't it cause an even more disastrous nurse shortage in developing countries, perhaps causing collapses in health care systems around the world? That already seems to be the case in the Philippines and India. On the broader issue, the New York Times ran a good piece a while back on the "brain drain" developing countries face when all their skilled workers leave for OECD countries. It can cause "a vicious downward cycle of underdevelopment." Not good for them, and it's hard to know what to do. Restrict immigration of skilled workers? Screw the poorer countries?
Now Newman's solution to the nursing issue seems unexceptionable—train more nurses in the United States, since there are currently more people who want to become nurses than spots in nursing school. On the other hand, for those worried about keeping health care costs down, it's much cheaper to "outsource" nursing education to the Third World, where education costs are naturally lower. Ideally, perhaps, the United States would do more to help develop the poorer countries that are sending us all their cheap labor, but that would involve more drastic changes than anything being contemplated in Congress right now.
Posted by Bradford Plumer on 05/24/06 at 11:07 AM | E-mail | Print
TrackBacks
TrackBack URL for this entry:
http://161.58.185.225/mb/mb-backtracks.cgi/726
Comments
What was interesting in the NYT article (yet not surprising) was their focus on the effect that the exodus of nurses and doctors is having on their home countries. When 150,000 qualified Americans are turned away from nursing schools annually because of overcrowding, Congress should be appropriating funds for more training. The problem (paucity of professors due to inadequate pay) is growing in other professions (like engineering) as well. How are poor and middle class Americans to support themselves in George H.W. Bush's "new world order"?
Republicans have been trying to destroy public education for over thirty years, by cutting budgets and passing the buck around from federal to state, until only those with money can get their children a solid basic education from which they can study further and build a worthwhile career and life on.
The cover story on Time magazine's April 17, 2006 issue was "Drop Out Nation" - 30% of America's high school students won't be graduating. Newt Gingrich's plan is for Americans to be the "investor class" of the world - Those of us with wealth (damned few) will reap the benefits (dividend checks) of the labor and sweat of the few that can find what work there is that requires little or no training (and pays less), just a strong back. All others are what? In prisons, on the streets, commiting suicide?
We're about to experience a train wreck, and nobody who is in a position to do anything to stop it is doing anything to stop it.
Posted by: Maeven on 05/27/06 at 12:42 AM
That is so true, Michael. When you bring in 5 foreign nurses, you're actually bringing in all their nuclear family to the US. Maybe those concerned with the social cost of hosting entire clans of immigrants should look closer at this angle. It is precisely because nurses, or any other professional for that matter, can eventually bring with them their families that's making the prospect of migrating to the US more attractive.
Posted by: Rose on 06/09/06 at 8:20 PM
ARCHIVE
October 1, 2006 - October 7, 2006
September 24, 2006 - September 30, 2006
September 17, 2006 - September 23, 2006
September 10, 2006 - September 16, 2006
September 3, 2006 - September 9, 2006
August 27, 2006 - September 2, 2006
August 20, 2006 - August 26, 2006
August 13, 2006 - August 19, 2006
August 6, 2006 - August 12, 2006
July 30, 2006 - August 5, 2006
April 23, 2006 - April 29, 2006
April 16, 2006 - April 22, 2006
April 9, 2006 - April 15, 2006
March 26, 2006 - April 1, 2006
March 19, 2006 - March 25, 2006
March 12, 2006 - March 18, 2006
March 5, 2006 - March 11, 2006
February 26, 2006 - March 4, 2006
February 19, 2006 - February 25, 2006
February 12, 2006 - February 18, 2006
February 5, 2006 - February 11, 2006
RECENT COMMENTS
Texas to DC: Don't Fence Me In (2)
Clarence Smart wrote:
Thank you, Eleanor! My thoughts exactly!
...
[more]
Supreme Court Declines to Take Up Sex Toys (1)
Clarence Smart wrote:
Do they grow cucumbers in Texas? ...
[more]
Woodward, Kissinger, Vietnam--Let's Do The Time Warp Again (2)
john wrote:
1938 was over 50 years ago. Like the “world’s greatest g...
[more]
Foley Now In Deeper Trouble (3)
john wrote:
Kathleen, you are forgetting that 50% of the population ar...
[more]
And the Next Secretary General Is... (2)
airtravel wrote:
airtravel...
[more]
Predatory Payday Lenders Ground Thousands of Troops (2)
car loan wrote:
car loan...
[more]
Turn Up the Propaganda, Please (1)
Joe DeLibertas wrote:
Here WE Go Again:
We're not fooling anyone particularly s...
[more]
They've known about Foley for almost a YEAR? (3)
M Baley wrote:
It looks like the Congress will now have to get together ...
[more]
Foley Resigns Over Sexually Explicit Emails (Or, "...sick sick sick sick sick.") (4)
seattledem wrote:
Typical Republican ...
[more]
Remember the Anthrax Investigation? (9)
Dr.Q wrote:
by having antrax identified of an specific strain tells me...
[more]
Movable Type 3.33
Jail.org - Inmate Search
Criminal records, instant public records & people search & current court records. www.jail.org
U.S. Public Records Search
Search County & State Court Records, Criminal records, Vital and Adoption Records
www.PublicRecordsInfo.com
Records.com - People Search
Public Records and Background Checks. Instantly Search Criminal Records, Addresses and Court Records www.Records.com
Court Records & County Records
Find Instant Public Records, Criminal Records as
Well as County Property Records Search.
www.PublicRecordsIndex.com











The entire issue doesn't make one bit of sense. If the Philippines are already "exporting" nurses into the USA, why do the Democrats "feel the need" to amend the new bill to allow it...?
The current thinking on the subject of nurse immigration is that "nursing schools limit enrollment because they want to limit supply exactly the same way medical schools limit the supply of physicians, and for exactly the same reason, to create a shortage."
It was in June, 2005, that the AMA first recognized the physician shortage ("at least in some regions and specialties"). To rectify the problem, it declared that it would "work to develop mechanisms, including identification of funding sources, to create medical school and residency positions ..."
I'm thinking that, after they identify these funding sources, the AMA is going to somehow manage to cognize that, yes sir, only rich people can afford to send their kid to medical school, and that, yes certainly, we can trust the rich folks to skew the supply/demand in order to reap higher wages...
Waht a tasteless joke; right, we can trust these jokers to "fool around" with the gravest problems imaginable...
Maybe these aliens wouldn't be so eager to make the move if they weren't allowed to bring their entire extended family with them...
How does it make any sense that if a foreign national marries a citizen, than he/she can bring the entire "boatload" along for the ride? And if indeed by chance that's not how the law reads, in practice it works the same way. An elderly "second aunt" is granted a visitors visa, and that's the last time she ever appears on radar...
Maybe the Gov. can move some of the relatives of aliens off the welfare roles and into nursing school...
Posted by: Michael L. Wagner on 05/24/06 at 2:16 PM