MOTHER JONES BY E-MAIL
MoJo Blog Home

«--Previous Post | Blog Index | Next Post--»

That's Why It's Called the Nobel, Not the Noble

James Watson, a geneticist who won the Nobel Prize in 1962 for discovering the structure of DNA, was suspended this week from his position at the Cold Spring Harbor Laboratory in New York state, after being quoted in the Times of London saying he was "inherently gloomy about the prospect of Africa," because "all our social policies are based on the fact that their intelligence is the same as ours—whereas all the testing says not really."

Even if Watson, who seems believably mortified by his own words, is in fact a horrible bigot, he’s far from the only award-winner to have a less-than-illustrious record. Consider Menachem Begin, who won the Peace Prize in 1978 for helping to negotiate the Camp David Accords and who went on, in the 1980s, to authorize Israel’s invasion of Lebanon. And then there is the notorious Henry Kissinger, who received the prize in 1973 for his work on the Vietnam Peace Accords, and yet also orchestrated the secret carpet-bombing of Cambodia.

Perhaps this is all fitting somehow, considering that Alfred Nobel was the inventor of dynamite.

Leave a Comment »

Posted by Jennifer Vogel on 10/19/07 at 4:55 PM | E-mail | Print | Digg | de.licio.us | Reddit | Newsvine | Yahoo! MyWeb | StumbleUpon | Netscape | Google |

Technorati Tags: | | |



Comments

There was a Spanish doctor whose name I forget, from early in the 20th c. who won a Nobel for being the inventor of the procedure known as lobotomy. It all started out with animal experiements in which he'd simply insert an ice pick into the critter's eye supraorbitally, flick it around it there, and that was it: abnormal behavior repaired. He transferred and adapted the procedure to (supposedly) psychotic humans and won a Nobel for it.

You are right, consider Al Gore, the big hypocrite that also won with that fraud of a movie. Al is in good company with all these other misfits.

Posted by: Bobby on 10/22/07 at 3:42 PM  Respond

Most people saying that climate change is a fraud, or needs more research, bought everything Bush said re. Iraq hook, line and sinker. They casually dismiss the 10,000 times as much evidence for climate change as they considered adequate justification for conquering Iraq. It's noteworthy that over the next 25 years, with vet's benefits and debt service, we'll probably spend as much on iraq as they think doing something about the climate issue will cost.

Posted by: unevenly on 10/22/07 at 4:45 PM  Respond

In our society there are two ways of thinking: the wrong way and the politically-correct way. Mr. Watson, despite his brilliant achievements, is being punished for publicly enunciating his politically incorrect views.

It's a damn shame you're not allowed to hold certain views anymore withoug being persecuted. What's suddenly happened to the First Amendment, anyhow??

Regarding Mr. Watson's views, does anyone even care that they could quite possibly be CORRECT?? For example, blacks consistently score below all other races on IQ tests. And I can find no example of blacks governing themselves successfully -- not in Africa or elsewhere. Every place they've taken over has proven to be a disaster -- Zimbabwe, Uganda, South Afica, Detroit, Washington, D.C., Cleveland,Newark, New Jersey, etc., etc., etc.

Mr. Watson is simply trying to view this matter objectively, and for this he's been ostracized.

Posted by: Harry Ryan on 10/22/07 at 7:02 PM  Respond

In our society there are two ways of thinking: the wrong way and the politically-correct way. Mr. Watson, despite his brilliant achievements, is being punished for publicly enunciating his politically incorrect views.

It's a damn shame you're not allowed to hold certain views anymore withoug being persecuted. What's suddenly happened to the First Amendment, anyhow??

Regarding Mr. Watson's views, does anyone even care that they could quite possibly be CORRECT?? For example, blacks consistently score below all other races on IQ tests. And I can find no example of blacks governing themselves successfully -- not in Africa or elsewhere. Every place they've taken over has proven to be a disaster -- Zimbabwe, Uganda, South Afica, Detroit, Washington, D.C., Cleveland,Newark, New Jersey, etc., etc., etc.

Mr. Watson is simply trying to view this matter objectively, and for this he's been ostracized.

Posted by: Harry Ryan on 10/22/07 at 7:02 PM  Respond

Harry, you are certainly correct. You speak the truth.

Posted by: MaryJo Lee on 10/22/07 at 8:12 PM  Respond

Re Harry Ryan/ Mary Jo Lee posts:

Under the First Amendment one assumes you are able to spout racist rubbish freely; just don't confuse it with having any basis in fact,

"Every place they've taken over has proven to be a disaster"

Hmm.. American interventions in the Middle East and South America have been glowing successes have they? I really don't think that people in glass houses should throw too many stones about, personally.

Posted by: Nick Gall on 10/23/07 at 12:47 AM  Respond

Dr. Watson won the Noble Prize in 1962.
But his inability to give credit to Dr.Rosalind Franklin at the time, says more about his character, than anything else!

Posted by: Martin Gold on 10/23/07 at 5:43 AM  Respond

Harry, you're wrong. Zimbabwe was a model for success among African nations until its current leader took over. Go read The Economist on that subject.

As for Watson-- one cannot call just anyone who says anything bad about members of another group, genetic or otherwise, a bigot. It bankrupts the term and reduces the speakers to nothing more than partisans. Science, whether it says Watson is right or wrong, has to trump what people desperately wish to believe. Those who say that that is true with global warming are the most profound hypocrites if they deny it with whatever links there are between genes and intelligence.

Posted by: Forrest on 10/23/07 at 7:18 AM  Respond

Martin, Dr. Watson did state that "Ashkenazi Jews" have higher intelligence than other people, which some believe may be his way of making amends to the late Dr. Franklin.

Posted by: Bob on 10/23/07 at 7:22 AM  Respond

Harry, perhaps you need to take a few classes in history and political science before attempting to paint with mop head. First off IQ has little to do with governing as George Bush being exhibit A. Although he does a poor job of that, so... Two, the places you use as example Zimbabwe, Uganda, South Afica, Detroit, Washington, D.C., Cleveland,Newark, New Jersey, etc. Are perfect exhibits of countries, cities that were inherited problems by white politicians and businessmen. These oppresors, and that is the right term, took what they needed exploited those people and then they were either run out or cut and ran when they could no longer extract whatever value they could from those people. Slavery can not be overstated as a primary cause of much of the problems we see today in Africa and African-Americans. The economic prisons that these people have had to endure at the hand of white opressors is staggering. Yours and James Watson's IQ justification is fuel for that type of incorrect thinking. While it is true that Africa and many other developing nations are in peril of collapse, I think there are far too many powerful outside influences on their economies, and society that are the root causes of their misery. Let's maybe work toward helping out our fellow man, as opposed to causing the problems and then insulting their intelligence.

Posted by: Fact checker on 10/23/07 at 7:41 AM  Respond

Fact Checker, you just proved Dr. Watson's point that Africans have weak genes and can not raise above perceived hardships and injustices without the help of the oppressor. You really have a victim's mentality and will always be bound by the prison of your weak mind.

Posted by: Geri on 10/23/07 at 10:34 AM  Respond

Dr. Watson may have won a Nobel prize for the determination of the structure of DNA, but that doesn't mean he knows what he is talking about. Science is supported by empirical evidence not supposition and loosely observed anecdotes. Anyone who has done genetic research can easily identify his statements as faulty, overreaching, and consisting solely of his opinions. There is no one gene or a couple of genes for anything as complex as cancer or intelligence. The environment also plays a factor in the development of both. So for those of you who have argued for the veracity of Dr. Watson's statements, you have no scientific proof and your suppositions and perhaps prejudices are showing.
As for Global warming , there actually has been evidence presented in peer reviewed journals so you can't really compare the two.

Posted by: Ursula on 10/24/07 at 9:31 AM  Respond

First, someone needs to show me empirical evidence that an IQ test measures something more than desired traits by those who developed them. If capitalism is the measure of our success, maybe the test is worth something; our culture is not always the best model for determining valuable traits.

Posted by: Terri on 10/26/07 at 8:50 AM  Respond

Thank you HARRY.

Posted by: dsfx88 on 10/26/07 at 2:29 PM  Respond

Post a comment





 

RECENT COMMENTS

That's Why It's Called the Nobel, Not the Noble (15)
dsfx88 wrote: Thank you HARRY.... [more]

FEMA's Fake Press Conference (3)
Dennis Finch wrote: MO JO FO... [more]

Rudy's 'Senior Freedom Adviser': Curtail Arab Birth Rate (4)
Eric wrote: He's talking about cutting subsidies. That means stopping... [more]

That Was Quick: Times Tackles Rudy Story (3)
suprf88 wrote: Wow -- you complained and they obliged? Now can you get th... [more]

Freedom Agenda Proponents Depart State Department (2)
Richard Aberdeen wrote: I've had a lot of jobs in my life, both blue collar and ow... [more]

Stephen Colbert's Fictional Campaign Beating Real Republicans in South Carolina (3)
Scott wrote: I'd vote for him! He's a character being played by a comed... [more]

State's Security Chief Out Over Blackwater Shooting (1)
Dr.Q wrote: at the end we all shall see... who can press further. Dr.... [more]

People Are Crazy, Mike Huckabee-Edition (4)
LANE HAGOOD wrote: By the way, you sound like your are discriminating on the ... [more]

Conservative Blog Bans Ron Paul Supporters (9)
Neil B. wrote: Mitch - corporations only exist as entities with limited l... [more]

52-Year-Old Scientific Paper Retracted Due to Enthusiam Amongst Creationists (1)
Neil Bates wrote: Dr. Jacobsen shouldn't retract the paper unless it really ... [more]

XML RSS Feed

Powered by
Movable Type 3.33

Jail.org - Inmate Search
Criminal records, instant public records & people search & current court records. www.jail.org

U.S. Public Records Search
Search County & State Court Records, Criminal records, Vital and Adoption Records www.PublicRecordsInfo.com

Records.com - People Search
Public Records and Background Checks. Instantly Search Criminal Records, Addresses and Court Records www.Records.com

Court Records & County Records
Find Instant Public Records, Criminal Records as Well as County Property Records Search. www.PublicRecordsIndex.com

















bookIN PRINT

CLICK HERE
for more great reading

headphones IN TUNE
New music every issue

CLICK TO LISTEN


This article has been made possible by the Foundation for National Progress, the Investigative Fund of Mother Jones, and gifts from generous readers like you.

© 2007 The Foundation for National Progress

About Us   Support Us   Advertise   Ad Policy   Privacy Policy   Contact Us   Subscribe   RSS