MOTHER JONES BY E-MAIL
July 6, 2008

«--Previous Post | Blog Index | Next Post--»

Is the Huckasurge For Real?

huckabee_flag250x200.jpg WASHINGTON D.C. — The conventional wisdom that began emerging yesterday evening, even before all of Super Tuesday's votes had been cast, was that Mike Huckabee's wins in the South were something of a coup for the former Arkansas Governor. Chris Matthews called Huckabee's five Southern victories – he won zero states in the rest of the country – a "stunning development." The New York Times wrote that Huckabee "revived his candidacy with a surprise string of wins in the South." Mitt Romney didn't reveal any shock publicly, but must have felt it in his more private moments: he had spent weeks treating Huckabee like a sideshow.

One has to wonder what these folks were thinking. Let's review the facts. Mitt Romney is a loafer-wearing country clubber from Massachusetts whose family is from Michigan. He has never served in the military and is a member of the Mormon faith. John McCain is a southwestern Senator who has called evangelical leaders "agents of intolerance." He is notoriously unsuccessful among the most conservative members of his party, most of whom reside in the South. Mike Huckabee on the other hand is a former Southern governor and former Baptist preacher. He is the strongest and most consistent advocate for "values voters" left in the presidential race.

These facts alone should have made Huckabee the obvious frontrunner in the states he won – Alabama, Arkansas, Georgia, Tennessee, and West Virginia (he lost Missouri, a border state, to John McCain by one percentage point). In fact, in my discussion of how the rules of awarding delegates hurt Mitt Romney, I pointed out that if Romney took a close second to McCain in the moderate coastal states and he took a close second to Huckabee in Southern states, he would win almost no delegates. Though I was incorrect to assume Romney would contend seriously in many of these states, I was correct to assume that Huckabee would lock up the South.

And before we get carried away with Mike Huckabee's chances, let's stop to ask a key question: Where does the Huck go from here? As I mention above, Huckabee didn't win a single state outside the South. Exit polling from almost every primary held thus far shows that Huckabee polls in the single digits among non-Evangelicals. On February 9, Kansas, Louisiana, and Washington state hold their Republican primaries, meaning Huckabee has a chance to win one state. Three days later he has a shot at Maryland and Virginia. Then there's a string of non-Southern primaries before the candidates get to the March 4 contest in Texas. If Huckabee wins three of these states, which is no sure thing, he will be winning one state for every two or three of his opponents. It's a plan that simply cannot be sustained.

But if Huckabee is in bad shape, Romney may be in worse. He won six states on Super Tuesday, none of which were in the largest nine, delegates-wise, being contested by the Republicans. His base of support was the West: he won Colorado, Montana, North Dakota, and Utah. But his argument that he is the true conservative in the race relied on him winning the South, the bastion of conservatism in America. He was unable to win a single Southern state, and only finished within a half dozen points of Mike Huckabee in two of them.

But neither Huckabee nor Romney are going anywhere. Or so they claim. "I think there are some people who thought it was all going be done tonight," Romney told supporters last night, "but it's not all done tonight. We're going to keep on battling. We're going to go all the way to the convention, we're going to win this thing, and we're going to get in to the White House." Those are strong words for a candidate who will wake up tomorrow badly behind in the delegate count. But losing as badly as Romney did yesterday – and remember, though Romney won a decent number of states, he won zero large ones – would create a possibly fatal hurdle for many candidates that won't exist for Romney: money. Romney doesn't have to worry about his campaign chest running out, because he can always reach into his wallet and fill it up again.

A cautionary note on Romney's future prospects: MSNBC reported last night that Romney's senior staff will meet the former Massachusetts Governor Wednesday for "frank discussions" about the future of the campaign. Apparently, campaign stops scheduled for later this week have been cancelled. This may mean everything. It may mean nothing.

As for Huckabee, he made it sound in his speech yesterday like his campaign is ascendant. "Tonight we're proving that we're still on our feet, and much to the amazement of many, we're getting there," he said. "We're getting there."

I suggest that Huckabee did exactly as well as he should have — he did not outpeform accurately calibrated expectations. In fact, the fact that Huckabee couldn't win a state in the Midwest, the Northeast, the Rocky Mountain region, or the West further shows how much of a niche candidate he is. If there was a Huckaboom yesterday, it will be followed very closely by a Huckabust.






Comments

come, come Jonathan. In the Huchabee article you went out of your way to mention that Romney never served in the military. You don't mention that neither did Huck (re: Wikipedia). I'm not a Republican, and I do not take well to bias writing. Serve it up like it is.

Posted by: alexis on 02/06/08 at 2:55 PM  Respond

It's too bad about Huckabee. He's entirely crazy for this crackpot religion, but he's a decent sounding man with a sense of humor. I wish we'd had this nut for the past 8 years instead of Bush who really is a very evil man.

Posted by: Don Donn on 02/06/08 at 4:22 PM  Respond

The Republican voters have been totally Skinnerized and Pavlovian conditioned into totally abrogating any desire for independent thought and rememberance of issues such as freedom and independence and soveriegnty.

The Huckster and Plastic Man are tweedledums of each other...with the MadMan Bomber McManiac gleefully watching the sideshow..

Ron Paul and his Message of freedom was Orwellian-like thrown down the memory hole by the MSM and the malleable GOP establishment..

The wall of separation between the GOP voters and the candidates is quite solid and controlled...Dr Paul and his message almost got through...

And Americans blithely and bovine-like march to polls and parties....

while our freedoms are on the bankrupt empire abyss..

they and we deserve what will be happening...

Posted by: Chris Bieber on 02/06/08 at 10:00 PM  Respond

Sadly for the Huckster, there just aren't enough crazy evangelicals to nominate or elect him.

It seems that most Republicans hate McCain nearly as much as they hate Clinton, but then, what choice did they ever have?

Romney (after deadline) has caved, thank God-if-I-believed-in-Him. Ron Paul was never the messiah they thought he was -- just another fiscally semi-sensible libertarian (as opposed to the wholy UN-sensible crowd in power now). Giulianni was never more than a bad joke, with "9/11" as the perennial punchline.

There are even signs that disgusted Republicans (it's about friggin' TIME!) might even vote for Obama, over McCain.

If so, or even without a "turncoat vote," the "black JFK" may get his shot at changing the political culture of our country.

So quit stressing over WHO the next president will be, and start focusing on HOW change will happen. Four years, or even eight, is a pretty short time, for the shift that needs to happen. Start pushing ALL candidates, even the doomed McCain and Huck, for commitments on progressive priorities. Pressure equals words, equals (in the fullness of time), some attempts toward action.

Global Warming. Ending War. Ending Illegal Torture. Respecting the authority of the World Court, and International Treaties. Acknowledgment of the legitimate aspirations of other nations. Worldwide Economic Equity.

There is a long long list of things we need to handle, if humans are to continue to entertain anything similar to civilization, on our one and only planet. We need to get on with this, or it's good bye world as we know it.


------
Kill your TV, and free your mind.

Post a comment





 

RECENT COMMENTS

Ann Coulter Is Insane Over McCain, Supporting Hillary (15)
jj wrote: Hey all! Actually, I said the same thing earlier today wit... [more]

Which Dem Is Better Able to Beat John McCain? (62)
macduck wrote: To those of you who say you'll vote for McCain because you... [more]

Romney Out; What Will Huckabee Do? (15)
Dana Ward wrote: Strikes me that the far more logical choice is Leiberman a... [more]

Is it Time To Worry about Superdelegates in the Clinton-Obama Contest? (8)
Thom Tibor wrote: I think that the Super Delegate plot is the Democratic Par... [more]

OSC's Investigation of Rove May be Legit. Very Legit (2)
iyinet webmaster forumu 2008 seo yarışması wrote: Yorumsuz.... [more]

Time for A Superdelegate Pledge (3)
denis wrote: I respectfully disagree. It is probable that almost 1/2 o... [more]

Attorney General John Edwards? (28)
Elaine N. Ramey wrote: I have said it many times before and I will say it again, ... [more]

CPAC's Coulterkampf (13)
Dave P. wrote: What I don't understand is why she insists on putting her ... [more]

Can Hillary Stop Obamamentum? (38)
patti wrote: I think a lot of people are underestimating the JR Senat... [more]

How Will Ron Paul's Libertarian Fans View His Big Anti-Abortion Endorsement? (17)
Unbelievable wrote: Wow, I never knew that being a Libertarian meant we all ha... [more]

XML RSS Feed

Powered by
Movable Type 3.33

Jail.org - Inmate Search
Criminal records, instant public records & people search & current court records. www.jail.org

U.S. Public Records Search
Search County & State Court Records, Criminal records, Vital and Adoption Records www.PublicRecordsInfo.com

Records.com - People Search
Public Records and Background Checks. Instantly Search Criminal Records, Addresses and Court Records www.Records.com

Court Records & County Records
Find Instant Public Records, Criminal Records as Well as County Property Records Search. www.PublicRecordsIndex.com

















bookIN PRINT

CLICK HERE
for more great reading

headphones IN TUNE
New music every issue

CLICK TO LISTEN


This article has been made possible by the Foundation for National Progress, the Investigative Fund of Mother Jones, and gifts from generous readers like you.

© 2008 The Foundation for National Progress

About Us   Support Us   Advertise   Ad Policy   Privacy Policy   Contact Us   Subscribe   RSS