MOTHER JONES BY E-MAIL

«--Previous Post | Blog Index | Next Post--»

Tim Russert, Dead at 58: Remembering One Q&A with Cheney

Tim Russert suffered a heart attack at NBC News' Washington bureau on Friday afternoon and died at the age of 58. As he was eulogized on air by NBC colleagues Tom Brokaw, Brian Williams, David Gregory, Howard Fineman, Keith Olbermann, and Andrea Mitchell, I thought of a moment when he tried to give Vice President Dick Cheney a decent grilling days before the invasion of Iraq.

That March 16, 2003 edition of Meet the Press was a good moment for Russert. By this point, it was clear George W. Bush was committed to attacking Iraq. Still, Russert hurled sharp queries at Cheney, questioning several fundamentals of the Bush-Cheney case for war. Cheney did manage to slip by--but only because he was willing to deny reality:

MR. RUSSERT: If your analysis is not correct, and we're not treated as liberators, but as conquerors, and the Iraqis begin to resist, particularly in Baghdad, do you think the American people are prepared for a long, costly, and bloody battle with significant American casualties?
VICE PRES. CHENEY: Well, I don't think it's likely to unfold that way, Tim, because I really do believe that we will be greeted as liberators….
MR. RUSSERT: The army's top general said that we would have to have several hundred thousand troops there for several years in order to maintain stability.
VICE PRES. CHENEY: I disagree. We need, obviously, a large force and we've deployed a large force to prevail, from a military standpoint, to achieve our objectives, we will need a significant presence there until such time as we can turn things over to the Iraqis themselves. But to suggest that we need several hundred thousand troops there after military operations cease, after the conflict ends, I don't think is accurate. I think that's an overstatement.
MR. RUSSERT: We've had 50,000 troops in Kosovo for several years, a country of just five million people. This is a country of 23 million people. It will take a lot in order to secure it.
VICE PRES. CHENEY: Well, but we've significantly drawn down our forces in Kosovo and in the Balkans…..
MR. RUSSERT: Every analysis said this war itself would cost about $80 billion, recovery of Baghdad, perhaps of Iraq, about $10 billion per year. We should expect as American citizens that this would cost at least $100 billion for a two-year involvement.
VICE PRES. CHENEY: I can't say that, Tim….

There were plenty of times when Russert--like most prominent figures in the media--could be criticized. But this was one of many instances when he posed the right questions and did so in a vigorous and facts-based manner. He did not succeed in forcing Cheney to speak candidly about the challenges of the Iraq war, but, then, Russert was responsible only for the questions he asked, not the answers the politicians gave.






Comments

58 is not very old.

A very sad a somber day.

Posted by: capt on 06/13/08 at 1:51 PM  Respond

He was grossly overweight. Plus a high stress job. Not unexpected.

Posted by: Doc Holiday on 06/13/08 at 4:26 PM  Respond

What's most unfortunate is that if we had Universal Medical Care like Cheney has, would Russert's heart condition been discovered and his heart attack at 58 prevented? The California Nurses Union advertised the following "Vice President Cheney would "probably be dead by now" from his multiple heart attacks if he didn't have federally funded health care that most American's can't get".
http://blogs.abcnews.com/politicalradar/2007/12/nurses-union-ch.html

Posted by: Steve on 06/14/08 at 7:16 AM  Respond

I felt today with the death of Tim Russert the same way I felt on the death of Martin Luther King..A feeling of great loss and sadness..

It is hard to understand the loss of Mr Russert and the continuation of people like Limbaugh and O'Rieley..

Posted by: doober on 06/14/08 at 7:57 AM  Respond

Yo! Doc H.!
Please show some respect for the dead! He was NOT grossly overweight. Your statement is discompassionate and judgemental. Though he may have been stressed to say his death was a result of his weight displays a callousness symptomatic of today's internet lack of decorum. "Check yourself!" as the homies would say on the basketball court. Or judge not lest ye be judged as it's has been said in an ancient text. Tim Russert asked the hard questions and was an avid, respectfful listener who spoke truth and carried on the literary tradition of storytelling to get points across. Something that smart politicians and writers the world over use to get their narrative across to the rest of us. May he rest in peace.

Posted by: treehugger on 06/14/08 at 10:48 AM  Respond

I heard this Heart Attack thing is all a cover-up. I heard he went into a post nomination interveiw with Hillary Clinton yesterday. Two went in, only one came out. They found Russert slumped over his desk with a Emery file jammed between his ribs. That's a "Heart Attack", Belt-Way Style. He tried to shiv her, she pushed back hard! You dont lean on the Clinton homies, they street, Yo Ha Ha

Posted by: Franklin Grimes on 06/14/08 at 6:53 PM  Respond

"Meet the Press" should have been called "For the Record". At least the remarks of a Dick Cheney are preserved for posterity as proof that a Vice President's own words can later bite him in the ass. Thanks Tim!

Posted by: dadpasadena on 06/14/08 at 7:23 PM  Respond

RIP, Tim - Sunday mornings will never be the same :-(

Posted by: Laurie on 06/15/08 at 6:29 AM  Respond

I hope a thorough autopsy is done of his body, as he was just too young to die. And, he wasn't that overweight.

I agree with doober, it would have been better to have been Limbaugh or O'Riley; apparently evil people live on and on because they are evil, but evil has no hope in the hereafter.

Posted by: MarthaA on 06/15/08 at 9:02 AM  Respond

I'll miss him. Wouldn't it have been great if he'd followed up on some of Cheney's answers - had him explain the basis for his disagreements with the experts? Well, guess that wouldn't have allowed Cheney to shape the message as much. It is a sad day for journalism when the greatest point that can be made was not that he uncovered the hidden story or held their feet to the fire, but that he didn't seem to kiss up to the administration as much as most journalists did.

Posted by: Phaedrus on 06/15/08 at 3:49 PM  Respond

The patient was diabetic, and enlarged heart(heart worked too hard due to being grossly overweight), in addition to the high stress job. You all out there in Internet land, take heed, least you be next. Put that hamburger down. Pick up a tomato and lettuce(from California).

Posted by: Doc Holiday on 06/15/08 at 5:10 PM  Respond

Sad indeed. I really enjoyed his work on Sunday mornings.

On a side note, sometimes I really hate the internet. Giving stupid people a voice, and I question the value in that. First off Russert was not "grossly overweight" and your a moron for thinking it. Second, if the death of one person encourages you to wish for the death of others, you are in a sense evil. I really shouldn't expect much else from someone who thinks her points are stronger illustrated by simply CAPITALIZING the cliched talking points of her given ideology. Stupid and shameful.

RIP Tim. You were one of the good ones.

Posted by: dan on 06/16/08 at 8:30 AM  Respond

Doc Holiday:

It seems awfully strange to me that everyone in the media knew just what it was that happened to cause Tim Russert to drop dead, immediately after his death, without an autopsy. Is that supposition or clairvoyance?

Posted by: MarthaA on 06/16/08 at 8:48 AM  Respond

MarthaA, you are overweight. Now how do I know that? I live in Arizona, and I see a lot of overweight people die. That is a leading cause of death. You are only in denial if you don't see the overweight problem in yourself and others.
Tim Russert:
SMOKER? Check.
DIABETIC? Check
OVERWEIGHT? Check
WORKAHOLIC? Check
TRAVELED A LOT? Check.
OVER 50 YEARS OLD? Check.
PRONE TO OUTBURSTS? Check.
ADDICTED TO POLITICS? Check.
FRUSTRATED OVER THE STATE OF THE WORLD? Check.

Why is everyone shocked that a 58-year old man died with these symptoms? A lot of people I've spoken with ask me, "How can a man just drop dead?"

Posted by: Doc Holiday on 06/16/08 at 9:24 AM  Respond

Doc Holiday:

I have seen a lot of people die, but usually in such cases it is from stroke, not dropping dead from their heart stopping.

Wikipedia says that an autopsy was performed Friday evening, right after Russert died, which seems rather fast. Forgive me, but I have never seen people move that fast. Hopefully, his blood and flesh were checked for sedatives of whatever; because, whatever you say, his death could easily have been from other than natural causes.

I only have doubts, because in my humble opinion the cause of death was cut and dried entirely too fast. It is amazing that an autopsy was performed the same evening that he died and the cause arrived at immediately without having any analysis research waiting time at all.

Since, apparently an autopsy has already been accomplished with the heart attack conclusion, there isn't any more to discuss relative to Tim Russert's death, so I have to say que sera sera.

It appears you think only overweight people have heart attacks, but I have seen just as many slim people die of heart attacks as I have overweight people. Sudden heart attack is not strictly overweight people. I have heard sudden heart attack is caused by taking too much iron when one is young, that the iron breaks down the walls of the heart.

Posted by: MarthaA on 06/16/08 at 1:03 PM  Respond

MarthaA, the cure for too much iron in the blood, is a puncture womb. I lived in Tombstone, I speak from experience. Ike got a blood letting, according to the inquest. He didn't need to worry about "high iron" in the blood, it went right through him.

Posted by: Doc Holiday on 06/16/08 at 5:39 PM  Respond

And pigs fly.

Posted by: MarthaA on 06/17/08 at 7:02 AM  Respond

Lord help us not to be going back to Medieval times with LEECHES --- and Anthrax must be a "miasma in the field" to be removed by holy water or smoke. This type of philosophy could not be a LEFT WING Democrat, maybe a DLC RIGHT WING Democrat or a REPUBLICAN EXTREMIST getting us back to our roots. We started with leeches --- we end up with leached -- good social conservatism, wouldn't you say?

Posted by: MarthaA on 06/17/08 at 7:23 AM  Respond

I'm sorry, but I think people have missed the point.

Corn says, "...Russert was responsible only for the questions he asked, not the answers the politicians gave."

There is another responsibility, one that Russert and virtually all MSM personnel have neglected.

They are not "responsible ONLY for the questions they ask", but also equally responsible for the questions they do NOT ask.

As I read through the excerpt of Russert's interview with Cheney presented here, all I kept thinking was that this was merely a public forum for Cheney to deny criticisms, not an honest effort to hold him, or this administration, accountable. This has been the pattern in the media AND in congress during the entire reign of the Bush administration: throw them a question, let them avoid answering it, and pretend you grilled them.

Posted by: rixhex56 on 06/27/08 at 11:04 AM  Respond

thanks a lot dış cephe kaplamaları.

I have seen a lot of people die, but usually in such cases it is from stroke, not dropping dead from their heart stopping.

I have seen a lot of people die, but usually in such cases it is from stroke, not dropping dead from their heart stopping.

hekimboard is good.

teşekürler basri dayı.

thanks ..

Post a comment





 

RECENT COMMENTS

Tim Russert, Dead at 58: Remembering One Q&A with Cheney (25)
mantolama wrote: thanks ..... [more]

McCain's Big Speech: More Prison Cell Than Policy (39)
Marc Sheffler wrote: McCain et al are betting the farm that the voting public n... [more]

Palin is the Right's Obama (1)
Mockingbird wrote: I think that a lot of people are going to start realizing ... [more]

MoJo Video: Palin Puts the Party Back in GOP (15)
Freethinker wrote: McShame!... [more]

Palin's Big Night: A Win for McCain--And a Possible Worry for Democrats (134)
Jim Guinnessey wrote: Let's face facts, it was the secretive GOP insider group t... [more]

Peggy Noonan: "It's Over" (3)
Bruce wrote: Here's another cringworthy note that Noonan is hiding from... [more]

Christian Right Group: "Export Homosexuals" (61)
Dave Fennell wrote: I have met and spoken with many individuals who are agains... [more]

Key Source for Palin's Connection to Alaskan Independence Party Backs Off Account (27)
Nil O'Raly wrote: Just some questions: how many states in the Union have sec... [more]

McCain in NH: Would Be "Fine" To Keep Troops in Iraq for "A Hundred Years" (147)
不動産 wrote: 不動産不動産不&#... [more]

"John Sidney McCain" (22)
laurie wrote: Let's launching the phrase "Sidney Creep" into the blogesp... [more]

XML RSS Feed

Powered by
Movable Type 3.33

Jail.org - Inmate Search
Criminal records, instant public records & people search & current court records. www.jail.org

U.S. Public Records Search
Search County & State Court Records, Criminal records, Vital and Adoption Records www.PublicRecordsInfo.com

Records.com - People Search
Public Records and Background Checks. Instantly Search Criminal Records, Addresses and Court Records www.Records.com

Court Records & County Records
Find Instant Public Records, Criminal Records as Well as County Property Records Search. www.PublicRecordsIndex.com

















Charlie and Sarah

Drill, Baby, Drill

Torches and Pitchforks

Quote of the Day


More MoJo voices...



bookIN PRINT

CLICK HERE
for more great reading

headphones IN TUNE
New music every issue

CLICK TO LISTEN


This article has been made possible by the Foundation for National Progress, the Investigative Fund of Mother Jones, and gifts from generous readers like you.

© 2008 The Foundation for National Progress

About Us   Support Us   Advertise   Ad Policy   Privacy Policy   Contact Us   Subscribe   RSS