MOTHER JONES BY E-MAIL

Shadow Figures: A Portrait of Life on Texas Death Row

Page 2 of 2


TOOLS

EmailE-mail article
PrintPrint article




BACKTALK

E-mail the editor





Google


The majority live out their time in individual cells, 5 feet by 9 feet, equipped with a 6-foot bunk, a steel sink, and a toilet. There's no air conditioning. There is no exercise equipment on the Row. The men clean their own cells. They are issued clean pants and a shirt every three days, and underwear, socks, and a towel every day. Showers, a 10-minute daily ritual, are taken alone.

Those who choose to can work a regular four-hour shift at the garment factory or at a handful of other jobs; some are barbers or Death Row porters, who help serve food to men in lockdown. They are moved to the H wings, where most of them live in double cells, 10 feet by 9 feet, with another man. When a prisoner's execution date arrives, however, he has to leave the work program and move to a higher security Administrative Segregation wing until five days after his stay of execution, if he has received such a stay.

Many men talked about their initial fears in facing Death Row. Once they were convicted and sentenced to die, most believed they would be executed right away. Almost no one anticipates the months or years of waiting, or how living on the Row will change them.

Prisoners spend their time watching TV, reading, writing, listening to the radio, sleeping, and constantly talking. The noise is nonstop -- running conversations, gossip, storytelling, jokes and jive, yells at one another or at shows playing on the TV sets. Guys who aren't restricted "piddle," or make crafts that they sell to pay for stamps, extra food from the commissary, and other items.

The garment factory is the crown jewel of Texas's Death Row. It started as an experiment in 1981 and remains the only prison program in the nation where the entire work force is under a death sentence. Work Capable prisoners are given certain measures of autonomy. The work program is a useful management tool, offering incentives for good behavior that don't otherwise exist for the condemned. The program is controversial among the prisoners, however, and many see it as divisive. Through the years, the privileges given to those who work have helped to create a kind of class system on the Row.

Members of the public who even think about these men generally remember them as they were portrayed when they were caught, or at trial. The death sentence in essence pronounces these men incapable of change, irredeemable, and unfit to live. Once convicted, they become shadow figures, their images frozen in a media frame. But no one is truly suspended in time.

Many of the condemned change dramatically while they are there, some for the better, some for the worse. Other than family and friends of these men, the one group intensely aware of how they change on the Row is family members of their victims. This is another way in which the survivors' lives become unintentionally yet inextricably bound with the condemned, as the survivors track the months and years "their" inmates spend on the Row.

A number of the condemned learn more about themselves while waiting to die than they did in all the years they were free. As one prisoner said, "All we have to talk about is our past," and many spend countless hours trying to make sense of what brought them to Death Row.

Because the conviction and appeals processes appear to be random and arbitrary, and because the men on the Row typically don't have solid information about their cases, explanations infused with superstition about the order of executions have evolved.

Many men believe the Death Row number assigned each prisoner indicates execution order -- the lower the number, the more likely you are to get killed. A variation on this is that when someone with a number near yours gets a date, you soon will, too. The truth is that, since men with low numbers have been there the longest, some anecdotal evidence supports this theory. But judges don't set execution dates by prison numbers. There are also stories of guards having parties before or during executions, and of body parts being sold by the system to medical researchers after executions.

The stories and beliefs are inadvertently supported by the ritualistic way in which the system carries out executions. Every step leading to the final injection is followed, even when the authorities know a court stay is about to be issued -- or has been issued -- to halt the execution.

Thirty-six hours before the appointed time, the man is moved with a few personal effects, like toiletries and writing paper, to the Death Watch cell for observation. He's told to write his will.

The "execution summary" is filled out by the warden at Ellis and then passed along to the warden at the Walls prison, where the death chamber is located.

The prisoner is asked what he wants for a final meal, what color outfit he wishes to wear, and who should be on a final visiting list. An inventory of his property is taken, and he is asked to whom it, as well as any money in his prison account, should be distributed. He is also asked if he wishes to donate his body to the prison medical facility in Galveston or if next of kin will claim the body. The poorest, and the men without family, are buried in the Joe Byrd cemetery, their graves marked only by a simple white cross inscribed with their prison number.

Twenty-four hours before the scheduled execution, the condemned man is taken in shackles to the Walls in a prison van by secret route. Before 1976, execution in Texas was by electric chair, and, until 1995, the killings took place after midnight.

Every movement the prisoner makes in his final hours is observed and logged in excruciating detail by officers, first every 30 minutes, then in 15-minute intervals. At this time the prisoner is entitled to longer visits, and is allowed to call family members and speak to his lawyer. Many men take a shower, brush their teeth, and put on clean clothes before they're taken to the gurney.

Death Row offers society the illusion of finality in the service of justice. It is the "end of the line," yet the ripple effects of each execution reach out and move through us silently, like sound waves. A man takes a life, and we demand that, under specific circumstances, his life be sacrificed in return. When all the legal and political arguments are pushed aside, it seems so basic -- a clean trade. We crave simplicity in executing justice. But there is nothing simple about what we have created in the ritual of executing men.

Ken Light is a social documentary photographer whose published collections include Delta Time, To the Promised Land, With These Hands, and In The Fields. He teaches in the Graduate School of Journalism at the University of California Berkeley.

Suzanne Donovan is a freelance journalist, a former director of the American Civil Liberties Union of Texas, and project specialist for the Texas Council on Family Violence.



 

Post a Comment

Your Name: 

Your Comment: 
 
Please press "Submit" only once to avoid double-posting.
All HTML formatting is removed from comments.
Read the Mother Jones community rules here.

Comments:

Well narrated. I am not here to judge the legality of death penality. But "eye for an eye" theory which the Government seems hell bent on implementing does not justify.Once convicted and then put on hold for 23 hours a day in a solitary cell for years is a punishment itself. Executing a person is just probably freeing him from bondage. A convicted guy has no freedom for years and there have been few cases where Court has found few of them "not guilty." Can we, as Human race, give back the lost time that the inmate has spent in a death row? I am an Indian. I am against death penalty. In India we still have death penalty but rare. But I am against.Killing a person is crime -off course.The convicted person needs to be punished. But if society decides a "closure" by executing, then WE are criminals too. Many convicts probably have killed his/her victim becuase of " sheer madness on that particular moment." But he MAY not a serial killer or Jack the Ripper kind and poses no threat to socity. But when the State decides to execute they do it in "cold blooded" method- a ritual-very methodical, very in-humane. I thought Hinduism and Christanity are a tolerant group. We are civilised lot but only moving back. You are right- its delirium of hatred which has gripped us, society & mankind.We HAVE created a ritual of executing men. You are on dot when you say-Death Row offers society the illusion of finality in the service of justice.....illusion. Execution was and never is a detterent. It will never be. If it were, crimes would have almost dissappeared by now. Its the gap between rich and poor; between the haves and have nots, between previlged and not so preveliged lot, poor educational system ( resulting in growth of relgious fanatics).....this decides number of crime & criminals. I am not a communist nor am I of capatilistic frame of mind.I am human.Live and let live!
Posted by:ParthaJune 6, 2007 10:58:03 AMRespond ^
[deleted]ing america. bad system. dead system.
Posted by:jaJune 6, 2007 5:06:50 PMRespond ^
The death penalty is wrong yes one person chose to do something wrong at a bad time in their life but it doesnnt give any one else the right to put someone to death only god should be able to make that decision it is just not right for a nother person to decide that because they are also killing someones father,brother,son,ect. in that case the cycle shouldnt finish and they should also be put to death.its just another way of people to dignify the evil inside them. when you put someone to death nomatter the surcomstances you are also as guilty as them
Posted by:S.A.June 12, 2007 1:08:07 PMRespond ^
If only we had the Death Penalty in England. Im all for it. If you take a life you should pay with your own.
Posted by:ScouseJune 13, 2007 2:31:03 PMRespond ^
This is a groundbreaking article, a wonderful portrayal of a life without life. The Author is an exquisit writer who manipulates the feelings of the reader with mastery creating simple emoutions which are rarley felt in normal life. Yet i feel that the eye for and eye theory is just but horribly imployed by our system a reasonable stay is 3-9 months because as Partha said spending a total of 83950 hours in your cell in 10 years is a punishment all on its own. The ritualistic fashion of which is done is a near insult to injury. It seems irrational that once a man who has killed another man and is incarcerated and no longer a threat to society should be killed its almost a Dumas, revenge plot. Now a man once incarcerated and no longer a threat to society, he is therefore no longer a threat to society and society as a whole loses interest, but the family of the lost wants a sort of retribution ( an original human feeling) yet that does nothing to avenge the death or right any wrongs all it does is provide retribution. Now as a modern society do we want to perpetuate that kind of mentality, an example would be if you were driving and someone cuts in front of you and you had the oppertunity to do it to them would you? Now, as a family member of a lost one obvioustly the perpitrator should be punish severly but should you afflict on another inoccent bystander the pain and suffering you have felt, or do you have the emoutional maturity almost a Jesus like generosity and forgiving nature to not forgive but to be merciful. As Jesus on teh cross forgave his killers and prayed for them. This death avenging your loss will also cause others, other family members to feel your pain but of course this is human nature and some find security that others have gone through this, but in all fairness I would seek my retribution at all costs. I feel that we as a people as a nation and the human race as a whole should really look into ourselves and our human kindness to fully understand and make an informed decision on this concerversial punishment and then take action on our side.
Posted by:a 13year old from miamiJune 20, 2007 7:57:02 PMRespond ^
I love the way Texas is handling the whole process. I hope that some day the appeals processes will be faster. The only thing that I would like to see happen is that if you shot someone, that is how you should die. Or if we most use a drug to so it then why not use mivacron (mivacurium chloride) it is a lot cheaper then the $86.06, that we spend now. And if they would like to eat and where clothes they should have to make it. Stop making the tax payers have to pay for it, 10 years of food, clothes, water and paying for the other stuff (TV, cable, books, A/C (not at this building) etc.) is for the birds. My kids have to earn what they get. It is not handed to them. When they do stupid stuff they loose what they have worked hard to earn. I would like to let the folks that took the time to write this know that I did learn a few things about the death row. I just think that we should be a little tougher on condemed and other that brake the law
Posted by:FiregirlrennyJune 28, 2007 11:20:33 PMRespond ^
Up until I read 'Willie Shannons' letter and this article I was more in favour of the death penalty than against it, now i am not so sure, ok someone takes anothers life, maybe we should be asking why so many people are commiting murder or other awful crimes that 'give' the criminal the punishment of 'death row', how can a race of people decide who should live or die, sometimes these 'criminals' are just in the wrong place at the wrong time, or reacting to undue pressure, and quite often they were never there in the first place or not in their normal frame of mind, or it's a case of either mistaken identity and/or a 'system' that doesn't care, how many of these people on death row are from poor black families?? when the vast majority of those in the judiciary are typically white middle americans, so how can we ALL as a collective on this earth, decide that for whatever reason that alleged criminal should be treated as less than a human, without the basic needs for life, be subjected to wardens 'watching' almost their every move, who made the warden god all of a sudden? now I am not religous by any stretch of the imagination, but does that not stink of abuse to anyone else reading this??? 'the system' have locked up these people for abusing their time on gods earth, and hold on a minute do we not abuse them by locking them up in way too small cells, without adequate exercise, sometimes infringing their basic human rights of movement and such and do those who lock these people up get put away on death row for that, NO, so who decided that we can play god with peoples lives?? If this is supposed to be a deterrent to people to make them think twice about commiting murder or other henous crimes, why are there so many people waiting on death row, and why are there as many people incarcerated in prisons and jails around the world, it doesnt seem much of a deterrent to me. I am so glad we do not have the 'death penalty' here in England anymore, there were enough people 'we' hanged and some of them were proven innocent, but unfortunately it was way too late for some of them, some crimes can never be proven beyond reasonable doubt, and if someone is to be condemned to death that needs to be totally proven, but does that not make those who 'kill' these alleged criminals a murderer, where is the justice in that, abolish the death penalty.
Posted by:Jen in EnglandJuly 6, 2007 4:40:09 AMRespond ^
The People on D.R. may have done wrong,but if we kill them are we right?Our lord and only him, has the right to take our life!
Posted by:Lissy GermanyJuly 10, 2007 11:13:28 AMRespond ^
I used to be ambivalent about the death penalty. I never really knew anyone who was murdered or who was a murderer. Not personally... This is no longer true. I have family members who have been victims of attempted murder, several times, by two serial stalkers, rapists, and murderers. I, too, am one of their victims. I pray that these two reprobates are executed every single second of my life. In addition, I hope that their families are executed for raising them. This is unrealistic, but it is my wish list. You see...there are far too many innocent victims in the world. And no one speaks for them. The death penalty is the greatest spokesperson for criminally insane scum. I don't give a crap about the criminals' tough childhoods, psychological damages, real or imagined hurts, etc. They have got to leave this planet so that innocent people can exhale. Life is too short to be miserable and terrorized every second of every day. If only the appeals process for death row inmates was non-existent. Often, the inmates live better than homeless people. They have a place to live, sleep, eat, bathe, read, watch TV, etc. This is wrong on so many levels. I used to subscribe to Mother Jones magazine and I still enjoy it when I can. However, issues about the death penalty are personal and relative. Peoples' viewpoints change, based on their life experiences. Good luck everyone.
Posted by:Angel BrownJuly 21, 2007 2:39:00 PMRespond ^
ever seen someone killed ? executing someone for murder is fair and just
Posted by:mark gressleyJuly 30, 2007 10:17:52 AMRespond ^
Does anyone ever give a thought to the crimes these monsters committed??
Posted by:Paul WestAugust 31, 2007 9:52:31 AMRespond ^
Everything on this about deathrow is outdated from 1993. Why not go back to deathrow in tx and update your information. Iam sick of reading what you and ken saw in 1993. Locked down for 23 hours a day, no contact visits w/family even before execution. Even their mother's can't touch them till they are dead, just ask chitown's mother and daughter. TX has killed innocent men that has been proven. They have only poor men on deathrow and some only 18 when they were convicted. Most are black & hispanic & poor white trash. This poor human being's have no money or anybody to help them even if they are innocent. Please update your page.
Posted by:PaulaSeptember 2, 2007 3:33:01 PMRespond ^
Good article. I have researched death row, executions etc for many years. Devoured many many books, researched internet till I can't find any new articles. Before I started my research I was 100% in favour of the death penalty. Now - I am not so sure. I think it should depend on the crime(s) committed, circumstances etc. Although I think if someone killed a member of my family, would I want the death penalty for the murderer?? I only hope I never have to answer that question.
Posted by:Suzanne from IrelandSeptember 5, 2007 6:09:31 AMRespond ^
This is VERY outdated information. Anyone who reads this will think that this is the way it is on deathrow now. There are NO T.V.s., not jobs, etc. I think it would be fantastic if you and Ken could go back and show the country just how bad its gotten in Texas. Things have really changed for the worst.
Posted by:MassSeptember 23, 2007 9:46:56 AMRespond ^
I was born and raised in Huntsville, TX.. My father has worked for TDCJ For 25 years and is now a Warden for the prison system. I grew up on the Estelle Unit... "Ellis II" As It Was Called When I Lived There. I could smell what the men were having for breakfast, they mowed our yard, maintnanced any issues in our housing and of course always did my fathers laundry and hair cutting. It's a different lifestyle, even for those that are living on the outside of those cement walls. I grew up in a family consumed by the prison system. Both of my uncles, my only other family, were also involved in the Prison system. One was an Internal Investigator for TDC and the other a Luitennant at Estelle. The death penalty is a touchy subject. For one, how can we teach a nation that killing is wrong, by killing in return? Eye for an Eye maybe... but, ethical? Who's to know. I have had very conflicting feelings on the issue for as long as i can remember. I recall being a young child, enquiring about the death penalty and why some men had to face it, while others, whom have committed the same crime are damned to LIFE in prison. However, as i've grown older and come to understand that life is far more precious than i ever though as a child i have realized some things. visit www.tdcj.com and click on the tab that says "offender information" you can then view Death Row Information, including a summary of the crimes these men and women have committed. If a man was to ever rape, brutalized, maim, dismember and murder my mother.. i would want his life taken. I would beg for the death penalty. When put into perspective, a personal linkage, opinions seem to change. People that are living on death row have obviously committed an atroscious crime that has landed them there. It's unfortunate, but it's reality.
Posted by:Courtney COctober 18, 2007 2:37:08 PMRespond ^
Extremely Well written. It gave a fantastic insight into everyday experience to live on Death Row. Death is not the answer. I believe that whilst, there is most certainly death row inmates with personality disorders, there is also the high majority who are poor and have been let down by society because other than crime and drugs, they really don't have anything going for them. America needs to give them the Life Sentence not the death sentence. Inmates can at least spend the rest of their life learning about their mistakes and changing, even if they are trapped behind bars. There is no point in preaching about not killing your fellow man, when the texas justice system does just that by the lethal injection. It obviously hasn't worked because new inmates are still coming to death row...perhaps texas needs to focus on their social problems instead of killing inmates?
Posted by:JagNovember 6, 2007 3:41:49 PMRespond ^
Killing another human being is inherently wrong, no matter what the circumstances. I don’t feel comfortable granting any government the authority to kill one of it’s own citizens, for any reason. In Washington State, one of the worlds worse murderers, the green river killer, is locked up n solitary confinement, spending most of his time in a miniature cell, with occasional exercise time spent in a dog cage. Why should we grant him an early release through a fully anesthetized execution? A brief, painless procedure for all the great pain that he has caused. Are we so sure of his punishment in the afterlife? He’ll have the remaining decades of his existence to think abut it, sitting alone in his dog cage. Better to leave him there and let God decide his release date.
Posted by:Floyd GreenNovember 6, 2007 9:13:22 PMRespond ^
this is a touchy subject! The ritual of executing men/women seems very harsh but justice does have a price.
Posted by:elaine claussenNovember 21, 2007 5:46:43 PMRespond ^
One hour of solitary recreation each day. No work, no tv, only a radio. Non sexual magazines can be mailed in as well as newspapers. The rest of the time is in your solitary cell with a solid steel door. So there's no card playing by reaching "through the bars" etc.,. I say this is "wonderful." :)
Posted by:BuzzCDecember 30, 2007 7:33:54 PMRespond ^
wow thats amazing! very interesting!
Posted by:skJanuary 4, 2008 10:05:02 AMRespond ^
I BELIEVE THAT THE DEATH PENALTY IS GREAT! FOR THOSE WORTHLESS PEOPLE IN OUR SOCIETY THAT THINKS IT'S OKAY FOR ANY REASON TO KILL ANOTHER. I DON'T CARE HOW MUCH THEY MAY OR MAY NOT CHANGE ON DEATH ROW, I JUST WISH THEY'D GET TO THEM A LITTLE FASTER RATHER THAN WASTE OUR MONEY ON KEEPING THEM THERE. FOR THOSE THAT ARE AGAINST IT, I'M ASSUMING YOU'VE NEVER HAD SOMEONE EITHER IN YOUR FAMILY OR A CLOSE FRIEND THAT HAS BEEN MURDERED IN COLD BLOOD! I HAVE I KNOW WHAT IT DOES AND IT WOULD MAKE YOU FEEL SO MUCH BETTER TO KNOW THAT THE PERSON WHO DID IT IS NO LONGER CAPABLE OF EVER HARMING SOMEONE AGAIN.
Posted by:LADY FROM TEXASJanuary 11, 2008 6:36:57 AMRespond ^
to firegirlrenny: I will pray for you.
Posted by:servantJanuary 18, 2008 7:19:56 PMRespond ^
Hey,jus wanna say about the death penalty.These people who side up for these terrible murders don,t seem to see the other side.If they too were victims of crime,U bet they would want some form of punishment for his or her crimes to pay dearly for their crimes.We as citizens of this planet,well the law-abidin ones anyway need the law to protect society from people who commit horrible crimes.As much as I too hate to hear of someone gettin the death penalty,"BUT" again these(murderers,criminals etc )cross that line that is put there for people to abide by don,t heed this warning.Well U can bet what my answer will be horsedance
Posted by:horsedanceMarch 26, 2008 11:15:45 AMRespond ^
Hey,jus wanna say about the death penalty.These people who side up for these terrible murders don,t seem to see the other side.If they too were victims of crime,U bet they would want some form of punishment for his or her crimes to pay dearly for their crimes.We as citizens of this planet,well the law-abidin ones anyway need the law to protect society from people who commit horrible crimes.As much as I too hate to hear of someone gettin the death penalty,"BUT" again these(murderers,criminals etc )cross that line that is put there for people to abide by don,t heed this warning.Well U can bet what my answer will be horsedance
Posted by:horsedanceMarch 26, 2008 11:15:46 AMRespond ^
Interesting how some people moan and groan about executing someone convicted of killing another human and in most cases horribly. But yet these same people demand(!!!) the murder of an innocent child within 8 months. Over forty million child murders since 1976 ... but the media only counts the one thousand executions of killers.
Posted by:Rikki DoxApril 5, 2008 8:42:39 AMRespond ^
are u kidding me? who do you think came up with the death penalty? if you go back and read the laws God set down in the old testement of the bible the penalty for breaking almost any law was death. disrespect your parents and they could take you outside the city and stone you to death. harsh but God came up with this because some people need to pay the ultimate price for the horrible things they have done. i believe in eye for an eye justice! And YES im PROUD TO BE A TEXAN!!!
Posted by:madkatters02April 14, 2008 10:50:51 PMRespond ^
oh and furthermore i think that we should execute them in the most fitting way according to their crimes. lethal injection is too easy of a death for some of these monsters!!!
Posted by:madkatters02April 14, 2008 11:02:49 PMRespond ^
This Article Really Helped With A Paper I'm Writing!
Thanks So Much For This! I Hope To Read More Of Your Work In The Future!
Posted by:HannahApril 30, 2008 8:27:04 AMRespond ^

Jail.org - Inmate Search
Criminal records, instant public records & people search & current court records. www.jail.org

U.S. Public Records Search
Search County & State Court Records, Criminal records, Vital and Adoption Records www.PublicRecordsInfo.com

Records.com - People Search
Public Records and Background Checks. Instantly Search Criminal Records, Addresses and Court Records www.Records.com

Court Records & County Records
Find Instant Public Records, Criminal Records as Well as County Property Records Search. www.PublicRecordsIndex.com
















bookIN PRINT

CLICK HERE
for more great reading

headphones IN TUNE
New music every issue

CLICK TO LISTEN


This article has been made possible by the Foundation for National Progress, the Investigative Fund of Mother Jones, and gifts from generous readers like you.

© 1997 The Foundation for National Progress

About Us   Support Us   Advertise   Ad Policy   Privacy Policy   Contact Us   Subscribe   RSS