Sicko in the House
News: By some miracle, no one got hurt at Michael Moore's screening on Capitol Hill—not even the Republican.
June 21, 2007
|
|
It's ironic, but outside of hospitals and day care centers, perhaps the best place to acquire some kind of illness on Wednesday in Washington, D.C., was at Michael Moore's press conference on Capitol Hill. The long lines and the sweaty, claustrophobic committee room were emblematic of the enthusiasm that Moore's appearance and Sicko, his new film on the decrepit state of U.S. healthcare, have generated both in Washington and around the country.
Behind the podium from which Moore and influential House Democrats spoke and answered questions, an array of sign-wielding activists stood along the back wall. Facing them from the other side of the room, women from the group Code Pink lofted a large, painted sign reading, "Healthcare now, for all." At one point, a security officer approached them about lowering the banner. Clearly ambivalent about his duty, he gave them a thumbs up.
The film, characterized by Moore's usual mix of wry humor contrasted sharply with somber personal narratives, traces the health care crisis back to the early 1970s when Richard Nixon, under pressure from Edgar Kaiser, helped launch the Health Maintenance Organization (HMO) system. That system is the prime cause, according to Moore and many others, of problems such as lack of insurance, underinsurance, and adverse selection that have caused our health care standards to topple well below those of other wealthy nations, including France, Germany, and Japan, all of which have government-paid universal health care systems. Today, as Moore noted both on Capitol Hill and in his film, there are four health care lobbyists in Washington for every member of Congress.
The high point of yesterday's hearing—the part that most resembled a scene in a Michael Moore movie—occurred when Rep. John Conyers (D-Mich.), chair of the House Judiciary Committee, spotted Rep. Darryl Issa (R-Calif.) standing quietly in the back of the room. Conyers thanked Issa "for making this a bipartisan issue," and invited him to stand in front of the crowd. Issa gestured in protest, making a cut-throat gesture at his neck, but to no avail. He was cowed into standing with Moore and the Democrats anyhow.
When Issa finally spoke, he did so extemporaneously, joking that his scheduler must have forgotten to inform him of this engagement. Then he reached for common ground, calling health care a "bipartisan issue," approvingly citing Gov. Arnold Schwarzenegger's health care plan for California, and suggesting that, while the parties "may differ on the specifics," Congress and the president "must take steps toward universal access."
On those specifics, Issa differs wildly from either Schwarzenegger or most Democrats. Schwarzenegger, one of a small handful of governors to aim to bring his state's health coverage anywhere near universality, recently enacted an individual mandate to buy insurance that will cover almost everybody in California. His policy sits somewhere in between Conyers' single-payer plan to provide Medicare for all, and a much more incremental plan Issa drew up in 2005, which would help some business owners secure health coverage for their employees via tax credits.
Aside from Moore, the loudest applause of the afternoon went to Rep. Maxine Waters (D-Calif.), who beseeched universal health care activists not to "get in bed with the right wing who means us no good." Conyers, for his part, compared his work on the health care bill, H.R. 676, to his efforts years ago to make Martin Luther King, Jr.'s birthday a national holiday. Back then, as today, he told the crowd, many of his colleagues said to him "you have a great idea, but you know you can't win."
After the hearing, Moore headed out to a theater in Washington's Union Station to hold yet another free screening—food and drink provided—for anybody in the city who has a career lobbying on behalf of private health care companies. No word yet on how many people attended.
Brian Beutler is the Washington correspondent for the Media Consortium, a network of progressive media organizations.
