Bad News Baer

The former CIA agent talks about suicide bombers and his dark vision of what Iran?s really up to.

Wed July 5, 2006 12:00 AM PST

But who are these people? I immediately jumped to the pat answer that they were psychologically disturbed. Over the years this has been broken down and proved to be wrong. Israeli intelligence has summed it up for me: There is no profile. You’ve got a 47-year-old man with seven children blowing himself up, you have a Lebanese girl—Christian, attractive, young—she blows herself up for nationalism. You have the famous case of a Palestinian woman who was married with two children, had an affair, husband finds out about it. The husband and boyfriend get together and say the way they’re going to solve this problem is by having her blow herself up. And she did.

MJ.com: When you talked with the family members of suicide bombers, they told you they were happy that their children had become martyrs. Do you think that’s just what they tell the cameras, or is that emotion genuine?

RB: Could be. This woman in Tehran was very categorical about it. She said, “suicide is when you have serious personal problems and feel there’s no way out. But we have political reasons.” It’s a sensitive subject; they don’t want to be labeled as having personal problems; it’s political—[they say] their relative died for a purpose, not to wreak havoc. You can reduce it to things like humiliation. There is a feeling of humiliation—“The Israelis are killing us with M-16s; we’re being invaded by the United States in Iraq; our identity is being attacked; we have no way to address grievances except suicide bombings.” It’s all about grievances.

MJ.com: Speaking Arabic, can you get more of the story than a typical Western journalist might have?

RB: Speaking Arabic, you can go in you and just chitchat. I went to a Hezbollah school and was talking to these young girls whose dads had blown themselves up. They’re just teenage girls. I asked them what kind of TV they watch; they said Oprah. And I said, “Come on, you’re sitting here on the border of Israel, at war with the Israelis, and you’re watching Oprah?” They said, “We love Oprah!” And then you ask the obvious question: “If the Israelis invaded again, would you sacrifice a brother, a father?” “Absolutely.” So you have these two worlds.

MJ.com: As a former CIA officer, were you nervous hanging out with Hezbollah or visiting Lebanon’s Bekaa Valley?

RB: No, because they’re sophisticated. It’s not like dealing with the Khmer Rouge or Zarqawi. You wouldn’t tell Zarqawi, “Don’t worry, I’m with the press”—he’d still cut your head off. But you have to be aware of what stage of resistance they’re in. You wouldn’t want to be doing this film in 1984; you wouldn’t be coming back. But now in Lebanon, Hezbollah is ascendant, the Iranians are sophisticated—they obviously agreed to this film. I assume they knew who I was.

MJ.com: In the film, you note that there are more suicide bombings in Iraq in one month than there are in Israel in a year. But in Iraq, it seems that this is not just a reaction to occupation but another tactic in a civil war.

RB: Well, you’ve unleashed hatreds that have been submerged for years. You’ve got the Sunnis cutting the heads off of heads of Shiites and putting them in boxes. We have split open this volcano. We have no control over it. I think the neocons have done more damage to the United States’ reputation and foreign policy than anybody since—I don’t know when. They’ve opened Pandora’s box in Iraq.

MJ.com: You think that Iran started a “secret war” against the United States in Lebanon. What do you mean?

RB: They started off by taking us on directly, when they kidnapped [American University president] David Dodge and took him to Tehran. They brought him back and released him. Then they used surrogates. The idea was to get us out of Lebanon and completely get rid of American influence—journalists, diplomats, everybody. And it worked.

MJ.com: So, if Iran’s been fighting the U.S. since Lebanon, why are we just hearing about it as a threat now?

RB: It’s pure spin. We deal with it superficially. We follow current events; we get a paragraph in the newspaper about Zarqawi or whatever it is. And then we get on with life. It’s not the way [the Iranians] deal with the world. They think they’re in mortal combat against the United States. Their survival is based on this conflict. Our attitude is, “Give us the oil.” We don’t take this part of the world seriously and yet it is so important to us. Iran has always been looked at like a crazy uncle in the attic: Every once in a while he starts knocking things around and breaks a window, but otherwise we just ignore him.

Get Mother Jones by Email - Free. Like what you're reading? Get the best of MoJo three times a week.
Comments
no profile pic for comment author

Is his recent Pro-IRGC article in Time Magazine entitled "Are The Iranians Out For Revenge"... Bob Baer makes the following statements.

"Some Iraqis speculate that the IRGC has already started a campaign of revenge with the killing of five American soldiers in Karbala on Jan. 20, nine days after the arrest of the IRGC members in Erbil. As the logic of the rumor goes, five American soldiers were killed for five Iranians taken; Karbala was an IRGC message to release its colleagues — or else."

Mr. Baer maybe a former CIA operative, but he is apparently not much of an expert on war, or the unsurpassed capacity of the US military and particularly US Spec Ops forces. The detainment of five leading members of the Iranain "Quds Force" by US Special Forces, is just the latest in a series of severe attacks suffered by Iran at the hands of the vastly superior US military machine. The attack in Karbala may have killed five soldiers, but it didn't result in the capture or killing of five US generals, so in the scheme of things it was hardly an equal response. Unlike the 1980's (When America had the means and capabilities of decimating Hezbollah and IRGC members in response to the attacks that Bob Baer recounts in his
article, but did not do so) America today has even more capabilities against Iran, and is in fact using them.

The IRGC and Quds force maybe potent, but they are hardly a match for the US Military, and are in no way a match for units like Delta Force, SEAL Team Six, or the CIA'S SAD, which can and will strike Iran's best, anytime and anyplace in Iraq, Lebanon or elsewhere. Perhaps Mr. Baer should get off of the IRGC payroll and join the winning team, or at least get his facts straight before he writes another un-informed article.

no profile pic for comment author

o

شات-العاب-منتدى الفتاة
المسلمة

صوتيات
و مرئيات و اناشيد اسلامية

المنتدى
العام

منتدى
الترحيب بالاعضاء الجدد

منتدى النقاش
الجاد

العاب
منتديات بنات ستايل

نكت و طرائف
السياحة و
السفر

ازياء و موضة
اكسسوارات و
مجوهرات

ميك اب و
مكياج

فساتين سهرة
و زفاف

تسريحات
واخر موضات الشعر

العناية
بالبشرة و الشعر

ركن العطور
و البخور و مساحيق التجميل

ديكور و
اثاث المنازل

مول بنات
ستايل

اطباق
رئيسيه

حلويات و
معجنات و عصيرات

سلطات

روايات
ادبية
- همس الخواطر
قصص و
حكايات

شعر و قصائد

المنتدى
الطبي العام

المشاكل
النفسية و الاجتماعية و العاطفية

الامومة و
الطفولة

منتدى الصور
و الغرائب

تصاميم و
ابداعات العضوات

مسجات
ثيمات جوال
برامج
كمبيوتر و جوال

اخبار الفن
و الفنانين
-a1-شات
الرياض


دردشة صوتية
-العاب
بنات
-العاب باربي-العاب
مغامرات
-العاب سباق دراجات-العاب
ذكاء
-العاب متنوعة-العاب
قص الشعر
-العاب تلبيس-العاب
تلوين
-العاب ديكور-العاب
مطاردات سريعة
-العاب رياضية-العاب
تلبيس عرايس
-العاب طبخ-العاب
حربية
-العاب قتالية-العاب
افلام كرتون
-العاب مكياج-العاب
سباق سيارات
-العاب ورق-العاب
اطفال
-منتديات-مركز
تحميل برق
---ارشيف-الارشيف

-بنات ستايل-منتديات
بنات ستايل
-ارشيف بنات-business
directory
-business-health-xml-map-
بنات ستايل-منتديات
بنات ستايل
-توبيكات
بنات
-العاب بنات-ارشيف
بنات
-منتديات فتيات-منتدى
عام
-نقاش جاد-نكت
وطرائف
-سياحة وسفر-موضة-اكسسوارات-مكياج-فساتين
سهرة
-تسريحات-البشرة-ديكور-عالم
حواء
-اطباق رئيسيه-حلويات
و معجنات
-سلطات-روايات
ادبية
-همس القوافي-قصص-اشعار-منتديات
طبية
-عيادات نفسية-منتديات
الامومة و الطفولة
-منتديات
الصور
-مسجات بنات
ستايل
-ثيمات جوالات-برامج
كمبيوتر و جوال
-اخبار
الفنانين

no profile pic for comment author

It definately was the authenticity that got me into the theatre, and got me hooked on Robert Baer's books.

no profile pic for comment author

tiffany jewelry

That little blue box - everyone woman dreams of seeing it come their way. tiffany jewelry jewelry is world renowned for its stunning quality and top of the line artisanship; however, it also has a reputation for having a price tag that is way out of most people's leagues.
discount tiffany jewelry That doesn't mean you can't get that Tiffany look you want at a price you can afford, however. Thanks to replica Tiffany jewelry, you can look like you are draped in Tiffany jewelry, and yet still have the money left in your pocket to go out and show off your looks.

Post a comment
Alternately, you may login to or register an account
The content of this field is kept private and will not be shown publicly.
  • Web page addresses and e-mail addresses turn into links automatically.
  • Allowed HTML tags: <a> <ul> <ol> <li> <blockquote> <img>
  • Lines and paragraphs break automatically.

More information about formatting options


Jail.org - Inmate Search
Criminal records, instant public records & people search & current court records. www.jail.org

U.S. Public Records Search
Search County & State Court Records, Criminal records, Vital and Adoption Records www.PublicRecordsInfo.com

Records.com - People Search
Public Records and Background Checks. Instantly Search Criminal Records, Addresses and Court Records www.Records.com

Court Records & County Records
Find Instant Public Records, Criminal Records as Well as County Property Records Search. www.PublicRecordsIndex.com

Mother Jones Podcast
Get in on the conversation! We talk about culture, politics, the environment, the economy and more. Listen now!

TalkBackTees.com
A treasure trove of liberal wit, wisdom and quotations, from ancient to modern, on colorful, cotton tees.

Support Independent Artists
Amazing art, crafts, apparel, paper-goods and more. A carefully curated selection of sundries since 1999.

FREE CONNECTIONS FOR GREEN SINGLES
Meet progressive singles in the environmental, vegetarian & animal rights community who share your values