«--Previous Post | Blog Index | Next Post--»
The Hidden Cameras' Anti-Marriage Sentiments Way Ahead of Their Time
Like Jonathan, I'm profoundly disappointed about the apparent passage of California's Proposition 8. While he managed to look to the future, reminding us that this is a battle we'll eventually win, I'm ticked off right now, sick of having nuptials dangled in our face only to be snatched away again, pissed off that people get to vote on this. My fellow angry queers and sympathetic straights are already proposing a radical solution: ban marriage entirely. That seems like a fine idea to me--plus, if the movement takes off, we'll have a theme song all ready to go! Back in 2003, Canadian combo The Hidden Cameras released a wildly underappreciated album called The Smell of Our Own. The music was a celebratory cross between the Polyphonic Spree, the Magnetic Fields, and Neutral Milk Hotel, but lyrically, they crossed even more boundaries, refusing to hide their sexuality behind coy double-entendres or bland generalities. The song "Ban Marriage" whips the musicians into an uptempo frenzy, but the lyrics are complex, with the protagonist's wedding to another man disrupted by cries "to let coupledom die." Is it an anti-assimilation tirade in defense of promiscuity, a dream of equality, or an expression of hopeless isolation? Whatever it really means, it's great, and its joyous three-chord pattern is helping calm my fury. But you breeders aren't getting any more wedding presents from me until we get this shit worked out, I'll tell you that right now.
Video of a live show after the jump.
The Hidden Cameras - "Ban Marriage" (live in Sweden, 2006)
Comments
Dear Angry Queer -
Please understand that radicals on both sides of this issue are using it to push their own agendas.
Banning marriage isn't terribly practical; however, getting government out of the marriage business may be. The hang-up many people of faith have with gays getting "married" is that marriage is first and foremost a spiritual institution. They perceive - and rightfully so - that radicals on the other side are using this issue to push an agenda far beyond legal rights for same-sex couples.
The rhetoric from the pro-gay marriage forces equating this issue with miscegenation laws hits the ears of many people - myself included - who would otherwise be quite sympathetic to your plight entirely the wrong way. We know from the Biblical description that Moses' wife was a Black woman, not a Black man. The Old Testament Prophet practiced miscegenation. He did not lay down with a person of the same gender. As far as the vast majority of people are concerned, the Bible and the Qur'an are unambiguous on the issue of homosexuality.
By insisting, however, that marriage remain a blessing bestowed by the government, the Christian Right is continuing to use marriage as the camel's nose in the tent to further an agenda of pushing their morality through the force of government institutions, and keeping the hope of theocratic creep alive.
The gay community has an amazing opportunity here to gain allies on the libertarian side of the political spectrum - the same right-wing folks who believe balls to bones that pot should be legal - by arguing that the government should only sanction civil unions between consenting adults regardless of gender, and that the blessings of marriage must be left to the individual churches and religious institutions.
In short, gays can gain truly equal status under the law - in perception and in fact (the fact part is already largely there in many states, including California) - by making this an argument about the separation of church and state.
Asking tens of millions of people nationwide who believe with all their hearts that they can love gays but hate the sin of homosexuality to take the leap of compromising one of the most basic and sacred of spiritual institutions is the gay movement's bridge too far. A more enlightened recognition that a secular government has no business dictating the boundaries of a spiritual institution - IOW, the government should be telling churches who they can and cannot marry - is the gay community's best chance of attaining unambiguous equal status under the law for same-sex couples.
I worked for over a year to get President Obama elected. Now, it appears that the large black turnout in California, 70% of whom, voted to ban gay marriage. We seem to have worse discrimination against our gay brothers and sisters. What a disappointment!
Posted by:
Sandy
on 11/07/08 at 12:55 PM Respond
Simple solution for the hate: tax religion. Treat organized religion like the infomercial that it is.
Posted by:
Ralphie
on 11/07/08 at 2:07 PM Respond
CHICAGO - Coretta Scott King, speaking four days before the 30th anniversary of her husband's assassination, said Tuesday the civil rights leader's memory demanded a strong stand for gay and lesbian rights.
"I still hear people say that I should not be talking about the rights of lesbian and gay people and I should stick to the issue of racial justice," she said. "But I hasten to remind them that Martin Luther King Jr. said, 'Injustice anywhere is a threat to justice everywhere.'"
"I appeal to everyone who believes in Martin Luther King Jr.'s dream to make room at the table of brother- and sisterhood for lesbian and gay people," she said.
"Gays and lesbians stood up for civil rights in Montgomery (and) Selma (Alabama), in Albany, Georgia, and St. Augustine, Florida, and many other campaigns of the civil rights movement," King said.
She said she saluted the contributions "of these courageous men and women" who fought "for my freedom at a time when they could find few voices for their own."
and that is why a lot of gay folk feel as if we were thrown under the bus
Posted by:
hjpowell
on 11/07/08 at 2:46 PM Respond
ARCHIVE
RECENT COMMENTS
The Best Albums of 2008 (1)
SecretCode wrote:
If you thought Kanye had something to bring to the SNL tab...
[more]
Melissa Etheridge Meets with Rick Warren, Responds to Controversy (1)
a wrote:
Etheridge is out of her mind. Obama is no real friend to ...
[more]
Some Writerly Advice (2)
earledj wrote:
the problem is that professional writers always need some...
[more]
Why Tina Fey Had to Get All Tarted Up (1)
earledj wrote:
Tina Fey didn't become popular from being a sex symbol. M...
[more]
The Best Singles of 2008 (1)
Lea wrote:
Well, well. I do adore LES Artistes - it's amazing, and it...
[more]
CD Review: Lil Wayne - Tha Carter III (15)
reid allmaras wrote:
well the carter album is seriously overrated and weezy doe...
[more]
NPR Lays Off Staff, Cuts Shows (1)
Old Hand wrote:
PBS and NPR are both ridiculously underfunded by the gover...
[more]
Coldplay Deny Plagiarism Accusation, Get Dissed By Reuters (2)
Old Hand wrote:
PS - Thanks for that. I've been sleeping on indie rock sin...
[more]
Thoughts on Milk (1)
electriclady281 wrote:
I'm not gay, but I fail to understand the callous way that...
[more]
YouTube Wrapup: Kermit Sings LCD Soundsystem, Pole Dancing Robots, Mashup Mayhem, Walrus Saxophone Action (1)
Old Hand wrote:
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=gjTBH4_4pO0&feature=related...
[more]
Movable Type 3.33


Posted by: mheister
on 11/07/08 at 12:55 PM Respond