First "Best of 2008" Album List Very Wrong, Very White

Kids, this right here is more proof that sometimes it's better to take it slow than rush to be first. Stereogum points out that Paste Magazine is the first major publication to drop their "Best Albums of 2008" list, and while there are some good and interesting albums all up and down it, the order (and the omissions) are kind of head-slapping. Here's their Top 10:

10 Deerhunter - Microcastle (Kranky)
09 Lucinda Williams - Little Honey (Lost Highway)
08 Sun Kil Moon - April (Caldo Verde)
07 Girl Talk - Feed the Animals (Illegal Art)
06 Fleet Foxes - Fleet Foxes (Sub Pop)
05. Okkervil River - The Stand Ins (Jagjaguwar)
04. Bon Iver - For Emma, Forever Ago (Jagjaguwar)
03. Vampire Weekend - Vampire Weekend (XL)
02. Sigur Rós - Med sud i eyrum vid spilum endalaust (XL)
01. She & Him - Volume One (Merge)

You read that right: She & Him, #1 album of the year. My current top two faves, TV on the Radio and Portishead, landed at #50 and nowhere, respectively. And we all know how I feel about Sigur Ros. But there's something even more nefarious about this list, and that's its blinding whiteness.

Out of all the Top 50, I count only five albums with non-white contributors: two by Santogold, and one each from Lil Wayne, Thao Nguyen, and the TV on the Radio guys. Of course, one could note that three of those had major involvement from white people as well. Musical taste, and lists of this sort, are, obviously, subjective, and I don't mean to levy any charges of racism at the fine folks at Paste. But I will levy charges of closed-minded stupidity. If they had named this the Top 50 Folk Albums of the Year, I might be more sympathetic, but clearly they're making a half-hearted attempt to be musically inclusive. It's symbolic that Girl Talk's Feed the Animals landed at #7: while it's a fine album of attention-deficit mashup ridiculousness, capturing some of the euphoria of his live shows, it mostly features hip-hop vocals, so it's by far the highest placement of any non-white contributors on their list, if you want to think of it that way. I guess Paste likes their hip-hop well enough, but only if it's scrubbed clean of its original thumpiness and layered over some classic rock?

Comments

After all of the inane crap I've read on your blog, this was the one that finally motivated me to sign up for typepad so I can tell you how I feel. I think it's no coincidence that the worst blog on this site also happens to be the only one that requires a typepad account, but I digress...

It's PASTE, what did you want? I mean Jesus, when they started that rag, it was like the AARP version of No Depression. I haven't bothered picking one up in the last seven years, but it's a freaking AAA magazine. They threw in a few palatable choices from different genres in an attempt to mix it up a little, but you can't really take this seriously as an end-of-the-year list. Let me guess, next you are going to bitch that the Source didn't put enough freak-folk in their list?

Posted by: Old Hand on 11/21/08 at 3:17 PM Respond

Take a good listen to "Elephant Revival" from Colorado. Their first CD has great music on every cut. Mark my words if this band stays together for awhile you will hear of them. But then, you just did.

First "Best of 2008" Album List Very Wrong, Very White

Comments

ARCHIVE

RECENT COMMENTS

THE CURRENT ISSUE

SEARCH MOTHER JONES

PHOTO ESSAYS

TODAY ON...

SPECIAL REPORTS

INTERVIEWS

LETTERS

BLOG LINKS

Blog Reader Project Survey

IN PRINT

DONATE TODAY