Is It Really Illegal to Make Undercover Recordings in California?

Fight disinformation: Sign up for the free Mother Jones Daily newsletter and follow the news that matters.


I Am Still Not A Lawyer, and I don’t want to go too far down this rabbit hole, but I’ve gotten a fair amount of pushback to my post last night suggesting that the folks who did the undercover Planned Parenthood videos shouldn’t be prosecuted. The pushback takes two forms. First, they’re horrible people who did horrible things. Second, California law requires consent from both parties for any kind of recording, and they broke that law. They should pay for this.

As to the first, I agree that they did horrible things and endangered people. But that’s not what they’re charged with. As to the second, California law (link here) is not as clear-cut as you might think:

If a real live California attorney with specific experience in this area wants to chime in, I’m all ears. For now, though, no matter how much I loathe what they did, I don’t like the idea of prosecuting people for political activities unless their violation of the law is very serious and very clear. This is neither.

Criminal prosecution of secret recordings is rare in California, and I’d just as soon keep it that way. There’s a huge amount of prosecutorial discretion involved in this case, and that’s a recipe for political retaliation against ideas we don’t like. That’s where I get off the train.

UPDATE: Then again, we have this:

The penal code is stricter than the civil code, “but excludes a communication made in a public gathering.” I don’t know if this refers only to public meetings (town halls, protests, etc.) or to any public place, like a restaurant. Probably the former.

This is all kind of strange. Why would there be an “investigatory” exception for lawsuits but not for criminal prosecutions?

BEFORE YOU CLICK AWAY!

Mother Jones was founded to do journalism differently. We stand for justice and democracy. We reject false equivalence. We go after stories others don’t. We’re a nonprofit newsroom, because the kind of truth-telling investigations we do doesn’t happen under corporate ownership.

And the essential ingredient that makes all this possible? Readers like you.

It’s reader support that enables Mother Jones to devote the time and resources to report the facts that are too difficult, expensive, or inconvenient for other news outlets to uncover. Please help with a donation today if you can—even a few bucks will make a real difference. A monthly gift would be incredible.

payment methods

BEFORE YOU CLICK AWAY!

Mother Jones was founded to do journalism differently. We stand for justice and democracy. We reject false equivalence. We go after stories others don’t. We’re a nonprofit newsroom, because the kind of truth-telling investigations we do doesn’t happen under corporate ownership.

And the essential ingredient that makes all this possible? Readers like you.

It’s reader support that enables Mother Jones to devote the time and resources to report the facts that are too difficult, expensive, or inconvenient for other news outlets to uncover. Please help with a donation today if you can—even a few bucks will make a real difference. A monthly gift would be incredible.

payment methods

We Recommend

Latest

Sign up for our free newsletter

Subscribe to the Mother Jones Daily to have our top stories delivered directly to your inbox.

Get our award-winning magazine

Save big on a full year of investigations, ideas, and insights.

Subscribe

Support our journalism

Help Mother Jones' reporters dig deep with a tax-deductible donation.

Donate