«--Previous Post | Blog Index | Next Post--»
White House: What Missing Emails?

Today, the White House dramatically changed its tune on the 5 to 10 million emails reportedly missing from its servers. Since early 2007, the administration has repeatedly acknowledged (to the press and Congress) that it had experienced a "technical issue" and that a still unknown quantity of emails might not have been archived, as required by the Presidential Records Act. But, asked by reporter about the missing emails today at a White House press conference, Tony Fratto, the deputy press secretary, contradicted the administration's previous statements.
Q: ...I've taken a real sky view of this particular story, but— so it was wrong to say a few months ago that there were possibly millions of emails missing?
MR. FRATTO: I think those charges [of the 5 million missing emails] came from outside the White House. I think that's the charge of one of the—
Q: One of your colleagues [Perino] addressed those from the podium and suggested that that was accurate‹again, I'm taking—
MR. FRATTO: I'm not sure what was said on that. I can tell you today, though, that we have no evidence and we have no way of showing that any emails at all are missing.
Anne Weismann, the chief counsel of Citizens for Responsibility and Ethics in Washington (CREW), one of the groups suing the Bush administration to ensure the preservation of the missing emails, called Fratto's comments "an outrage."
"There's objective evidence that [there's an email problem]," she said. "The White House is apparently making statements left and right that are contradictory with each other."
Indeed, Fratto's take on the missing emails is at odds with what his boss, White House Press Secretary Dana Perino, has told the press on more than one occasion. On April 13, 2007, Perino told reporters that she "wouldn't rule out that there were a potential 5 million emails lost" by the White House. And three days later, on April 16, she told reporters, "We are aware that there could have been some emails that were not automatically archived because of a technical issue."
While Perino's statements stop short of directly confirming the problem, an August 30, 2007 letter (PDF) from Representative Henry Waxman, the chair of the House oversight committee, to Fred Fielding, the White House counsel, sheds more light on the situation. Waxman wrote:
On May 29, 2007, Keith Roberts, the Deputy General Counsel of the White House Office of Administration, and Emmet Flood, Special Counsel to the President, briefed Committee staff on the White House e-mail system and the missing e-mails. At the briefing, Mr. Roberts informed Committee staff that the White House had discovered in 2005 that an unknown number of e-mails may not have been preserved in the White House archive, as required by the Presidential Records Act.
Fratto's comments today certainly drew the attention of Waxman's committee today, which, noting that "statements made at today’s White House press briefing contradict information provided to the Committee," scrambled to schedule a February 15 hearing to investigate White House compliance with the Presidential Records Act. Called to testify are Fred Fielding; Alan Swendiman, the director of the White House Office of Administration; and Allen Weinstein, the head of the National Archives, which is responsible for preserving presidential records.
In the coming weeks, congressional pressure could start to clarify matters. In mid-December, Waxman sent another letter (PDF) to Fielding, this one requesting "any documents relating to potential failures to archive or maintain Executive Office of the President e-mails during the Bush Administration, including documents discussing options for restoring or recovering lost e-mails." The White House has until February 1 to comply. House oversight spokeswoman Karen Lightfoot told me last night that she expects the administration will hand over the documents. If that happens, we'll know a lot more about what the administration knew about the missing emails and when it knew it. Lightfoot didn't drop any hints, but if the White House refuses Waxman's request, don't be surprised if a sternly-worded letter turns into a sternly-worded subpoena.

Comments
人材派遣人材派遣・業務請負・紹介予定派遣を利用するお仕事をお探しの方のお仕事情報サイト美容学校 "データ復元,データデータ 復旧,データ復活,データ修復,データ救出,修理,故障,回復,消失,トラブル,リカバリ,パソコン,サーバー,ハードディスク,HDD,RAID,NAS"東京都江東区にあるダイビングプロショップ「ル・ポワソン」。ダイビングスクール、ファンダイビング等、各種イベントを開催。医師募集・看護師求人|医師の募集、看護師の求人ならMedical Messiah カラーコーディネーター ウォーキング インストラクター スクールマンスリー 東京特許事務所会社設立SSL SecureStageで販売しているSSL証明書はGeoTrust社からお客様へと、ダイレクトに送信致します。格安 レンタカーJネットレンタカーグループの公式サイトアトピーアトピー/アトピーの事ならCreation Life防犯カメラ監視カメラ、窓対策、ドア対策、SNS周辺対策、セキュリティーなど商品説明ウィークリーマンション新橋 浜松町 品川 大崎 五反田 目黒. 渋谷 新宿 高田馬場 池袋 日暮里 上野 秋葉原 神田 六本木 赤坂 四谷 大森 蒲田 大井町 三田マンスリーマンション 東京マンスリーマンション 東京/東京 港区でマンスリーマンションを選ぶならアーバンホームズ就職ナビ広告業界マスコミ,就職,就職情報,就職活動,求人,広告,広告代理店,広告就職ナビ2009,マスメディアン,massmedian"カラコンTealla~デカ目カラーコンタクトの激安通販治験・臨床試験(新薬・市販薬・健康食品・医療器具)、パッチテストなどにおける医学ボランティア(モニター)の募集・紹介情報サイトマンスリーマンションアンチエイジング 化粧品人材派遣特許事務所会社設立携帯電話 マッスルトレーナーウォーキングシューズウォーキングシューズマッスルトレーナー担当者のメッセージウォーキングサウナスーツ「私も履いています!」「私のウォーキングのマストアイテムです!キャッシング ウコン 有料老人ホーム永代供養永代供養 永代供養永代供養墓,川口,埼玉県,墓,実相寺,宝珠之碑,宝珠,宝珠の碑,領家,日蓮宗納骨堂深妙寺,納骨壇,永代供養,先祖供養,檀家,江戸川区,平井 弁理士ビザSE 転職コンタクトレンズフランス語フランス語,スピードラーニング,フランス,教材,言葉
Posted by: yu on 01/17/08 at 5:41 PM Respond
This administration has proven over and over that they will lie through their teeth whenever it is beneficial to their personal agendas. They have never been held accountable for the hundreds of lies in the past, why would they change their tactic now?
This is the most corrupt and criminal administration I have ever seen. And they are made even more dangerous by a congress that is impotent and lacks the courage to stand up to them. This country is in terrible trouble.
Posted by: Lab3434 on 01/17/08 at 9:25 PM Respond
I'm not sure what all the fuss is about. Given the way these people operate, surely we didn't expect that they would leave us evidence of deliberately breaking a law, did we?
The only thing that surprises me about BushInc is that as far as I know, they haven't had anyone killed yet, but correct me if I'm wrong on that.
-Wexler
Posted by: William W. Wexler on 01/18/08 at 8:29 AM Respond
"haven't had anyone killed yet"
If all humans count - thousands of our brave and best - tens if not hundreds of thousands of Iraqis and Afghanistans.
That is without any regard for the deadly domestic policies.
Posted by: capt on 01/18/08 at 8:35 AM Respond
Can't disagree with you there, capt... he's a homocidal maniac when it comes to foreign policy and his domestic policies cost lives as well.
However, I was referring to something more along the line of a contract killing.
-Wexler
Posted by: William W. Wexler on 01/18/08 at 10:30 AM Respond
Perhaps the appropriate sculpture outside the GWB Library would be a giant reproduction of a Fabre-Castelli eraser, along with enpty shelves inside, of course.
Posted by: Galt on 01/18/08 at 12:27 PM Respond
Impeachment is the only answer.
Posted by: John Schroeder on 01/18/08 at 12:41 PM Respond
Addenda to Wm. Wexler letter. Let's not forget all those people (ours and theirs)in Iraq. They had them murdered didn't they?
Posted by: Roger F. Crawford on 01/18/08 at 1:15 PM Respond
What's your point?
:)
Posted by: Mike on 01/18/08 at 1:58 PM Respond
ATTN: MIKE
Are you on drugs? What's your point???
Posted by: Christopher Flynn on 01/18/08 at 2:21 PM Respond
No, Galt, the appropriate sculpture outside the GWB Library should be a HUGE phallus. Every time he screamed
'9/11!!!' everybody in America bent over. Perhaps the caption under the sculpture should be...
'In the Name of Freedom, They never asked for K-Y Jelly!'
Posted by: steppenRazor on 01/18/08 at 4:02 PM Respond
If I'm wrong sue me, but the post by Yu, above, appears to be either a spam post or a very personal blog entry -- talk of diving, cosmetology, and burial, but nothing to do with this forum (I used web-tranlation softw).
To the point, no actual thinking being can now be expecting to hear the truth, from the Perpetrator Administration. The only logical choice is over which lie is more revealing. In the current case, they made a tactical error by letting us know that any emails were missing in the first place.
Of course that was in response to a request for some emails, to show who was in on deliberations regarding the firing of the US Attorneys (remember them?). Naturally they thought, "Hey, we'll tell 'em we pushed the delete button by mistake! And while we're at it, there are all these OTHER incriminating emails we could do without, too!" So they rolled out the story about mistakenly deleting hundreds of emails, forgetting how hard it is to actually lose an email, if a semi-competent professional is really looking for it, in the Executive Branch's legally-mandated cache of backup disks.
Now that they've had their noses rubbed in that fact (who knew?), they have a choice of fall-back stories. They could say that there ARE no backups -- oops, that wouldn't carry very well, in terms of basic competence and respect for law. Or they could say that all of the copies were accidently deleted AND THEN the backup disks were mistakenly dropped into a disk-shredder, but that might be just a few too many coincidences. Some scapegoat would have to be fired for emailing with their elbows. Or they could come clean and hand over the emails they said were deleted.....Nah!
But hey, there's always reality redefinition -- remember when the Shrub tried to change the public's programming ex-post-facto, by claiming that he'd never urged us to "Stay The Course" in Iraq? Well that didn't play, because too many people were paying attention the first time. But now it's different. No one's really keeping track of the lies anymore, so who's going to notice, if they change one of the whoppers they've already told?
Too bad about Dana Perino, who has to be made to look as if SHE told the first lie (she must have an unknown grudge against the prexy, to make up something so hateful!). But Presidential Spokespersons are basically disposable now anyway, since they get stuck telling the Shrub's lies for him, and eventually are forced to retire and write bitter memoirs of betrayal.
This might sound transparently ridiculous to you and I, but remember that thirty percent of American citizens still believe Bush's lies -- and when he changes his story they believe the new version just as they believed the old one. They've had lots of practice, to be sure, trying to make sense of the Bible's internal inconsistencies. These folks can believe that homosexuals should be forgiven -- at the very same time that they should also be stoned to death for doing what they've been forgiven for! Worshiping a schizophrenic God has put these voters in great shape for supporting this President.
However you frame it, we have an epidemic of incompetent (say it with me, children: "STUPID") citizens in our democracy. As much as anything, this is an important lesson to remember, even after this failed presidency retires to the shadows.
---------
Kill your TV, and free your mind.
Posted by: Dan Mortenson on 01/18/08 at 5:04 PM Respond
Can you just imagine the fury of the right wing if Bill Clinton had pulled this kind of crap?
Posted by: adp3d on 01/18/08 at 10:49 PM Respond
Suggest we flood Speaker Nancy Pelosi's website or e-mail with Demands that Impeachment proceedings begin immediately.
She has delayed this process long enough. What more does she need to begin impeachment of Bush and Cheney?
If she is unwilling to take action, she should resign and allow a new leader to take charge.
Posted by: Ida Casillas on 01/19/08 at 1:31 AM Respond
We have no way of knowing that any emails are missing, is secret agent code for YOU have know way of knowing ANY emails are there!
Posted by: iggy on 01/19/08 at 11:02 AM Respond
i've applied the same Clinton test to so much of what the Bushies have done. Imagine if the Clinton Administration had outed a CIA operative who was investigating WMDS. Imagine had it been discovered that Clinton had planted a gay male prostitute and escort service operator in the White House Press Corps. Imagine if under Clinton a secret meeting with energy company heads had taken place and a year later energy costs had doubled and tripled while historical profits were being made by the same companies. Imagine if Clinton had subcontracted out almost half of our military operations. Imagine if it came to light that Clinton had conned the Evangelicals like Bushco did with Faith Based Initiative. It boggles the mind and shows the hypocrisy of the Right....
Posted by: jim h on 01/19/08 at 1:31 PM Respond
i wonder what britney is doing?
Posted by: carefulwiththatAXEeugene on 01/19/08 at 3:59 PM Respond
Some people say there's already a"hit list."http://www.sonic.net/~taryfast/destruction.html
Posted by:
kissdskye
on 01/20/08 at 4:10 PM Respond
Isn't it amazing that nowadays you can destroy potential evidence (i.e., millions of e-mails), publicly contradict what your immediate colleagues are saying (i.e., Fratto and Perino) and get away with it? There is no leadership in the absence of moral courage, and this is a country bereft of any moral courage.
Posted by: Ed Leward on 01/21/08 at 10:54 AM Respond
Yeah, so WHEN Bush doesn't hand over the documents and WHEN he refuses to comply with the subpeona (because that's what always happens), will Congress finally hold him in contempt, unlike all the other times when they chickened out? Hmmm, smells like it's impeachment time.
Posted by: Rosemary on 01/21/08 at 12:09 PM Respond
Lost emails aren't really lost. Let me explain: Imagine a bunch of road signs along the highway are cut down. They fall into the gutter, not lost just out of sight. It's the same with emails which can be retrieved with the right software. Tell that to the Whitehouse staffers and watch their artificial tans vanish in seconds.
Posted by: lou on 01/21/08 at 7:01 PM Respond
I should say that Pelosi isn't impeaching Bush for two good reasons:
1. she knows that, even if she could push the bill of impeachment through the House (not a sure thing, I hate to tell you), it wouldn't pass in the Senate
2. there are other things (like winding the war in Iraq, or seeing if some of the past republican-passed idiot laws can be gotten rid of) that she has a chance of doing if she doesn't waste the House's time on this sort of pointless effort. remember: W has less than a year before we get to see him ride into the sunset (hopefully he'll ride out in front of a speeding 18 wheeler, but hope does not spring eternal there). let him be remembered for what he is" a fraud, failure and liar. impeach him and his supporters get to make it all into a "witch hunt" and him a hero. do you *really* want that for W??
Posted by: andrew on 01/22/08 at 4:52 PM Respond
Do you for one minute think that there will be impeachment hearings? Over the dead bodys of the Democratic leadership. What a joke.
Posted by: John on 01/23/08 at 12:55 PM Respond
"Technical Issue?" This administration has had technical issues since it entered power in 2001! The lack of Congressional counterweight is a Constitutional concern. The "loss" of emails is another indication for this administration's lack of concern for integrity and transparency. What do they have to hide? A lot. It is the responsibility of the press to keep tabs on those in power, and it too in large part has failed. Democracy as we knew it is under threat of being legislated away to the likes of the Patriot Act and general indifference.
Posted by: Chris Santos on 01/26/08 at 8:56 PM Respond
ARCHIVE
January 20, 2008 - January 26, 2008
January 13, 2008 - January 19, 2008
January 6, 2008 - January 12, 2008
December 30, 2007 - January 5, 2008
December 23, 2007 - December 29, 2007
December 16, 2007 - December 22, 2007
December 9, 2007 - December 15, 2007
December 2, 2007 - December 8, 2007
November 25, 2007 - December 1, 2007
November 18, 2007 - November 24, 2007
November 11, 2007 - November 17, 2007
November 4, 2007 - November 10, 2007
October 28, 2007 - November 3, 2007
October 21, 2007 - October 27, 2007
October 14, 2007 - October 20, 2007
October 7, 2007 - October 13, 2007
September 30, 2007 - October 6, 2007
September 23, 2007 - September 29, 2007
September 16, 2007 - September 22, 2007
September 9, 2007 - September 15, 2007
September 2, 2007 - September 8, 2007
August 26, 2007 - September 1, 2007
August 19, 2007 - August 25, 2007
August 12, 2007 - August 18, 2007
August 5, 2007 - August 11, 2007
July 29, 2007 - August 4, 2007
RECENT COMMENTS
White House: What Missing Emails? (24)
Chris Santos wrote:
"Technical Issue?" This administration has had technical i...
[more]
South Carolina's Lasting Impact (5)
Sean Cobb wrote:
Obama is, indeed, a better orator than Reagan, by quite a ...
[more]
What's Next for (Bill) Clinton and the Anti-Obama Attack Machine? (1)
Contrabass wrote:
Come on,Corn. Do you really need to pussyfoot around Bill...
[more]
Happy 2008! Your Prius' Fuel Efficiency Just Dropped 16% (9)
Kent Johnson wrote:
My parents taught me a respect for the law. This country ...
[more]
Obama Wins South Carolina; Plus, Bill's Jesse Jackson Comparison (1)
Tanisha R wrote:
Yikes is right. Look, I know that there has been a lot of...
[more]
What Saddam Learned From George H.W. Bush (1)
chuck wrote:
The US as "world policeman" in a very jingloistic sense. S...
[more]
"Mr. Ten Percent:" Bhutto's Party Picks Her Widower, Son as Successor (5)
James wrote:
All corrupt polititions should be packaged into a containe...
[more]
Attorney General John Edwards? (2)
Enver Torres wrote:
Any of the three will be great in key roles in a new admin...
[more]
Saddam Gambled And Lost, Says FBI Agent (4)
fastfood wrote:
Saddom played a stupid game of cat and mouse and lost his....
[more]
"The Man's" Morse Code and the Continuing Blight of White Racism (54)
Sharon Ash wrote:
to gtash: Obama wants what most everyone wants who goes i...
[more]
Movable Type 3.33


RECENT ENTRIES
Clinton Campaign Keeps On Pushing Bogus Rationale
More on McCain's Climate Change Speech Today
China Outlaws Pringles and Fanta
The Weird McCain-Dictator Connection
Bob Barr Throws Down Gauntlet to Ron Paul
Obama-McCain Could Create Some Fun Moments
McCain Portrays Himself as Environmental Champion, but Record Undercuts Credibility
"Sacking" of Washington Mid East Hand Points Up Growing Rift Between D.C. Ideology and Israeli Pragmatism
Harry Reid Promises Hearings on Pentagon Puppets