MOTHER JONES BY E-MAIL

«--Previous Post | Blog Index | Next Post--»

The Three Trillion Dollar War

freedom-isn%27t-free.jpg

The Bush administration has spent a lot of money in Iraq since White House economic adviser Lawrence Lindsey was fired in 2002 for daring to predict the war might cost as much as $200 billion. An estimate issued last August by the Congressional Budget Office suggested the war will have cost at least $1 trillion before it's over. A September report (PDF) by the Democratic staff of Congress's Joint Economic Committee pegged the cost at $1.3 trillion. Now a new book by a Harvard professor and a Nobel Prize winner in economics claims the true cost could be more than twice that—as high as $3 trillion dollars. If you wanted to pay that off with a single wad of $1,000 bills, your billfold would have to be almost 240 miles wide.

In The Three Trillion Dollar War, Nobel Prize winner Joseph Stiglitz and Harvard's Linda Bilmes claim to have laid out the "true cost of the Iraq conflict." Instead of simply including appropriations costs and the estimated costs for the future care of soldiers, as most estimates do, Stiglitz and Bilmes take many other factors into account. They include the costs of paying the interest on the money we've borrowed to finance the war; the increased costs of recruiting and retaining soldiers given the fact there is a war on; the macroeconomic costs, like part of the increase in the cost of oil and the lost economic productivity from spending the money overseas instead of reinvesting it at home; and the cost to the economy of the loss of the dead and the seriously wounded and their caretakers, using a metric called a "Valued Statistical Life."

All this sounds very complicated, and it is. Some will certainly question Bilmes and Stiglitz's calculations. But arguing over the exact cost of the war won't change the fact that defense spending is very high in historical terms. In constant 2008 dollars, this year's military budget is the highest since World War II. And the U.S. military is spending millions of dollars a day in Iraq.

Even so, the financial cost is just one factor that Americans have to consider in deciding whether the war was, and is, worth fighting. The cost in lives and the geopolitical and strategic costs are also serious considerations. The cost in lives is, in some ways, easier to quantify and understand than the cost in dollars. And Americans who read the newspaper (or MotherJones.com) see the geopolitical costs of the war every day. So even if the difference between "an unimaginable amount of money" and "a twice as unimaginable amount of money" seems abstract or silly to you, Bilmes has a point. Speaking at the National Press Club Wednesday, she said: "The bottom line on all of this is if the public is trying to make a decision about whether the benefit of staying in Iraq is worth the money they ought to have an accurate price of what it is costing.... If this war costs significantly more than the administration says it does, then we have a responsibility to say, 'Well actually, this is the cost."






Comments

This is good

Only three trillion?

Lindsey thinks its MAY be seven times that.

Posted by: Ya Know... on 02/13/08 at 10:43 PM  Respond

What is our objective in Iraq that is worth the cost at home in terms of Child Health Care, Universal Health Care, Hydroelectric generators on the Ohio and other rivers? What are we fighting for that is worth the lives we are losing or ruining? What are we protecting besides Bush's place in history?
-jack houston

Posted by: Jack Houston on 02/13/08 at 11:51 PM  Respond

"What is our objective in Iraq"

Think billions in contracts making Defense contractors and private equity companies very wealthy.

The real revolving door is the money. It goes from our pockets as taxes then to the cronies and defense industries then to the politicians that award the (usually no-bid) contracts in the for of political donations.

The door revolves again when those politicians decide who should write the regulations and laws.

Posted by: capt on 02/14/08 at 9:38 AM  Respond

No more wars for Israel. No war on Iran. Free Palestine.

Posted by: Ishmael on 02/16/08 at 10:44 AM  Respond

Thank you

Thank you

Ok

This is good

The Best

Ok

This is best article

Posted by: Coreg on 02/22/08 at 4:06 PM  Respond

thanks

Thank you

ok

Thanks

Thank you for all

the best

this is good

thank you

thanks

thank youf

the best ok

Post a comment





 

RECENT COMMENTS

Hillary's Prayer, Revisited (18)
Zola Daniels wrote: The only way to rid this fascist administration is to rem... [more]

In Open Letter, Journalists Slam ABC Debate (2)
Bill Nigh wrote: Hey People, How many of the "40" journalists do you t... [more]

The Smallness of Our Politics on Display at the ABC Debate (44)
unidiotic wrote: Bill, Give me some substance. Not a sigle idea or viewp... [more]

New "Pro Israel, Pro Peace" Political Group Launches: J Street Hopes to Prod Washington MidEast Policy Towards Center (78)
bozhidar bob balkas wrote: Trollstein. You are a historian who asserts that your writ... [more]

Clinton Bashes Obama's Weathermen Connection, But What About Her Own? (59)
Eddie wrote: David Corn, first rule of journalism, get your facts right... [more]

Prominent Irish Historian: Clinton Is "Silly" To Say She Was Instrumental in Peace Accords (27)
misha wrote: If HR helped bring peace to Ireland then she must've been... [more]

A Feminist Hears a Who (139)
joe wrote: You pushed out a fetus?? what a lovely description of givi... [more]

A Very Serious, Very Thoughtful Debate Live Blog (10)
Jessica wrote: Okay, so here's some substantive commentary, since it was ... [more]

Nebraska Teacher Taken Out Of Classroom For Showing Iraq Documentary (37)
free video wrote: Teachers always seem to take the brunt of things like this... [more]

Black Intelligentsia: Holla If You Hear Obama (87)
norris wrote: It seems as though the obama hating is not going to stop i... [more]

XML RSS Feed

Powered by
Movable Type 3.33

Jail.org - Inmate Search
Criminal records, instant public records & people search & current court records. www.jail.org

U.S. Public Records Search
Search County & State Court Records, Criminal records, Vital and Adoption Records www.PublicRecordsInfo.com

Records.com - People Search
Public Records and Background Checks. Instantly Search Criminal Records, Addresses and Court Records www.Records.com

Court Records & County Records
Find Instant Public Records, Criminal Records as Well as County Property Records Search. www.PublicRecordsIndex.com

















bookIN PRINT

CLICK HERE
for more great reading

headphones IN TUNE
New music every issue

CLICK TO LISTEN


This article has been made possible by the Foundation for National Progress, the Investigative Fund of Mother Jones, and gifts from generous readers like you.

© 2008 The Foundation for National Progress

About Us   Support Us   Advertise   Ad Policy   Privacy Policy   Contact Us   Subscribe   RSS