The Waste-Pickers of Delhi
The original Delhi recyclers have turned garbage into cash for decades. Now, a carbon-credit-generating incinerator may put them out of business.
It's so sad that people can only survive by digging through trash. I really hope they find a way to help these people. Too bad that 'privileged' people all over the world complain about the time it takes to get their coffee, being stuck in traffic, etc. Nex time your steak comes out medium well instead of medium, remember that it will be thrown out because you're so entitled to get whatever you want. Lighten up a little.
People are living in destitution like this to support U.S. freedom [of consumer choice]. They are the [forcibly conscripted] heroes of our [neo]liberty!
I really don't think it's appropriate to lay guilt upon ourselves because people in other countries live in squalor. I didn't choose to be born into this life any more than they chose to be born into theirs.
Given the skyrocketing population growth in so-called 'developing' areas like India, perhaps we could call for birth control education and push for literacy so that these people can pull themselves out of poverty instead of waiting around for handouts.
It is quite a shame that, like in many aspects of the recent spins on the "green" movement, the world bank (our hero) has kindly shown us the wonderful offsets we can obtain from such measures. Interesting how the argument goes, valiantly saving us from a more potent ghg enemy and helping the west feel better about itself in its refusal to abandon destructive ways. I would be curious to know how the CDM postulate could be further extended to the life cycle of the landfilling process. What about all that embedded energy in the materials that are being salvaged? Isn't their reprocessing more economical that extracting raw resources? And wouldn't separate management of the organic waste streams (ok, easier said than done) eliminate or substantially reduce the generation of methane in the anaerobic setting as well as provide benefical compost that could in turn provide nutrients to help them grow their own food? The point is there are way better possible manners to deal with this issue than incinerating. That is not to say that letting people fester in squalor is acceptable, but taking away the only thing they have that allows them to survive while claiming the way of doing it is an acceptable emissions reduction measure is preposterous.
This may seem like a quibble to some, but incinerators don't "turns trash into electricity." They turn it into smokestack gasses, particulates, and ash that greatly exceed the weight and volume of the waste burned....
Alan Muller
Green Delaware
How ironic, if those kids were sitting in a building, picking through debris for some Wal-mart purpose, you or your buddies would be screaming "sweat shop!" and "boycott Wal-mart!". Hard to take this rag seriously when it's not consistant.
so they rip off the poorest of the poor and shall be on their way to you soon enough to rip off you...................
This sad. they know how to live in amaerican people do this all the time.
We recycle, I recycle.
"Waiting for handouts?" Yes, these untouchables who have been socially outcast for generations and despite their economic disparity have managed to eek out a living by picking up the waste of the more privileged are just "waiting for handouts."
Get a clue. I guarantee if you fell on hard times (real starvation facing hard times, not "I can't afford cable" hard times) you'd be in line at the local food bank or welfare department begging for relief before you'd be picking through trash in a city dump.
Why don’t you save up some cash and buy a plane ticket to New Delhi. I promise you that your entire concept of “poverty” will be completely rearranged and you’ll be grateful that you’ve never known one ounce of the suffering some of those people go through. I know I was.
I rarely respond to responses but yours simply REEKS of the western arrogance born of privilege. No one is making YOU personally responsible, just be humbly grateful that your circumstances in life are a gift that can easily be taken away.
Until you have been to India and seen their ancient ways of life firsthand, you know squat. It is idealistic and callous to blame "these people" for choosing their birth conditions. They are performing an ancient service to survive ~ NOT asking for handouts. It is a shame, but one does what one must do to survive if one is not so privileged as yourself.
Perhaps in your next incarnation you should choose to be born in their circumstances to learn a little compassion and humanity. Or, perhaps Garbage Mountain in the Philippines.
Yes birth control education is a good idea, however, do you propose to let these current people just die as the poor are being killed off in Africa? Progress is not always a good thing when it negatively affects human beings just for dollars.
I imagine you are all for eugenics and that lovely NWO goal of reducing the world population by 80% too. Don't worry, you stand as much chance as the rest of us to survive that one. Where will your facetiousness be then?
In the meantime, it would bode you well to develop a modicum of compassion for the brothers and sisters with whom you share this planet. Otherwise you come across as unbelievably arrogant. Oh, did I mention selfish too?
With a growing population in a world of limited resources, the threat of widespread human deprivation, escalating conflict and war is greater now than ever before.
What if a New Message from God were sent to warn humanity of the grave implications of this threshold, and to ignite the kind of inspired individual action that is necessary now more than ever before?
To Bharati Chaturvedi,Concerning toxic incineration for electricity.
As someone who provides enducation to the waste-pickers; you might want to educate them on the point of law that they are in a perfect position to put together a class action suit against the incineration co. This co. is engaging in informed "reckless endangerment".
Where the Heck is MOSES when you need him
am always concern alll about garbage ,who can make earth cry..
Waste picking is not a human job. Also modern recycling m,ethods would change this. We need a better development for all peoplpe ( http://www.andherihilfe.de ). With kryo- recycling and modern sorting methods they would also lose their dangerous jobs.
http://www.buendnis-zukunft.de/phpBB2/viewtopic.php?t=174



























