«--Previous Post | Blog Index | Next Post--»
Torchwood: A New Approach to Sexuality on TV?
The BBC hit series Torchwood is a spin-off of a spin-off, really: an extension of the new Doctor Who series that is itself only vaguely related to the classic long-running original. Torchwood's creators were apparently inspired by the still-underappreciated Buffy the Vampire Slayer, a show that used elements of fantasy as illustrations of (and counterpoints to) the characters' lives, and on the surface, the shows have a lot in common: Doctor Who attracted fans as much for its winking humor as its geeky sci-fi, and on Buffy, the satire was built in.
Torchwood has also followed in Buffy's footsteps in another way: towards the end of the latter show's run, two of the female characters fell in love, and their relationship evolved into the most fully-realized same-sex couple on television at the time. In Torchwood, a secretive X-Files-type agency is led by a mysterious (and apparently immortal) guy named Captain Jack Harkness, and he's typically courageous and handsome. He also appears to be gay, or at least bi: his romantic entanglements are with men, whether it's the cute office guy or the interstellar co-conspirator.
Having a stereotype-defying gay lead in a series is definitely ground-breaking (even if it is the BBC), and out actor John Barrowman, who portrays Harkness, has become an outspoken advocate of gay causes, and a minor celebrity, in England. But is it a good show? Part of what made Buffy so compelling was the character development, perfectly calibrated to draw us in and then surprise us. While Torchwood has just started its second season, it seems impatient to have it all at once, loading the characters up with drama before we really know who they are. An early episode featured Captain Jack's office love interest betraying everybody at the agency just to help revive a secret robot girlfriend, yet by the next week all seemed to have been forgotten.
If you followed that last sentence, you'll see that actually most of the show's characters evidence bisexuality. In the second episode, a young woman is infected with an alien being that feeds on sexual energy, and both the male and female characters can't help but have a "snog" with her. (Star Trek famously used the alien-taking-over-a-body queer metaphor at least once as well). In fact, "gay" identity isn't really referred to at all in the show, and same-sex hooking-up is treated as matter-of-factly as opposite-sex. It's refreshing, and according to Kinsey, probably closer to the real truth about human sexuality than our current "Queer Eye"-influenced cultural norms. But, honestly, it seems like a bit too much of a leap forward, its vision of a post-sexual-identity world (or, at least, Cardiff) a little unrealistic. On top of that, Jack and the show's female lead, Gwen, appear to have a smoldering attraction for each other, which could turn out to be the show's "Moonlighting"-style central unrequited love relationship, pushing the queer relationships to the margins.
Maybe I'm being too rough on the show's philosophical underpinnings, when it's just supposed to be a bit of campy, B-movie fun. I'll admit, as well, that Captain Jack's makeouts with a WWII-era soldier and a former fling (played by James Marsters, Spike from Buffy, natch) were incredibly hot. Cute guys, spooky aliens, what's not to love, right? And it's easy to forget that the eventually-superb Star Trek: The Next Generation started out awkward and laughable in its first season. But if someone as tolerant for corny sci-fi as me finds himself rolling his eyes at the incredibly silly twists and turns on this show, you know it's got to be stretching it a little thin, and if nobody cares about your characters, they won't care if they're breaking down the boundaries of on-screen sexuality. Nevertheless, Torchwood is a show to keep your eye on.
Torchwood airs
Update: Hey, YouTube, you've got everything, don't you? Watch the Barrowman-Marsters makeout scene below. By the way, why Spike is dressed up like Adam Ant, I have no idea.
Comments
I have watched all the episodes of Torchwood and am a Dr. Who regular. From what I gather, calling Capt. Jack gay or even bi doesn't quite fit him. It has been implied in the series that he loves both male and female and those of an alien persuassion. Not sure what "term" you would use to describe him. He has been to other worlds and other times and may not even be human himself.
Hopefully we will find out more about him as the series progresses and the other members.
I am especially interested to see how the relationship between Gwen and her fiancee goes now that he is in on the secret.
Have you even watched the show fully? You've gotten a lot of the details wrong (or have slightly misquoted what you've seen). And the show is on Saturday night, not Sunday night.
Posted by: T.L.B. on 02/13/08 at 12:22 AM Respond
another American blogger trying to act superior and put down Torchwood.
Posted by: RP on 02/13/08 at 1:52 AM Respond
Oh, and I notice that the right to reply is curbed by a censor on the comments before they are posted. so questioning the bias against the programme is not allowed.
Posted by: RP on 02/13/08 at 1:53 AM Respond
Correction: Torchwood airs Saturday nights on BBC America.
Correction: Jack Harkness isn't bisexual, but omnisexual. In an early TW episode, he refers to human sexual characterizations as "quaint."
While the program may not always appear to be a serial drama (in reference to your complaint that characters seem to embark upon one quest then forget it by next week's episode), that's not entirely true. In my perspective, it appears that character personalities/psychology has been released in small quantities over time w/ large bursts here & there. I rather find that engaging. The way I see it, it keeps the viewer wanting to reurn if indeed he/she finds said character intriguing.
I must say, the show does run the risk of running flat if the current crop of writers fail or leave. But so far, TW has my faith.
Posted by: Ange on 02/13/08 at 3:00 PM Respond
An early episode featured Captain Jack's office love interest betraying everybody at the agency just to help revive a secret robot girlfriend, yet by the next week all seemed to have been forgotten.
No, it wasn't forgotten. Perhaps you expected a piece of dialogue or a conversation about it. This show is about the overt and the subtle. Nothing is ever forgotten and it all carries forward. Ianto feels heartbroken and guilty for his betrayal and for a few episodes after "Cyberwoman," you see that in the way he avoids eye contact with Jack.
In my opinion, your overly high expectations of a show with an "omni" sexual lead and bisexual/straight support characters are keeping you from viewing the content of the episodes and character interaction.
Posted by: Joy on 02/13/08 at 4:29 PM Respond
I just finished watching the first season and was very impressed. The "secret robot girlfriend" was not forgotten, and in fact I was very pleased how all the characters' "indiscretions" throughout the season got out in the open in the last ep of the season. I also felt the actors got a real handle on their characters and roles in the team by the end of the season. I'm looking forward to Season 2!
Posted by: Dee on 02/14/08 at 10:06 AM Respond
1. Whoops - thanks for correcting me about the night of the broadcast. I always watch it on demand on Sundays.
2. As far as the whole "he's not gay or bi, he's an omnisexual alien," okay, fine, you're taking this really seriously, and that's neat. But I did say "appears to be," and until I see him make out with a amorphous blob of gelatinous goo that has no obvious gender, I'm sticking with "bi."
3. We have a bit of a problem with spam so there's a short delay before comments appear.
Posted by: Party Ben on 02/15/08 at 1:12 PM Respond
This show is bound to become a big hit in the U.S. In any case, it will be VERY interesting to see how bible-belt America handles Capt. Harkness omni-sexuality. I can just see mass protests led by televangelists. Arguably, the first omni-sexual ship captain was Capt Kirk. He had sex with aliens...that makes him omnisexual...right?
Posted by: bocanot on 02/19/08 at 11:01 PM Respond
i saw the hole season and i know jack is strait. i mean in docter hwo he loved rose!!!!!!!
Posted by: shadow on 03/05/08 at 8:22 AM Respond
I watch the show in Paris (sorry for my english) and I love it. Your comment is "déplacé", inapropriate, I knew taht you were form USA since I read the first line. Why do you think that the authors thinks in Buffy? I saw Buffy sometimes and I didn't like it, pretending to be profound, but they didn't arrive, just boring for me. (Why do you think that you are the center of the world? Dr. Who is a very very old british show. Torchwood is born of there. Acttually Torchwood is an anaram form Doctor Who (try it). And it’s more near of Dr who that of Buffy. I adore Torchwood, with an excellent and "english" humor, not being a comedy, just here and there, with rythm and intrestings histories, and most of all, this sexual approach, free, without no prejudices. I'm agree with the caracter: we humans have a very schematic vision of the sex, even if I am heterosexual, I can be agree. Omnisexual, that's an excelent definition. But I can see that it's too much advanced for a lot of aericans minds (not all thank god).Here in Europe that doesen’t surprise no one. I wait the nex season avec plaisir.
Posted by: gaby on 09/05/08 at 4:39 PM Respond
ARCHIVE
RECENT COMMENTS
Time Caught in Act of Dumbing Down the News for US Readers (38)
chat wrote:
thanks :)...
[more]
Torchwood: A New Approach to Sexuality on TV? (11)
gaby wrote:
I watch the show in Paris (sorry for my english) and I lov...
[more]
New (Leaked) Music: Beck - Modern Guilt (2)
ava leigh wrote:
Hey have you heard the hottest reggae singer Ava Leigh’s n...
[more]
Barack Obama, Wire Fan (9)
PBLUNT wrote:
With all due respect to the original poster, who is after ...
[more]
Tigh/Roslin Ticket Will Provide Strength and Purpose in Defeating Democrats Cylons (2)
ProgGrrl wrote:
Yeah, frak that indeed... feel free to meme-build away til...
[more]
What's Up With That Tropic Thunder Controversy? (38)
boomhauer wrote:
has anyone found a copy of the original simplejackmovie.co...
[more]
God Understands Irony, A Postscript (12)
Jeff wrote:
I am continually amazed by the vast majority of Americans ...
[more]
Poor McCain, Even Jackson Browne and Mike Myers Are Against Him (1)
North Cyprus wrote:
How you combine all of these usuful information in a uniqu...
[more]
Hillary Clinton's Music Strikes a Minor Chord (4)
Sam wrote:
What was the orchestral music used, does anyone know? It w...
[more]
Slang White People Like (63)
skoob wrote:
I wish I wasn't more than a month late to this posting. M...
[more]
Movable Type 3.33


Posted by: Phil on 02/12/08 at 5:22 PM Respond