MOTHER JONES BY E-MAIL

«--Previous Post | Blog Index | Next Post--»

Hating on Muslims: GOP's Second Debate Same as the First

When the Republicans held their first debate two weeks ago, I was disturbed by the facile interpretations of Islamic terror that they presented. I wrote:

It has always bugged me that these guys misunderstand or understand and then deliberately misrepresent the reasons why certain factions of the Muslim world hate the United States. They don't hate our freedoms. Okay, maybe a tiny number of al Qaeda types do, but the 70 percent of the Islamic world (rough estimate) that currently tells pollsters that they can't stand the U.S. don't hate our freedoms; they hate that we have supported pro-Western dictatorships in their region, they hate that we reliably and sometimes unthinkingly support Israel, and they hate that we invaded a country that posed no threat to us and completely destroyed it.

The more insidious cousin of the "they hate our freedoms" explanation is the "it's in their religion" explanation. When Republicans argue vaguely that Islam orders followers to kill infidels, it amounts to saying the West is at war with Islam, and that our fights in Iraq, in Afghanistan, and in the global war on terror really are a clash of civilizations. (One might even call them a "crusade.") Worse than that, though, is that we lump all Muslims together -- in with Osama bin Laden and his henchmen, we throw millions and millions of peace-loving Muslims who might be convinced that the United States and not their violent, extremist enemies hold the keys to freedom and prosperity.

So when Tom Tancredo said yesterday that al Qaeda is trying to kill us "because it is a dictate of their religion," he needs to know he is doing far more harm than good to our interests. Fueling the sense in the Muslim world that their religion is our enemy -- and not its most wackjob adherents -- makes the prospect of peace in the region all the more dim.






Comments

Ahh. Another apologist. Tell me, should the US just close up and allow whichever tin-plated dictator a crack at governing? Because, if I go by your thinking, the US is the root of all evil in the world. Except that, if such a scenario did occur, none of us would be around to document the event. These 'Oh so misunderstood' muslims would kill every one of us. Not because of our politics or our choice of allies. Hey, we're allies with Russia, sort of, but they don't have a problem with that. Nope, just Israel. Such a tiny little nation to create such furor. If they are all so wonderfully tough, shouldn't they have wiped Israel off the map years ago? Yet, Israel is still there. Food for thought, but careful you don't choke on your disdain for anything American. Look, I'll make it easy. They hate us because we are in their way of world domination. They don't hate just us, really. We're just at the top of the list. Plus, they know they can play on the credulous simplicities of the US media and liberal robots like yourself. Meanwhile, I'm stumping for research on Mars exploration and colonization. I'm moving there as soon as I can. Its the only safe place, really.

Posted by: MrSemprini on 05/16/07 at 11:44 AM  Respond

Ron Paul clearly stated that we are hated because of our foreign policies and occupational forced over seas.

Posted by: Nina on 05/16/07 at 12:00 PM  Respond

Most of the GOP candidates are in the employ of AIPAC. They pay well I hear. This is the nature of politics. Unfortunately, when it influences our foreign policy(neocon Zionists)then we have problems. Remember the Democrats and the GOP Senators both voted for the AIPAC program of reconfiguring Iraq to the appoval of Israel's Likud Party and their allies.
We need to have courage, like President Carter, and stand up to AIPAC's foreign policy and enforcers at home.

Posted by: Hannah F. on 05/16/07 at 12:06 PM  Respond

[Nina wrote: Ron Paul clearly stated that we are hated because of our foreign policies and occupational forced over seas.]

And Ron Paul was right. But as we saw with the Republican operatives in the audience, it is clearly NOT popular to tell it like it really is on THAT point.

I'd venture to say you won't hear many voices among the Democratic candidates saying "Our interventionist policies over the last several decades are what brought it all down on us."
It is not something people who have been at the height of power during that period (nearly ALL the candidates of BOTH parties) want to admit.

Ron Paul is probably the lone exception, having consistently OPPOSED all such interventions during his time in Congress.

I have never voted in a Republican primary election. In 35 years of voting, no Republican running for president has ever gotten my vote.
Ron Paul may well change all that.

Posted by: gvc on 05/16/07 at 2:30 PM  Respond

GVC,

Go beyond foreign policy and take a look at Ron Paul's stances on domestic issues before you decide you are going to support him.

Posted by: Bob on 05/16/07 at 7:14 PM  Respond

The Republican base scares the hell out of me. I am a registered Republican, but wonder what planet these candidates and audience members are from. We're stuck in a war that should've never been waged, and they're calling for more aggressive behavior. If your car is stuck in mud, the solution isn't to accelerate forward like a madman. It might appeal to those who dream of a Jack Bauer president -- but there's clearly a difference between the portion of the electorate that is focused on reality, and the other that imagines enemies.

Posted by: Robert Taft on 05/17/07 at 8:11 AM  Respond

Bob, being of a very libertarian mind myself, I've been following Ron Paul's career for quite some time.

I'm quite satisfied that, as president, Ron Paul would do all he possibly could to prevent government involvement in the daily lives and decisions of American citizens, as well as stopping our government's intervention into the affairs of foreign people.

What more can a Liberty lover ask?

Posted by: gvc on 05/17/07 at 9:43 AM  Respond

I look forward to the day Mr. Semprini moves to Mars. The earth will be a better place for it.

Posted by: Andy on 08/18/07 at 7:37 PM  Respond

Post a comment





 

RECENT COMMENTS

"In the 21st Century, Nations Don't Invade Other Nations" (5)
Show Me wrote: Maybe he though we invaded and occupied Iraq before the gr... [more]

John McCain Has More Odd Things to Say About Russia/Georgia (1)
Franklin Grimes wrote: What I like about the Republicans is how they got war's st... [more]

Partition in Iraq: A Serious Problem With Biden as VP? (28)
Carolyn wrote: I'm going to have to agree with Danny, 'massimo.' Jest cuz... [more]

McCain's Bizarre Undiscovered Foreign Policy Ideas (12)
Drunk Philosopher wrote: To Jim, quote: "The "insightful" Zakaria calls Iran and No... [more]

The Campaign Goes Christian (3)
Sharon wrote: Vote for Ralph Nader for real change. Obama is a hypocrite... [more]

The Rooskies Are Out to Get Us! (6)
Emphyrio wrote: 5. They think it's the state of Georgia where the Atlanta ... [more]

Troops Abroad Give to Obama 6:1 (2)
Jeugenen wrote: LIBERAL OBAMA OR NEO-CON/NEO-LIB MC-CAIN The political st... [more]

Speedo's $600 Swimsuits: Made in America, Bought by China (45)
Brandon wrote: Tech has not gone too far. This is simply another geegaw ... [more]

Why is HHS Secretary Mike Leavitt Blogging About Abortion? (1)
PeaceNick wrote: I think what Secretary Leavitt and the Bush administration... [more]

Under for Fire for Pastor's Remarks, Obama To Give Major Speech on Race (11)
Acomplia wrote: Generic Acomplia is an Anti Obesity Drug that is Best Weig... [more]

XML RSS Feed

Powered by
Movable Type 3.33

Jail.org - Inmate Search
Criminal records, instant public records & people search & current court records. www.jail.org

U.S. Public Records Search
Search County & State Court Records, Criminal records, Vital and Adoption Records www.PublicRecordsInfo.com

Records.com - People Search
Public Records and Background Checks. Instantly Search Criminal Records, Addresses and Court Records www.Records.com

Court Records & County Records
Find Instant Public Records, Criminal Records as Well as County Property Records Search. www.PublicRecordsIndex.com

















Drill, Baby, Drill

Torches and Pitchforks

Quote of the Day

A Prayer For Palin


More MoJo voices...



bookIN PRINT

CLICK HERE
for more great reading

headphones IN TUNE
New music every issue

CLICK TO LISTEN


This article has been made possible by the Foundation for National Progress, the Investigative Fund of Mother Jones, and gifts from generous readers like you.

© 2008 The Foundation for National Progress

About Us   Support Us   Advertise   Ad Policy   Privacy Policy   Contact Us   Subscribe   RSS