Update: What Do Critics Mean Who Say Obamacare "Isn't Liberal Enough"?

| Wed Apr. 9, 2014 1:38 PM EDT

I periodically drone on about the laziness of polls that ask a simple approve/disapprove question about Obamacare. The problem is that a lot of people say they disapprove because Obamacare isn't liberal enough. These are folks don't necessarily disapprove of the concept of national healthcare in general or Obamacare in particular, and shouldn't really be counted among right-wing opponents of the law.

A couple of weeks ago, a Kaiser poll gave us a slightly deeper glimpse into all this. They asked the disapprovers why they disapproved, and it was clear that some of them had lefty criticisms of the law, not conservative criticisms. But the evidence was still a bit fuzzy.

Today, Mark Blumenthal goes further. In a recent HuffPo poll, about 9 percent of the respondents said they opposed Obamacare because it wasn't liberal enough. Then, in a follow-up question, they were asked, "In your own words, what do you mean when you say the health care law is not liberal enough?"

The results are on the right. There's still some ambiguity here, but I'd classify several of the responses as likely left-wing criticisms. Adding up the percentages, I get 6 + 4 + 15 + 4 + 4 + 3 = 36 percent. That's a little less than half of those who had a response.

So, very roughly speaking, in future polls I'd guess that about half of the "not liberal enough" folks are basically supporters of Obamacare but want the law to go further. It might even be more than that, but it remains hard to parse the motivations behind all of these responses with precision. Is "too complex" a liberal or conservative criticism? How about "lack of choice"? Hard to say.

In any case, this adds some context to the whole debate about Obamacare critics who say it's "not liberal enough." It's also an object lesson against assuming too much ideological coherence from survey respondents. A larger survey with a bigger sample size and a little more structure to the questions would be welcome.

Get Mother Jones by Email - Free. Like what you're reading? Get the best of MoJo three times a week.