How Obama Can Make Sure Hobby Lobby’s Female Employees Are Covered

The Supreme Court just gutted the contraceptive mandate. Here’s a workaround.

Jay Mallin/ZUMA

The Supreme Court on Monday blew a hole in an Obamacare provision that required employers to provide employees with contraceptive coverage. Specifically, companies whose owners have religious objections to covering contraception are now off the hook—regardless of whether their objections are based in reality.

So what does this mean for women who work for Hobby Lobby—or one of the 70 other companies that challenged Obamacare’s contraception mandate? The White House is considering whether President Obama can take unilateral action to ensure that they are covered. Health care experts say his administration can cover woman affected by today’s ruling similar to how it currently covers women working for nonprofit, religiously affiliated organizations.

Under the accommodation the federal government has worked out with religious nonprofits, the government waives fines for organizations that do not wish to cover contraception; the organization’s insurer or a third-party plan administrator provides the coverage instead. The cost is borne by the insurer, or in the latter case, the government.

“The obligation to provide [contraception] is technically on the insurers,” explains Timothy Jost, who runs Health Affairs Blog. “It’s just the government’s preference that the employers administer the coverage.”

Using the same workaround, the government can ensure that employees of companies such as Hobby Lobby still get the contraception coverage they are entitled to under the Affordable Care Act, says Sara Rosenbaum, chair of the health policy school at George Washington University. “The only difference is that the employer is not exposed to the cost,” she says.

Jost notes: “I don’t see any reason why [the Obama administration] couldn’t do it this way. The Supreme Court more or less told them to do it, or strongly suggested they do it.”

Indeed, the five justices who ruled in favor of Hobby Lobby made the accommodation a key piece of their decision. “HHS has…effectively exempted religious nonprofit organizations with religious objections to providing coverage for contraceptive services,” the court noted in its opinion. The justices suggested extending that exemption, which “does not impinge on the plaintiff’s religious beliefs.”

The cost of closing the coverage gap will fall to insurance companies, and in limited cases, the federal government. Jost estimates that most closely held companies, which tend to be small, are not self-insured. When one of those firms opts out, the cost of covering its employees’ contraceptives will fall to the company’s insurer. If a company that provides its own insurance declines to cover contraception, the company’s third-party plan administrator will offer contraception coverage. In compensation, the federal government will then waive some of the taxes the plan administrator would have paid to support the federal health care exchanges.

Rosenbaum says the existence of the religious nonprofit exemption, which has been upheld by several federal courts, helped doom the contraception mandate.

“There were very powerful arguments as to why corporations should not be allowed to put their employees’ benefits aside,” says Rosenbaum. “It’s a very unfortunate decision.” But, she adds, the government never made a convincing argument for why it couldn’t simply make the same accommodation for Hobby Lobby that it did for nonprofits such as the University of Notre Dame. “It was one of the weaknesses in the government’s arguments all along…and the Supreme Court seized on that.”


One More Thing

And it's a big one. Mother Jones is launching a new Corruption Project to do deep, time-intensive reporting on the corruption that is both the cause and result of the crisis in our democracy.

The more we thought about how Mother Jones can have the most impact right now, the more we realized that so many stories come down to corruption: People with wealth and power putting their interests first—and often getting away with it.

Our goal is to understand how we got here and how we might get out. We're aiming to create a reporting position dedicated to uncovering corruption, build a team, and let them investigate for a year—publishing our stories in a concerted window: a special issue of our magazine, video and podcast series, and a dedicated online portal so they don't get lost in the daily deluge of headlines and breaking news.

We want to go all in, and we've got seed funding to get started—but we're looking to raise $500,000 in donations this spring so we can go even bigger. You can read about why we think this project is what the moment demands and what we hope to accomplish—and if you like how it sounds, please help us go big with a tax-deductible donation today.

We Recommend


Sign up for our newsletters

Subscribe and we'll send Mother Jones straight to your inbox.

Get our award-winning magazine

Save big on a full year of investigations, ideas, and insights.


Support our journalism

Help Mother Jones' reporters dig deep with a tax-deductible donation.