Harvey Milk’s Medal of Freedom Sparks Protest—In San Francisco

by flickr user Stewf used under the Creative Commons licesnse

Get your news from a source that’s not owned and controlled by oligarchs. Sign up for the free Mother Jones Daily.


In Washington, no one blinked when President Obama chose Harvey Milk, the slain San Francisco councilman and gay rights activist, to receive the Medal of Freedom. But in San Francisco, one man did.  

His name is Randy Thomasson, and he heads the conservative policy watchdog Save California. On Wednesday, the group held a press conference outside San Francisco City Hall to protest the honor, spitting distance from where Milk was assasinated in 1978. Using a series of visual aids, Thomasson argued that the civil rights crusader was unfit for the nation’s highest civilian honor. 

“Is this for the Onion? Come on, this must be for the Onion,”  a casual observer announced to no one in particular.  

That pretty much sums it up. Of the 16 recipients of the Medal of Freedom today—among them Stephen Hawking and Sidney Poitier—perhaps none is more artificially controversial than Milk, whose life and work inspired last year’s Oscar-nominated film. Sure, California’s enjoyed it’s fair share ofreal gay controversy this past year (Prop 8, anyone?). But nothing stokes artificial controversy like TV news cameras. 

 

In a city where every third public building and charity breakfast is named for Milk, the conference was well attended by the local press. All in all, a half dozen showed up, along with a couple of photographers and another ten reporters, who flanked the camera-ready Thomasson and his posse. 

“I’m always curious who’s exercising their right to assembly,” said Steven Tritto, an observer who had stepped out to give his maltese Gusto a breather while he waited for a friend at a job interview. “And I’m always interested in who’s getting attention from the media.”

Others were less diplomatic. 

“They’re honoring a man. It’s just like honoring Caesar Chavez. Caeser wasn’t perfect,” said Dan Barber, a gay denizen of the city for more than 30 years. “Was Jesus Christ perfect?” 

 

In addition to protesting Milk’s Medal of Freedom, Thomasson is also fighting a proposed Harvey Milk Day in California schools, and the “sexual indoctrination of kindergarteners.” He told CBS and MSNBC that the president had made “a mistake” by honoring Milk, one he was anxious  that Gov. Arnold Shwarzenegger not repeat.

“Harvey Milk ‘Gay’ Day will rope school children into confusion,” he said, adding that honoring Milk in California’s public schools “would promote the homosexual-bisexual-transsexual agenda…to up to six million children.” 

Heaven forbid.  

Take the next step: Help us fight for the truth.

Investigative journalism, like the story you just read, takes time to do. Months of research. Weeks of writing, editing, and fact checking—and putting together the photography, art, video, and audio that tell the stories in a new way, illuminating new perspectives and voices.

We can afford to take that time because we don’t report to an oligarch or corporation with a special agenda. We report to you, and for you. That’s why we unabashedly pursue the truth and relentlessly shine a light into the darkness.

In this month’s Summer Membership Drive, we’ve got to raise $200,000 to support more crucial investigations. This is a pivotal moment in our nation, with democracy on the line, and we can only do this work because readers like you step up. Every donation, of any amount, makes a difference here. We cannot do this work without you.

So, we’re asking: Will you support independent journalism that demands those in power answer for their actions?

Take the next step: Help us fight for the truth.

Investigative journalism, like the story you just read, takes time to do. Months of research. Weeks of writing, editing, and fact checking—and putting together the photography, art, video, and audio that tell the stories in a new way, illuminating new perspectives and voices

We can afford to take that time because we don’t report to an oligarch or corporation with a special agenda. We report to you, and for you. That’s why we unabashedly pursue the truth and relentlessly shine a light into the darkness.

In this month’s Summer Membership Drive, we’ve got to raise $200,000 to support more crucial investigations. This is a pivotal moment in our nation, with democracy on the line, and we can only do this work because readers like you step up. Every donation, of any amount, makes a difference here. We cannot do this work without you.

So, we’re asking: Will you support independent journalism that demands those in power answer for their actions?

We Recommend

Latest

Sign up for our free newsletter

Subscribe to the Mother Jones Daily to have our top stories delivered directly to your inbox.

Get our award-winning magazine

Save big on a full year of investigations, ideas, and insights.

Subscribe

INDEPENDENT. BECAUSE OF YOU.

Mother Jones has no billionaires calling the shots—just readers like you making fearless reporting possible

Donate